Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Unavoidable Objectionable Current

User: 1.21 gigawatt, Location: PA

Asked on: Sunday, November 17, 2024 at 8:32 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:19 am EST

Question: Should we beat this dead horse a little more? There is a lot of discussion about parallel neutral paths and how sometimes it is unavoidable. Here's the current scenario that I'm struggling with.This is new service to a mobile home disconnect. The utility requires the meter socket and disconnect to be mounted on RMC posts with strut channel supports. The grounding requirement is per NEC and simple enough. Utility also requires metallic conduit between meter socket and disconnect with bond bushings. All that is straightforward enough until you bond the ground and neutral in the disconnect like we're supposed to. There is now a parallel neutral path from that bonding point to the factory neutral/enclosure bond in the meter socket.I can't see any way to eliminate this parallel path. One of the problems is that there are three different inspectors involved and they might disagree somehow. There has to be a solution to this NEC/Utility conflict.Thoughts?

You've hit upon a common problem, and you're right, it's tough to solve when multiple authorities (NEC, utility, inspectors) have requirements that seem to conflict. Let's break down the issues and explore potential solutions

The Problem:
The Parallel Path

Bonding the neutral and ground in the disconnect creates a parallel path for neutral current back to the source (transformer) via the metallic conduit system. Neutral current flows on the intended neutral conductor, but also on the metallic conduit, bond bushings, RMC posts, and even (to a lesser extent) the grounding electrode system.


Why is it a problem?
Potential for Increased EMF

More current flowing in the grounding path can increase electromagnetic fields (EMF) near the conduit.


Increased Impedance to Ground Fault Current

This parallel path can increase the impedance to ground fault current, potentially slowing down breaker tripping during a fault and increasing shock hazards.

Stray Voltage

It can contribute to "stray voltage" issues, especially on exposed metal parts of the mobile home.

Analyzing the Requirements



NEC Requirements



Service Disconnect Bonding

NEC
requires the grounding electrode conductor (GEC) and neutral to be bonded at the service disconnect (typically where the main breaker is located). This is to establish a low-impedance path for ground fault current back to the source.

Metallic Conduit as an Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC)

Metallic conduit systems are recognized as EGCs, and bond bushings are essential for ensuring continuity and low impedance.

Utility Requirements



Metallic Conduit

Utilities often require metallic conduit for physical protection and sometimes for shielding against RF interference.

Bonding at Meter Socket

While not always explicitly stated, utilities often assume or implicitly require the neutral at the meter socket to be bonded to the enclosure. This may stem from older code interpretations or specific utility practices.


Local Inspector Requirements

This is the wildcard! They are bound by the NEC but may have local interpretations or amendments, and they also have to consider the utility requirements.

Possible Solutions and Mitigation Strategies


Communicate, Communicate, Communicate!
This is the MOST important step. Get all three inspectors (NEC, Utility, Local) in a conference call or meeting. Explain the situation, the NEC requirements, and the potential for a parallel neutral path. Try to reach a consensus BEFORE starting the work. Document everything!2. Minimize the Parallel Path (The Best Approach)



Insulated Grounded Conductor (Neutral) from Meter to Disconnect

The best solution, if the utility and local inspector will allow it, is to use an

insulated grounded conductor (neutral)
from the meter to the disconnect AND to isolate the neutral from the metal enclosures at the meter enclosure. This eliminates the parallel path completely. The metal raceway then only serves as the equipment grounding conductor (EGC). Fault current would still have a low impedance path back to the source. The GEC connection would still be required in the disconnect. This is NEC compliant and arguably safer.3. Compensating for Parallel Paths (if eliminating is impossible)



Careful Grounding Electrode System

Make sure your grounding electrode system is robust. Drive the required number of ground rods (or other electrodes) and ensure they are properly bonded together with the correct size grounding electrode conductor. This strengthens the primary grounding path and helps ensure low impedance.


Minimize Conduit Length

Keep the metallic conduit run between the meter socket and the disconnect as short as possible. Shorter conduit = lower impedance in the parallel path.

Proper Bonding

Use the correct size bond bushings and bonding jumpers at all conduit terminations. Ensure all connections are clean and tight.4.

Utility Neutral Bonding at Meter (The Least Desirable, but sometimes required)

If the utility absolutely requires the neutral to be bonded to the meter socket enclosure, you'll need to address the parallel path more directly. This scenario is problematic, and I'd push back hard against it if possible.

Important Considerations



Code Revisions

Keep in mind that code cycles change, and interpretations can evolve. Consult the latest NEC edition and any local amendments.


Documentation

Document everything – discussions, interpretations, agreements, and installation details. This protects you if questions arise later.

Engineer's Opinion

If there's a major disagreement or if the situation is particularly complex, consider getting a professional electrical engineer's opinion in writing. This can provide additional support for your approach.


Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI) Protection

Ensure that all circuits in the mobile home are GFCI protected, especially outdoor receptacles. GFCI protection won't eliminate parallel neutral paths, but it provides an extra layer of safety by detecting even small imbalances in current flow.

Example of Communication Points

When talking to the inspectors and utility, be prepared to discuss: The NEC's requirement for bonding neutral and ground at the service disconnect. The function of the metallic conduit as the equipment grounding conductor. The potential hazards associated with parallel neutral paths. Your proposed solution and how it addresses both the NEC and utility requirements.* The benefits of eliminating the parallel neutral path (reduced EMF, improved ground fault clearing, etc.).

In Summary:


The key to resolving this situation is clear communication and a collaborative approach. By working with the inspectors and the utility, you can find a solution that meets the requirements of all parties while ensuring the safety and performance of the electrical system. If at all possible, push for the insulated neutral from the meter to the disconnect with no neutral to enclosure connection at the meter. This is the safest and most code-compliant solution. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question