User: JustSomeGuy, Location: Minnesota
Asked on: Friday, November 15, 2024 at 1:33 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:16 am EST
Question: Hello,I have an enclosure that is deemed a Class 1 Div 1 area and protected through intrinsically safe barriers. I have an RTD inside this enclosure to monitor temperature. I am using the manufacturer RTD cable between this area and the intrinsically safe barrier. I do not know if this cable is listed or not, if it is gas/vaportight, or if it transmits gas or vapors. I am currently waiting to hear back from the manufacturer with this information.My question is, if the manufacturer tells me this cable is not listed, not gas/vaportight, and transmits gas or vapors, am I able to strip the jacket of the cable back past where the conduit sealing compound is and seal around the individual wires? Does this meet the requirements of 501.15(D)?Additionally, if this cable is not listed, but I am using it per the manufacturers specifications, can I use it at all?
Okay, let's break down this situation with a focus on the NEC (National Electrical Code), specifically Article 501 for Class I, Division 1 locations.
Understanding the Problem
You've correctly identified the key concern: You have an RTD cable running from a Class I, Division 1 enclosure through an intrinsically safe (IS) barrier. The big unknowns are the cable's properties: Listing
Is it listed for use in hazardous (classified) locations? (NEC 501.4)
Gas/Vapor Tightness
Does it prevent the migration of flammable gases or vapors? (NEC 501.15(D))
Transmission of Gas/Vapors
Can it act as a pathway for flammable gases or vapors to travel through the cable itself (e.g., through the cable jacket or between conductors)? (NEC 501.15(D))
Addressing Your Specific Questions1. Stripping the Jacket and Sealing Around Individual Wires
NEC 501.15(D) and Sealing Raceways
This section is concerned with preventing the passage of gases, vapors, or flames from one portion of the electrical installation to another, and preventing the buildup of pressure in raceways. It mentions sealing conduits and other raceways at the point where they enter or leave a Class I, Division 1 enclosure. It's about containing the explosion, not just preventing vapor transmission along a wire.
No, Simply Stripping and Sealing Individual Wires is Likely NOT Compliant. While it might physically block the passage of gas along the outside of the individual wires, it doesn't address the core issue: Potential Internal Transmission
If the cable jacket and insulation materials themselves can absorb and transmit gas/vapors, sealing the ends only won't stop that.
Lack of Approved Method
There's no recognized method in the NEC that allows you to strip a non-listed cable and individually seal the wires as a substitute for a listed, gas/vapor-tight cable and appropriate sealing fitting.
Compromised Insulation
Stripping the jacket back exposes the wire insulation, and sealing compound may not be compatible with that insulation, potentially leading to degradation and failure over time.
Essentially, you are trying to create your own field-modified method to achieve a listed requirement, which is generally not permitted. It might look like you're sealing it, but it doesn't address the fundamental safety requirements.2. Using a Non-Listed Cable Per Manufacturer's Specifications
NEC 501.4: Equipment Generally, in Class I, Division 1 locations, electrical equipment must be listed for that use. This means it has been tested and approved by a recognized testing laboratory (e.g., UL, CSA) to meet the requirements for safe operation in that environment. NEC 501.4(B) Special Permission
This section might offer a very limited exception, but it is unlikely to apply. It says that equipment that is not listed can be used only if acceptable to the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ), and if it is used in the same manner for which it was tested or approved. The documentation of that testing must be maintained for inspection. This is typically used for specialized equipment or situations where listed equipment is simply not available.
It is not a blanket permission to use any non-listed cable. In practice, getting an AHJ to approve non-listed wiring for permanent installation in a Class I, Division 1 area is extremely difficult. You'd need an incredible amount of documentation to prove the cable is safe, and it would likely be cheaper and easier to just use the correct cable. Manufacturer's Specs Don't Override Code
Just because the manufacturer allows you to use the cable doesn't mean it's compliant with the NEC or other applicable regulations. The manufacturer is responsible for the performance of the RTD system, not necessarily the electrical safety of the installation.
Intrinsically Safe Systems Add Complexity
The fact that this is an IS system complicates things. You MUST maintain the integrity of the IS circuit. Using a cable that is not specified or listed for use with the IS barrier can compromise the safety of the entire system and invalidate the IS certification.
What You MUST Do1. Get the Cable Information
The absolute first step is to get the definitive information from the RTD cable manufacturer about the following:
Listing
Is the cable listed for use in hazardous locations? If so, what listing (e.g., CL1 Div 1, AEx i, etc.)?
Gas/Vapor Tightness
Is it certified as gas/vapor-tight?
Gas/Vapor Transmission
Does it prevent the transmission of gases/vapors?
IS Compatibility
Is it approved and compatible for use with your specific IS barrier? The barrier manufacturer should specify compatible cables.2.
If the Cable is NOT Listed and Gas/Vapor Tight
Replace the Cable
This is the safest and most straightforward solution. Use a cable that is listed and approved for Class I, Division 1 locations and IS applications. There are many options available from reputable manufacturers.
Use Appropriate Sealing Fittings
Install sealing fittings at the enclosure and barrier entries that are listed and approved for use with the cable you've chosen.3.
Consult with an Expert
Qualified Electrical Engineer
Engage a qualified electrical engineer with experience in hazardous locations and intrinsically safe systems. They can perform a thorough assessment of your installation and provide recommendations to ensure compliance with all applicable codes and standards.
AHJ Consultation
It's a good idea to discuss your installation with the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction, typically a local electrical inspector). They have the final say on what is acceptable in your specific area.
Summary and Key Takeaways Do NOT try to "make do" with a non-listed cable in a Class I, Division 1 location. The risks are too high. Listing and approval by a recognized testing laboratory (e.g., UL, CSA) are critical for safety and code compliance. Intrinsically safe systems have very specific requirements for wiring and components. Deviating from these requirements can invalidate the IS certification and compromise safety. When in doubt, consult with a qualified electrical engineer and the AHJ. Use a cable listed for Class I, Div 1 applications, that is gas/vaportight, and suitable for the intended application with the IS system.Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide professional engineering advice. This information is for general guidance only and should not be substituted for the advice of a qualified electrical engineer. You are responsible for complying with all applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review