User: fastline, Location: midwest usa
Asked on: Thursday, November 14, 2024 at 4:51 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:14 am EST
Question: Firstly, can anyone put any clarity in any difference between MC/BX/AC? The only thing we have ever used is MC, with ground, and indoor only, either in commercial walls or similar.I don't know if the BX/AC is identical other than conductor types, thickness of jacket, etc? We are looking to use flex in some OH lighting in buildings, and would like to clamp in the top edge of Ibeams so it is well protected.As well, I will admit that every time I use MC, I cuss like mad because the stupid bushings and connectors do not protect the conductors worth a damn so extreme caution is needed. Does anyone make good and proper MC bushings that actually do something?I can tell you it got bad enough that on some non-permit work, we resorted to adding sleeves over the conductors we can work with it with more confidence.
Okay, let's break down the differences between MC, BX, and AC cable, and then discuss options for improving your MC cable terminations.
Understanding MC, BX, and AC Cable
The primary difference between these cable types lies in their construction, grounding provisions, and application: MC (Metal-Clad Cable)
This is the most common and versatile of the three.
Construction
MC cable consists of insulated conductors (typically THHN/THWN-2) bundled together and wrapped in a flexible metallic sheath (aluminum or steel). It ALWAYS contains a separate insulated green grounding conductor.
Grounding
The insulated green grounding conductor provides a dedicated path for fault current, making it safer. The metallic sheath also provides a secondary grounding path, but the separate ground wire is the primary safety feature.
Applications
MC cable is suitable for a wide range of uses, including: Branch circuits Feeders Services (with proper listing and use) Concealed or exposed installations Dry locations Embedded in plaster finish on brick or other masonry (with limitations).
Advantages
Relatively easy to install compared to conduit. Flexible. Provides a good degree of mechanical protection. Dedicated grounding conductor. The metallic sheath is suitable as a ground.
Important Note
It is suitable as a ground, in addition to the ground wire, it is not a replacement for the ground wire.
AC (Armored Cable)
AC cable is older technology that is now less popular than MC. "BX" is a generic term for AC Cable.
Construction
AC cable (often called "BX") consists of insulated conductors wrapped in paper and then enclosed in a flexible metallic sheath. It has a
bonding strip in contact with the metal sheath. It does not have a separate insulated green grounding conductor. Grounding
The grounding path relies on the metallic sheath and the bonding strip inside the cable. The bonding strip ensures a low-impedance path for fault current back to the source.
Applications
Dry locations only. Concealed or exposed installations. Branch circuits and feeders.
Disadvantages
Less reliable grounding path than MC cable. The sheath can become compromised over time, increasing resistance and potentially creating a fire hazard. Can be more difficult to work with than MC cable. The paper insulation can become brittle over time. NEC restricts it's uses in comparison to MC
In Summary AC (BX) uses the armor itself as a ground in conjunction with a bonding strip, where MC uses a separate insulated green ground wire, but also the armor is suitable as a ground.
Use of Flex in Overhead Lighting
Yes, you can use flexible metal conduit (FMC) or liquidtight flexible metal conduit (LFMC) for overhead lighting applications. MC cable can also be used if you want to provide additional protection to the conductors inside. FMC (Flexible Metal Conduit)
Often referred to as "flex." It's a hollow, flexible metallic raceway. You must pull individual wires (typically THHN/THWN) through it. It can be used in dry locations where flexibility is needed. FMC
requires a separate grounding conductor to be pulled through the conduit. LFMC (Liquidtight Flexible Metal Conduit)
Similar to FMC, but has a waterproof jacket. Suitable for wet locations or areas where the conduit might be exposed to liquids. Requires fittings approved for wet locations. Like FMC, LFMC
requires a separate grounding conductor. Considerations for Overhead Lighting
Support
You'll need to properly support the flex or MC cable at regular intervals, typically every 4.5 feet or less, and within 12 inches of any box or fitting. Clamping to the I-beam is a good idea, but make sure you're using appropriate clamps that won't damage the cable or conduit.
Strain Relief
Ensure proper strain relief at both ends of the flex or MC cable to prevent pulling on the conductors inside.
Code Compliance
Always adhere to local electrical codes and the NEC (National Electrical Code) when installing electrical systems.
Improving MC Cable Terminations (Bushing Issues)
You're right – the standard red/orange plastic bushings for MC cable aren't always the best at protecting the conductors. Here are some solutions and tips:1. Proper Bushing Installation
Ensure Correct Size
Use the correct size bushing for the cable you're using. Too small, and it won't fit properly; too large, and it won't stay in place.
Securely Install
Make sure the bushing is fully seated and locked into place within the MC cable armor. It should "snap" in.
Inspect
After installing the bushing, inspect it to ensure it's not damaged and that it's providing a smooth, rounded surface for the conductors to pass through.2.
Improved Bushing Options
Metal Bushings
These provide superior protection compared to plastic bushings. They are more robust and less likely to crack or break. Some metal bushings have a rounded, smooth edge designed to prevent conductor damage.
Insulated Throat Connectors
These connectors have a built-in insulated throat that protects the conductors as they enter the box. They are a good all-in-one solution.3.
Connector Choice
Proper Connector Type
Use connectors specifically designed for MC cable. These connectors clamp the cable securely and provide a good grounding connection to the box.
Tighten Securely
Ensure the connector is tightened properly to the box and the MC cable. A loose connection can lead to arcing and overheating.4.
Conductor Preparation
Smooth Cuts
Use a proper MC cable cutter to create clean, smooth cuts in the armor. Avoid using hacksaws, as they can leave sharp edges.
Deburr
After cutting the MC cable, deburr the edges of the armor to remove any sharp burrs that could damage the conductors.
Gentle Handling
Be gentle when pulling the conductors through the MC cable and connectors. Avoid kinking or twisting the wires.5.
Your Sleeving Idea
While sleeving over the conductors may provide some extra protection, it's generally
not a code-compliant solution. It might be acceptable for additional protection beyond what is already required, but should not be used instead of proper bushings and connectors.
Recommendation for Your Overhead Lighting Project
Based on your description, MC cable with proper metal bushings and connectors is a good choice for your overhead lighting project. The key is to use high-quality components and to pay careful attention to the installation details. MC Cable
Provides good mechanical protection and a dedicated grounding conductor.
Metal Bushings
Essential for protecting the conductors from the sharp edges of the MC cable armor.
MC Connectors
Use connectors specifically designed for MC cable and ensure they are properly tightened.
Proper Support
Securely support the MC cable to the I-beams using appropriate clamps.
Important Notes
Local Codes
Always consult with your local electrical inspector to ensure your installation meets all applicable codes and regulations.*
Qualified Electrician: If you are not comfortable working with electrical systems, hire a qualified electrician to perform the work. Electrical work can be dangerous, and improper installations can lead to fire or electrocution. Flag for review