Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Shunt trip breakers

User: Noppe, Location: Jackson, Missouri

Asked on: Thursday, November 14, 2024 at 3:03 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:13 am EST

Question: Has anyone found anything in code about using shunt trip breakers for heat trace in a Class 1 div 2 area on a natural gas compressor station?

Okay, let's break down the potential code issues with using shunt trip breakers for heat trace in a Class 1 Div 2 area on a natural gas compressor station, and where to look for relevant information.

The Core Issues

The primary concern revolves around explosion protection and safety in a hazardous location. Class 1 Div 2 areas contain flammable gases or vapors that could be present under abnormal operating conditions. You need to ensure that any electrical equipment used in this area is designed and installed to minimize the risk of ignition.Here's why shunt trip breakers, specifically, raise questions:

Shunt Trip Coil Sparking

The shunt trip coil itself, when energized or de-energized, can potentially create a spark. This spark could be an ignition source if it's not properly contained or if the breaker is not rated for use in a Class 1 Div 2 area.


Wiring and Connections

The wiring and connections to the shunt trip coil must also be suitable for the hazardous location. Improperly sealed or protected connections could allow flammable gases to come into contact with energized parts.

Maintenance and Testing

Shunt trip breakers need periodic testing to ensure they function correctly. Maintenance procedures in a Class 1 Div 2 area need to be carefully controlled to minimize the risk of ignition.

Relevant Codes and Standards (Focus on North America, primarily the US NEC)


NFPA 70: National Electrical Code (NEC)

This is the primary code governing electrical installations in the US.


Article 500-505

These articles cover hazardous (classified) locations. Specifically, Article 501 addresses Class I locations.

501.10(B): Wiring Methods

Specifies acceptable wiring methods for Class I, Division 2 locations. Generally, you'll be looking at options like rigid metal conduit (RMC), intermediate metal conduit (IMC), or types of cable specifically listed for Class I, Division 2 (e.g., Type TC-ER with suitable glands/fittings). Sealing requirements are critical.


501.15 Sealing

This section dictates where seals are required in conduit runs to prevent the passage of gases, vapors, or dusts. This is crucial to maintaining the integrity of the hazardous area classification.

501.125(B) Circuit Breakers

Most relevant! This part of the code addresses the requirements for circuit breakers in Class 1 Div 2 locations. It generally allows the use of circuit breakers if they are one of the following:

Listed for Class 1 Div 2

This is the easiest path. If the breaker itself is listed for Class I, Division 2 (or better, like explosion-proof), it's generally acceptable if installed according to the listing.

Enclosed in an enclosure identified for Class 1 Div 2

This means putting a standard breaker inside a specifically designed and listed enclosure (e.g., an explosion-proof enclosure or a purged and pressurized enclosure).


Intrinsically Safe system Using a shunt trip relay that operates at intrinsically safe levels.

Article 427: Electric Heat Tracing and Heating Systems

This article provides specific requirements for heat tracing systems, including overcurrent protection.


427.22 Overcurrent Protection

Specifies requirements for overcurrent protection of heat tracing circuits. This will tie into the selection and application of the circuit breaker.

427.56 Control and Safety Devices Should be reviewed for proper installation of all components used to control heat trace systems.2.

NFPA 496: Standard for Purged and Pressurized Enclosures for Electrical Equipment

If you're considering using a purged and pressurized enclosure for the shunt trip breaker, this standard provides detailed requirements for design, installation, and maintenance. This is a more complex and often more expensive solution.3.

Other Standards



ISA (International Society of Automation)

ISA standards provide guidance on instrumentation and control systems in hazardous locations. Look for ISA 12.12.01 (Nonincendive Electrical Equipment for Use in Class I and II, Division 2 and Class III, Divisions 1 and 2 Hazardous (Classified) Locations) and related standards.

UL (Underwriters Laboratories)

UL standards are used for testing and listing electrical equipment. Look for UL 698A (Industrial Control Panels Relating to Hazardous (Classified) Locations).

Key Considerations and Steps


Hazardous Area Classification

Confirm the area classification is correct! Make sure the Class 1 Div 2 designation is accurate and properly documented by a qualified professional.2.

Equipment Listing

The best-case scenario is to find a shunt trip breaker (or a complete breaker assembly with shunt trip) that is specifically listed for Class 1 Div 2. This simplifies the installation and inspection process. Check the manufacturer's documentation carefully.3.

Enclosure

If a listed breaker isn't available, using an enclosure listed for Class 1 Div 2 is the next best approach. The enclosure must be properly sealed and installed according to the manufacturer's instructions and the NEC.4.

Wiring and Sealing

Pay meticulous attention to wiring methods and sealing requirements. Use approved fittings and seal-offs to prevent the migration of flammable gases.5.

Intrinsic Safety

Consider using intrinsically safe shunt trip circuits. This isolates the hazardous area from the energy levels that could cause ignition. This generally involves using an intrinsically safe barrier and a low-energy shunt trip coil.6.

Documentation

Maintain thorough documentation of all equipment, installation procedures, and hazardous area classifications.7.

Qualified Personnel

Ensure that all design, installation, and maintenance work is performed by qualified personnel who are familiar with hazardous location requirements.8.

Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)

Consult with the local electrical inspector or other AHJ to get their approval on the proposed installation. They have the final say.

Example Scenario

Let's say you need to use a shunt trip breaker to de-energize a heat tracing circuit if a high temperature is detected. Here's a potential approach:


Option 1 (Preferred)

Use a Class 1 Div 2 listed circuit breaker with a shunt trip coil.

Option 2

Install a standard circuit breaker with a shunt trip coil inside an explosion-proof enclosure listed for Class 1 Div 2. Run all wiring to the enclosure in rigid metal conduit with explosion-proof fittings and seals.


Option 3

Use an intrinsically safe shunt trip system. This would involve an intrinsically safe temperature transmitter, an intrinsically safe barrier, and a low-energy shunt trip relay.

In summary, using shunt trip breakers in Class 1 Div 2 areas is possible, but it requires careful consideration of the hazardous area requirements and strict adherence to the NEC and other relevant standards. Always prioritize safety and consult with qualified professionals to ensure a safe and compliant installation. Look specifically at NEC Article 501.125(B) and related sections. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question