User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Friday, November 15, 2024 at 1:24 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:16 am EST
Question: Would you ever field bend 4" PVC Coated RGS or always use prefab? Have about 250 bends within multiple sets.It's all on a roof on ground and not up in air, not sure if that makes difference in determing whether bend or use prefab.
Okay, let's break down the decision of field bending 4" PVC-Coated RGS (Rigid Galvanized Steel) vs. using prefabricated bends, considering your roof-mounted application.
Factors to Consider
Labor Costs
Field Bending
Requires skilled labor, specialized bending equipment (hydraulic benders), and time to set up, bend, and inspect each bend. The larger the conduit, the more time and effort required.
Prefabricated Bends
Reduces on-site labor considerably. The bends are ready to install, simplifying the process.
Material Costs
Field Bending
Slightly less expensive for the conduit material itself if you're just buying straight sticks. However, factor in the cost of wasted material from bad bends, especially when starting.
Prefabricated Bends
Higher initial cost per bend, but potentially less waste overall.
Consistency and Quality
Field Bending
Can be inconsistent, especially with 4" RGS, which requires significant force and precision. The potential for wrinkles, kinks, or improper angles is higher. PVC coating can also be damaged during bending.
Prefabricated Bends
Guaranteed consistent angles, radii, and quality. Bends are typically manufactured to meet industry standards.
Speed of Installation
Field Bending
Slower installation. Each bend must be measured, marked, bent, and inspected.
Prefabricated Bends
Faster installation. Bends are ready to go, allowing for quicker assembly.
Accuracy and Planning
Field Bending
Requires precise measurements and planning to ensure the bends align correctly. More room for error on the job site.
Prefabricated Bends
Requires accurate measurements upfront when ordering, but reduces the likelihood of errors during installation.
PVC Coating Integrity
Field Bending
Bending can damage the PVC coating, particularly at the bend itself. This damage can compromise the corrosion protection and require touch-up or repair. Specialized bending shoes for PVC-coated conduit are essential to minimize damage.
Prefabricated Bends
Bends are manufactured with the PVC coating intact and properly applied, ensuring consistent corrosion protection.
Bending Equipment
Field Bending
Requires a powerful hydraulic bender specifically designed for rigid conduit. A 4" RGS bender is a substantial investment.
Prefabricated Bends
No bending equipment is needed.
Waste
Field Bending
Potential for more waste due to mis-bends or cutoffs that are too short to use.
Prefabricated Bends
Less waste if the layout is well-planned.
Roof Considerations
The fact that it's on a roof on the ground: This makes transporting and maneuvering long sticks of conduit for field bending slightly easier than if you were working at height, but the difficulty of bending 4" RGS remains.
Recommendation
For 250 bends, using prefabricated bends is almost certainly the better option, especially for 4" PVC-Coated RGS.
Here's why: Quality and Consistency
Maintaining the integrity of the PVC coating is crucial for long-term corrosion protection. Prefabricated bends offer superior consistency and protection compared to field bending.
Labor Savings
The labor cost savings will likely outweigh the higher material cost of the prefabricated bends, especially with a large number of bends.
Speed and Accuracy
The installation will be significantly faster and more accurate, reducing the risk of errors and delays.
Equipment
The cost of a suitable 4" RGS bender can be substantial.
Skill Level
The project will be less dependent on highly skilled (and expensive) bending labor.
Reduced Risk
Minimizes the risk of damaging the conduit or creating inconsistent bends.
Overall Cost: With 250 bends, any field bend savings will be negligible and potentially non-existant once considering labor and waste.
When Might Field Bending Be Considered? Extremely limited budget
If the budget is so tight that the upfront cost of prefabricated bends is absolutely prohibitive (even considering the long-term cost savings), then carefully consider field bending.
Very few bends
If you only had a handful of bends, field bending might be viable.
Highly unusual bend angles or radii
If the required bends are non-standard and cannot be easily obtained as prefabricated items.
If you decide to proceed with prefabricated bends
Plan meticulously
Accurate measurements and a detailed layout are essential for ordering the correct bends.
Consider custom bends
If you have specific requirements, work with a supplier to create custom bends.
In Summary:
Prefabricated bends offer significant advantages in terms of quality, labor savings, speed, and consistency for a project of this scale using 4" PVC-Coated RGS. The investment in prefabricated bends will likely pay for itself in the long run. Flag for review