User: hhsting, Location: Glen bunie, md, us
Asked on: Thursday, November 14, 2024 at 5:40 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:14 am EST
Question: I have two tenant space call them X and Y. In tenant space X I have existing panel A. In tenant space Y I have new panel BThe existing panel A has feeder breaker which feed new Panel B. New panel B feeds lights and receptacle tenant space Y.My question is new feeder breaker in existing Panel A which is in another tenant allowed to feed new panel B which is in different tenant space according to NEC 2017?
Yes, generally, the NEC 2017 does allow a feeder breaker in an existing panel (Panel A) in one tenant space (X) to feed a new panel (Panel B) in a different tenant space (Y), but with very important conditions and considerations. You must carefully address these points
Key NEC Considerations (Based on NEC 2017, but ALWAYS consult with the AHJ and a qualified electrical engineer):
1. Accessibility and Identification (NEC 240.24(B), 240.32, 408.36)
Easy Access
The overcurrent device (feeder breaker in Panel A) protecting the feeder to Panel B must be readily accessible to the occupants of tenant space Y or to those responsible for the electrical maintenance of tenant space Y. "Readily accessible" means capable of being reached quickly for operation, renewal, or inspections without requiring those to whom ready access is requisite to climb over or remove obstacles or to resort to portable ladders, and so forth. This is a major hurdle in your scenario.
Identification
The feeder breaker in Panel A
must be clearly and permanently labeled to indicate what it supplies in Tenant Space Y. A simple label like "Panel B - Tenant Y" is usually sufficient, but consult with the AHJ. Panel Directory
The directory in Panel A must clearly identify the feeder breaker serving Panel B and its location.2.
Panel Capacity (NEC 408.41, Article 220)
Load Calculations
You MUST perform accurate load calculations for both Panel A and Panel B. The existing Panel A must have sufficient spare capacity (both ampacity and physical space) to accommodate the new feeder breaker and the load it will serve. Article 220 covers load calculations.
Panel Rating
Ensure Panel A's rating is not exceeded by adding the new load.
Feeder Size
The feeder conductors between Panel A and Panel B must be properly sized based on the calculated load and derating factors (temperature, conduit fill, etc.).3.
Overcurrent Protection (NEC 240.4, 240.21)
Feeder Protection
The feeder breaker in Panel A must provide proper overcurrent protection for the feeder conductors running to Panel B. The breaker size should be coordinated with the ampacity of the feeder conductors.
Tap Rules
If the feeder conductors are tapped from a larger conductor, the tap rules in NEC 240.21 must be strictly followed. This is unlikely in your direct panel-to-panel scenario but is worth noting.
4.
Grounding and Bonding (Article 250)
Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC)
A properly sized EGC must be run with the feeder conductors from Panel A to Panel B to provide a low-impedance fault current path.
Bonding
Ensure all metallic enclosures and raceways are properly bonded.5.
Wiring Methods (Chapter 3)
Permitted Wiring Methods
Use approved wiring methods for the feeder conductors between the panels (e.g., conduit, cable). The wiring method must be suitable for the environment (e.g., wet locations, corrosive environments).6.
Working Space (NEC 110.26)
Adequate Working Space
Ensure that there is adequate working space (clearance) in front of both Panel A and Panel B.7.
Local Amendments and Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)
Local Codes
Crucially, check with your local AHJ (city, county, or state electrical inspector). They may have amendments to the NEC or specific requirements that apply to your situation. They have the final say.
Permits and Inspections
Obtain the necessary permits and schedule inspections for the electrical work.
Practical Challenges and Considerations
Accessibility is Key
The biggest problem is the accessibility of the breaker in Tenant X to someone in Tenant Y. If the tenant in X doesn't allow easy access, or if there are security concerns, this arrangement will likely not be permitted. Think about after-hours access, emergency situations, etc. The NEC prioritizes safety and quick access for disconnecting power.
Tenant Agreements
Consider the lease agreements between the landlord and the tenants. They may have clauses that affect electrical installations.
Metering
Who pays for the electricity used in Tenant Y? You may need to install sub-metering to accurately bill Tenant Y for their consumption. This adds cost and complexity.
Future Changes
What happens if Tenant X moves out or needs to expand their electrical service? The arrangement could become problematic.
Alternatives to Consider
Separate Service
The best solution (though often the most expensive) is usually to install a completely separate electrical service for Tenant Y with its own meter and disconnect. This avoids all the complications of sharing a panel.
New Panel in Common Area
If space is available and permissible, installing a new panel in a common area accessible to both tenants might be an option. This requires careful planning and coordination.
In summary, while technically permissible under the NEC 2017 in some situations, feeding a panel in one tenant space from a panel in another tenant space presents significant practical challenges and code requirements, particularly regarding accessibility. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer and the local AHJ before proceeding. They can assess your specific situation and ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations. Do not proceed without their approval. Flag for review