User: User Name, Location: USA
Asked on: Thursday, November 14, 2024 at 6:32 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:14 am EST
Question: Hey guys, customer added a big addition to their building, need to get a 200 amp 3ph service to it. This is what I've got to work with, there's a fused 400 amp disconnect to the left. The panel looks like it's doing a lot but it's really not, I'd be surprised if it got over 50 amps at any given time. Really don't want to rip this out for a different box if I can help it. Could a guy tap the mains some how and set a 200 breaker disconnect right beside it? QO only makes a plug in breaker to to 100 in 3ph, they have bigger, but they're bolt on, and this isn't a bolt on panel. Or could a guy take 1 set of each phase out to feed my new panel and leave one set in the old panel?
Okay, this is a common situation and it's good you're thinking it through carefully. Let's break down the options and what's likely code-compliant and safest.
Understanding the Challenges Panel Capacity and Code
You're right to be cautious about overloading the existing panel. Even if the current load is low, adding a 200A service is a significant increase in potential demand. Code requires you to do a load calculation to make sure the existing service and panel can handle the new load.
Square D QO Limitations
The QO series panels are great for many applications, but their limited 3-phase breaker options are a constraint here.
Options & Analysis
Tapping the Mains Before the Existing Disconnect (NOT RECOMMENDED)
Why it's generally a bad idea
This is almost certainly a code violation. You can't tap service conductors before the main disconnect without proper overcurrent protection. You'd be essentially creating a parallel feed to the new panel, which is a recipe for disaster if a fault occurs.
Unless
You have approval from the power company, an engineer has sized the conductors properly, and you use Listed tap connectors, this is not something to consider.2.
Tapping the Mains Inside the Existing Disconnect (Potentially Possible, but Requires Careful Consideration)
Pros
Could avoid replacing the existing panel.
Cons
Requires careful planning and execution to maintain safety and code compliance.
How to approach it if it's feasible
Load Calculation is CRITICAL
You must perform a detailed load calculation for both the existing load and the new 200A addition. This will tell you if the existing 400A service is adequate. Don't guess – do the math according to the NEC.
Suitable Tap Connectors
If the load calculation allows it, use Listed and appropriately sized tap connectors within the 400A disconnect to run conductors to your new 200A disconnect. Polaris connectors are a popular and reliable option. Ensure the connectors are rated for the conductor size and ampacity.
Conductor Sizing
Size the conductors from the tap connectors to the new 200A disconnect based on the 200A load, following NEC guidelines for ampacity and derating (if applicable).
Grounding and Bonding
Maintain proper grounding and bonding throughout the installation. Pay close attention to the grounding electrode conductor (GEC) and bonding of the disconnect enclosures.
Physical Space
Ensure there's enough physical space within the existing disconnect enclosure to safely install the tap connectors and make the connections. Don't overcrowd the enclosure.
Inspection
This will be inspected. Make sure your work is neat, professional, and compliant with all applicable codes.3.
Using One Set of Lugs in the Existing Panel for the New Panel (Feasible, But Needs Careful Evaluation)
Pros
Potentially less invasive than tapping in the disconnect. May be easier to implement depending on available space.
Cons
Still requires a load calculation. May require replacing the existing panel's main breaker if the existing service isn't sized properly.
How to approach it if it's feasible
Load Calculation
As before, a detailed load calculation is essential.
Lug Capacity
Verify the existing panel's main lugs can accommodate two conductors per phase (one for the existing panel and one for the new panel). Most lugs are only rated for one conductor per hole.
If Lugs Can't Accommodate Two Conductors
You might be able to replace the existing lugs with larger lugs that are rated for multiple conductors, or use a Listed "lug reducer" or "tap block" to split the connection.
Breaker Space and Type
Again, the QO panel's breaker limitations become a problem. You cannot simply install a 200A 3-pole QO breaker because they don't exist.
Subfeed Lugs/Kit (Potential Solution, Check Availability)
Some panels have provisions for adding subfeed lugs. These are essentially a separate set of lugs that connect directly to the busbars, allowing you to feed another panel. If available for your panel model, this might be the cleanest solution.
Consider a Different Panel for the New Service
Instead of trying to make the QO panel work, consider using a different panel brand (e.g., Square D Homeline, Eaton, Siemens) for the new 200A service. These brands often have more options for 3-phase main breakers and subfeed lugs.4.
Replacing the Existing Panel with a Larger One (Recommended, but More Work)
Pros
This is often the safest and most reliable solution, especially if the load calculation indicates the existing service is marginal. It ensures you have adequate capacity and avoids potential code violations.
Cons
More expensive and time-consuming. Requires a complete shutdown of the existing service.
How to approach it
Select the Right Panel
Choose a panel with sufficient capacity for the existing load plus the new 200A load, with some extra capacity for future growth. Consider a 600A or 800A panel depending on your calculations.
Coordinate with the Power Company
You'll likely need to notify the power company and possibly coordinate a service interruption.
Proper Installation
Ensure the new panel is installed correctly, with proper grounding, bonding, and conductor sizing.
Important Considerations & Recommendations
Load Calculation is Paramount
I can't stress this enough. You must perform a detailed load calculation. This is the foundation for making any safe and code-compliant decision.
Consult with an Electrical Engineer (Highly Recommended)
Given the complexity of this project, consulting with a qualified electrical engineer is highly recommended. They can perform the load calculation, ensure code compliance, and provide stamped drawings if required by your local jurisdiction.
Local Codes and Regulations
Always adhere to your local electrical codes and regulations, which may be more stringent than the NEC.
Power Company Requirements
Contact your local power company to determine if they have any specific requirements for adding a new service.
Safety First
Always prioritize safety. Work with qualified personnel and follow all safety precautions when working with electrical systems.
In summary:
While tapping the mains in the disconnect might be possible (option 2), it's complex and requires careful planning and execution. Using the existing panel's lugs is also possible but might be tricky with QO's breaker limitations. Replacing the existing panel (option 4) is often the best long-term solution, although it's more work. Always* start with a load calculation and consult with an electrical engineer for professional guidance.Good luck! Let me know if you have any other questions. Flag for review