User: familyharvey, Location: New Bern, NC
Asked on: Sunday, November 17, 2024 at 8:43 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:19 am EST
Question: We are in the middle of a new build and I am getting conflicting information on ATS placement from generator dealers. We built a detached garage first and had 400 amp service brought in with the meter base feeding a 200 amp panel in the garage and a 200 amp service disconnect on the outside of the garage that will feed a 200 amp sub panel in the house. My intention was to place the ATS between the service disconnect and the sub panel in the house, most likely with the ATS next to the sub panel. I had one dealer tell me I would have to replace the service disconnect at the garage with the ATS. This doesn’t make sense to me and complicates things. Has there been an update to NEC that applies to this situation?
Okay, let's break down the ATS placement and the code implications in your specific situation. It sounds like you have a common setup, but the generator dealer's suggestion seems incorrect, given the description you've provided.
Understanding Your System
Here's how I understand your electrical setup:1. Main Service
400A service to the detached garage.2.
Garage Panel
200A panel inside the garage.3.
House Feed
200A service disconnect on the outside of the garage.4.
House Subpanel
200A subpanel inside the house, fed from the service disconnect at the garage.
ATS Placement: Your Intended Location IS the Correct One
Your plan to place the ATS between the 200A service disconnect (at the garage) and the 200A subpanel (in the house) is the most logical and standard approach. This is exactly where an ATS should be located to provide backup power to the house. Why it makes sense
The ATS will isolate the house subpanel from the utility grid when the generator is running. This prevents backfeeding power onto the grid, which is dangerous and illegal.
Simplicity
This setup is relatively straightforward to wire and doesn't require changing the existing service disconnect.
Why the Dealer's Suggestion is likely INCORRECT
The dealer's suggestion to replace the service disconnect on the garage with an ATS is generally not the best approach in your situation. Here's why:1. Code Compliance
The NEC (National Electrical Code) requires a service disconnect at each building or structure. Your garage has a service disconnect (the one feeding the house). Replacing it with an ATS would potentially violate this requirement, as an ATS is not considered a service disconnect.2.
Functionality
It doesn't make sense to have the ATS switch the entire 200A service feeding the house. You only want to switch the power to the house, not the entire garage feed.3.
Complication
Replacing the service disconnect would require running the generator feed to the garage, then back to the house. This adds unnecessary complexity and expense.
Possible Misunderstanding or Other Considerations
While the dealer's suggestion sounds incorrect based on your description, here are a few possible reasons why they might have suggested it (though they still don't make it the right approach):
Generator Size & Load Calculation
If the generator is significantly undersized compared to the potential load of both the garage and the house, they might be trying to force you to only back up the house. However, this should be addressed with proper load shedding, not by changing the location of the ATS.
Simplified Wiring (Rare)
In a very, very limited scenario, if you wanted to only back up the entire house and not anything in the garage during a power outage, and the generator was sized exactly for the house, it might be slightly simpler to put the ATS at the garage feed. However, this is unlikely and creates other issues.
Commission/Product Push
It's possible the dealer has a surplus of a specific ATS model that happens to integrate with a service disconnect, and they're trying to sell that. This isn't a good reason to compromise on the best solution for your situation.
Misunderstanding of Existing Setup
Double-check that the dealer fully understands your existing electrical setup. Make sure they realize the 200A disconnect at the garage is specifically feeding the house subpanel.
NEC Considerations Article 225 (Outside Branch Circuits and Feeders)
This article governs the wiring between the garage (source) and the house (load). Your setup is generally compliant as long as the conductors are properly sized, protected, and installed according to the code.
Article 702 (Optional Standby Systems)
This article covers generator installations and ATS requirements. It emphasizes preventing backfeed onto the utility grid. Your intended ATS placement achieves this.
Article 230 (Services)
This is where the requirements for service disconnects are found. Each building must have one.
Recommendations1. Confirm Understanding
Make sure the dealer completely understands your setup.2.
Get a Second Opinion
Get a quote and installation plan from another generator dealer. Describe your current electrical system in detail and explain where you want the ATS installed.3.
Load Calculation
Ensure the generator is appropriately sized for the loads you intend to back up in the house (and potentially the garage, if desired). A proper load calculation is crucial.4.
Permitting and Inspection
Before any work is done, obtain the necessary permits and ensure the installation will be inspected by a qualified electrical inspector. This will ensure code compliance and safety.5.
Written Proposal
Get a detailed written proposal that outlines the scope of work, equipment to be installed, and the placement of the ATS. Make sure it explicitly states that the existing service disconnect will not* be replaced.6.
Grounding and Bonding
Grounding and bonding are critical for safety. Ensure the generator, ATS, and electrical system are properly grounded and bonded according to NEC requirements.
In Summary
Your plan to place the ATS between the 200A service disconnect at the garage and the 200A subpanel in the house is the correct approach, assuming the generator is appropriately sized. Get a second opinion, verify the dealer's understanding, and ensure compliance with local codes. Do not let them replace your service disconnect on the garage unless there is some very specific circumstance not mentioned in the post. Flag for review