Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Is this safe?

User: pab77777, Location: long Island

Asked on: Saturday, November 16, 2024 at 9:23 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:18 am EST

Question: I have an 8-watt under-sink tankless water heater and replaced it with an 11W (rheen) 220 volts and max amperage of 45. I have #8 Romex with a 40 amp double breaker. I should use #6 with a 50amp breaker. I use the sink for 15-20 minutes a day to wash the dishes. The breaker terminal gets to 106(f) 38(c) after 15 minutes of continuous use. If I used it continually all day I would redo it, but I hope 15 to 20 minutes will be safe. If the 40amp breaker ever tripped I would replace the line. Is this safe?

Okay, let's break down the situation and address your concerns about the safety of your undersink tankless water heater installation.

The Short Answer: No, this is not safe, and relying on the breaker to trip is not a safe strategy. You have undersized wiring and potentially an undersized breaker for the load. You are also potentially using a type of wire that is not rated for the environment. The temperature you are seeing on the breaker is concerning.

The Detailed Explanation


Amperage Draw and Wire Gauge

You have an 11kW (11,000 watt) water heater operating at 220 volts. To calculate the amperage draw: Amps = Watts / Volts Amps = 11,000 / 220 = 50 Amps You stated the max amperage is 45 amps. This would mean the water heater is 9900 watts. To calculate watts: Watts = volts amps Watts = 220 volts 45 Amps = 9,900 watts. According to the National Electrical Code (NEC), you should size your wiring and breaker for 125% of the continuous load. Since a tankless water heater is considered a continuous load, you should use the higher number of 11,000 watts to be safe. Amps = 50 Amps 1.25 = 62.5 Amps For 62.5 amps (at 75C degree terminal), #6 AWG copper is required. #6 AWG copper wire, in many common insulation types, is rated for 55 Amps at 60°C, 75 Amps at 75°C, or 70 Amps at 90°C. Your breaker is rated for 75C degree terminal. Use the breaker degree for the minimum wire gauge. Using #8 AWG Romex with a 40 amp breaker is

inadequate and dangerous
. #8 AWG copper wire is only rated for 40 Amps at 60°C (most Romex).2. Breaker Size

The breaker's purpose is to protect the wire, not the appliance. It's designed to trip before the wire overheats and causes a fire. Using a 40 amp breaker with #8 AWG wire is a mismatch. The breaker should be sized to protect the wire.

You should use a breaker appropriate for the wire
. Use a #6 AWG wire that is appropriate to the wire. If the terminal lug on the breaker is rated for 75C, then #6 is rated for 55Amps. The breaker should be rated for 50amps.3. Romex in a Wet/Damp Location

"Under-sink" areas can be prone to moisture. Standard Romex (NM-B) is generally

not permitted
in wet or damp locations. You might need to use a cable type specifically rated for wet locations, such as UF-B.4. Breaker Temperature

A breaker terminal temperature of 106°F (38°C) after only 15 minutes of use is

a serious red flag
. It indicates that the breaker is working hard, and that excess heat is being generated. This could be due to: The undersized wiring causing resistance and heat buildup. Loose connections at the breaker terminal (or at the water heater). A faulty breaker. Normal breaker temperature should be close to ambient temperature.5. Why "Waiting for it to Trip" is Dangerous

Relying on the breaker to trip is not a safety strategy. Breakers can fail to trip at their rated current, especially as they age. By the time the breaker trips, the wire may have already been subjected to excessive heat, potentially damaging the insulation and creating a fire hazard. Also, depending on the type of breaker, a small current in excess of the rating might take a long time to trip the breaker. If the cable is rated to 40 amps and the heater is drawing 50amps, it could take hours for the breaker to trip while the wire heats up.

What You Need to Do (Immediate Actions)


Turn OFF the breaker supplying the water heater IMMEDIATELY.
Do not use the water heater until the wiring is corrected.2. Consult with a Qualified Electrician

Do NOT attempt to fix this yourself unless you are a licensed electrician and are very comfortable working with electrical systems. This is a safety issue.3.

Have the Electrician Evaluate and Correct the Wiring

The electrician will:
Verify the exact amperage requirements of the water heater. Determine if the existing breaker box can handle the additional load. Replace the wiring with the correct gauge (#6 AWG) copper wire of the proper type (suitable for damp locations, if applicable). Install a correctly sized breaker (likely a 50 amp, depending on the wire selected). Ensure all connections are tight and properly made.* Verify the entire installation is safe and compliant with local electrical codes.

In summary, your current setup is unsafe and needs to be corrected by a qualified electrician. Don't take chances with electricity; it's not worth the risk of fire or electrical shock.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question