User: 3oFElectric, Location: Tennessee
Asked on: Friday, November 15, 2024 at 12:07 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:15 am EST
Question: I'm troubleshooting some UFO high Bay lights in a shop. There are 6 lights. They're rated AC85 -277V. They're plugged into a 120v outlets in the ceiling.They're flickering in unison.When I unplug one light at the outlet box that powers the rest of the lighting plugs down the line, and plug in another exact same type of light into the outlet, they all stop flickering.When I disconnect that light from the outlet, they all start flickering again.I'd like to understand why this is happening.Voltage to the 1st outlet box is fine and steady. All connections are tight.The lights are 300 watt each on a 20 amp circuit.Here's a link to a short video showing what I'm talking about -
Okay, that's a tricky situation, but the behavior you're describing and the video you linked give us some good clues. Here's a breakdown of the possible causes and how to approach them, focusing on the common factor of one particular light "fixing" the problem when plugged in
Understanding the Symptoms:
Unison Flickering
The fact that all lights flicker together strongly suggests a shared electrical issue affecting all of them simultaneously. This points away from individual light failures being the cause.
Specific Light Fix
The key is why one particular light stabilizes the others. It implies that light has a characteristic that the other lights are missing in the circuit and need.
Voltage Steady
A steady voltage at the initial outlet rules out gross supply voltage fluctuations, but doesn't exclude more subtle voltage quality problems.
Possible Causes and How to Test/Address Them
Harmonic Distortion/Power Factor Issues
This is the most likely culprit.
Explanation
Modern LED drivers, especially cheaper ones, can draw current in short pulses rather than a smooth sine wave. This creates harmonic distortion on the power line. The more lights you have, the worse the distortion. This distortion can affect the voltage waveform, causing flickering. Power factor also comes into play here. If the lights have a poor power factor, they draw current out of phase with the voltage, further stressing the circuit.
Why the "Fixing" Light Works
That one particular light might have a better power factor correction (PFC) circuit built into its driver. It could be passively or actively filtering out some of the harmonic distortion, cleaning up the voltage waveform, and stabilizing the other lights. It's acting as a makeshift filter.
Testing
Power Quality Analyzer
The best way to confirm this is with a power quality analyzer. These devices measure voltage and current waveforms and quantify harmonic distortion and power factor. A spike in harmonics right before and during the flickering would be a strong indicator of this problem. If you have access to one, check the Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) of the voltage and current.
Clamp Meter (AC/DC)
An AC clamp meter will measure the amount of AC current flowing through the circuit. A DC clamp meter would show how much the current wave form is offset.
Multimeter (AC Voltage) Check the voltage at the last light in the daisy chain. Does it drop significantly when all the lights are on? Temporary Capacitor Bank
The first, fastest, and easiest thing to try is to add some capacitance to the circuit to filter it. You can easily buy a capacitor from an electronics store. When the lights are flickering, carefully attach the leads of the capacitor to the hot and neutral wires in the light fixture. Capacitors store up and release energy, and that may be enough to clean the power coming into the circuit. Use a high quality capacitor designed for AC voltage.
Solutions
Replace with Higher Quality Lights
Lights with active PFC circuits will significantly reduce harmonic distortion. Look for lights that explicitly state they have PFC and have a high power factor (close to 1.0).
Add Harmonic Filters
Install a dedicated harmonic filter at the panel or on the lighting circuit. These are designed to absorb harmonic currents. This is usually the most effective but also the most expensive solution.
Divide the Load
If possible, split the lights across multiple circuits to reduce the harmonic load on any single circuit. This is not possible in this scenario, but for other readers this is worth noting.2.
Neutral Wire Problems
Explanation
A loose or corroded neutral connection anywhere in the circuit (from the panel to the last light) can cause fluctuating voltage and flickering. A shared neutral wire in a multi-wire branch circuit with unbalanced loads can also create problems.
Why the "Fixing" Light Might Seem to Help
The added current draw of that specific light might be slightly changing the voltage drop across a bad neutral connection, temporarily mitigating the flickering.
Testing
Voltage Measurement
Use a multimeter to measure the voltage between neutral and ground at several points along the circuit, including the panel and each light fixture. You should see very close to 0 volts. Any significant voltage (more than a few volts) indicates a potential neutral problem.
Continuity Testing
With the circuit completely de-energized, use a multimeter to check the continuity of the neutral wire from the panel to each light fixture. Look for high resistance.
Solutions
Tighten Connections
Carefully inspect and tighten all neutral connections in the circuit, including at the panel, junction boxes, and light fixtures.
Replace Wiring
If you find corroded or damaged wiring, replace it.
Separate Neutrals
If you suspect a shared neutral problem, separate the neutrals for the lighting circuit from other circuits.3.
Marginal Voltage Drop
Explanation
While you said the voltage is "fine," a slight voltage drop under load could be pushing the LED drivers to the edge of their operating range. The lights may require more voltage than is making it to them
Why the "Fixing" Light Might Seem to Help
Adding that one light could slightly reduce the voltage drop elsewhere in the circuit (though this is less likely given they flicker in unison).
Testing
Voltage Measurement Under Load
Measure the voltage at the first and last light fixtures with all lights turned on. Compare the readings. A significant drop (more than a few volts) indicates excessive voltage drop.
Clamp Meter on Wiring How many amps is the branch circuit using when the lights are flickering? Solutions
Increase Wire Gauge
If the voltage drop is excessive, consider running thicker gauge wire for the circuit to reduce resistance. This is a major undertaking.
Reduce Load
Reduce the number of lights on the circuit.4.
Faulty Breaker
Explanation
A failing breaker can sometimes exhibit intermittent voltage drops or erratic behavior.
Why the "Fixing" Light Might Seem to Help
Less likely, but the slightly different current draw could be enough to alter the breaker's behavior temporarily.
Testing
Breaker Voltage
Measure the voltage at the breaker itself under load. Compare it to the voltage at the panel's main terminals.
Breaker Replacement
The easiest way to test is to simply replace the breaker with a new one of the same rating.
Solution
Replace Breaker
If the breaker is suspected, replace it.
Troubleshooting Steps
Start with the Obvious
Double-check all connections (especially neutrals!) for tightness and corrosion.2.
Power Quality Analysis (Ideal)
If possible, use a power quality analyzer to diagnose harmonic distortion and power factor.3.
Voltage Drop Measurement
Measure voltage at the first and last light with all lights on.4.
Neutral Testing
Carefully check neutral-to-ground voltage at multiple points.5.
Breaker Check
Test the breaker's voltage output under load.6.
Try a Different Brand of Light
If replacing all the lights isn't feasible immediately, experiment with replacing one light with a different brand and model known for good power factor correction. If that eliminates the flickering, it strongly suggests a harmonic distortion issue.
Important Safety Notes
Work De-energized
Always turn off the power at the breaker before working on any electrical wiring.
Qualified Electrician
If you're not comfortable working with electrical wiring, hire a qualified electrician. Electrical work can be dangerous.*
Proper PPE: Use appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), including safety glasses and insulated gloves.Let me know what you find when you perform some of these tests, and we can refine the diagnosis. Good luck! Flag for review