Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Fire hazard

User: blueheels2, Location: Raleigh, NC

Asked on: Monday, November 18, 2024 at 9:15 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:21 am EST

Question: So I did a trouble call on some cheap apartments and each unit has individual FPE panels with aluminum wiring that I know is trash. I’m suggesting replacement on those. But I also know some Zinsco are trash as well. Any idea if this meter assembly is a fire hazard. I know due to age it should be replaced but is it a fire hazard?It’s a Zinsco 5MRT.Thanks

Okay, let's break down the Zinsco 5MRT meter assembly and its potential fire hazard status.

Key Considerations for Zinsco Meter Assemblies (Including 5MRT)



Known Issues with Zinsco

The primary concern with Zinsco (and Sylvania, which acquired Zinsco) electrical equipment revolves around circuit breakers that can fail to trip under overload or short circuit conditions. This failure is a

significant fire hazard
. The breakers can become "welded" internally or have other mechanical problems preventing proper operation. Why the Breakers Fail



Poor Design

Zinsco breakers used a flawed design in how they attached to the bus bar. This connection can loosen over time, leading to arcing, overheating, and a failure to trip.


Aluminum Bus Bars

Many Zinsco panels used aluminum bus bars. Aluminum is more prone to oxidation and corrosion, which can exacerbate the connection problems.

Tight Fit

The breakers often fit very tightly on the bus bar, which can lead to mechanical stresses and binding.


Age

Being an older Zinsco meter assembly significantly increases the likelihood of problems. Materials degrade over time, connections loosen, and corrosion sets in.

Anecdotal Evidence

There are countless documented instances of Zinsco panels failing to trip during overloads, resulting in fires. While not every Zinsco panel is guaranteed to fail, the risk is substantially higher than with other brands.


Specific to Meter Assemblies (like the 5MRT)

Meter assemblies are critical points in the electrical system. They handle the full current load for the entire building/units they serve. If a problem occurs in the meter assembly (loose connections, breaker failure), the consequences can be severe.

Is the Zinsco 5MRT a Fire Hazard?
Yes, it should be considered a significant potential fire hazard. Here's why:1. Zinsco's inherent breaker failure problems apply to meter assemblies as well. The breakers in the 5MRT could fail to trip, leading to overheating, arcing, and fire.2. Age

The age of the unit makes it more likely that connections are loose, breakers are corroded, and the overall condition is compromised.3.

Critical Point

As the central connection point, a failure in the meter assembly has the potential to affect multiple units and cause a widespread outage or fire.

Recommendations


Immediate Recommendation: Replace it.
The 5MRT should be replaced with a modern meter assembly that uses reliable breakers and is properly rated for the load.2. Inspection

If immediate replacement isn't possible (due to budget or logistical constraints), have a qualified electrician: Carefully inspect the meter assembly for signs of overheating, corrosion, arcing, or loose connections.

Use extreme caution when inspecting live equipment.
Check the tightness of all connections. Perform a load test on the breakers (if possible and safe) to see if they trip properly. Document everything.3. Inform the Building Owner/Management

Clearly explain the risks associated with the Zinsco meter assembly and the FPE panels with aluminum wiring. Provide written documentation outlining the potential hazards and the recommended replacement. Liability is a significant concern if a fire occurs and you haven't properly informed them.4.

Prioritize Replacement

Emphasize that replacing the meter assembly and the FPE panels are critical safety upgrades and should be prioritized. Point out potential cost savings from improved energy efficiency and reduced insurance premiums.5.

Consider an Electrical System Assessment

If the budget allows, recommend a comprehensive electrical system assessment of the entire building. This will identify other potential hazards and provide a roadmap for necessary upgrades.

Important Considerations



Local Codes

Check your local electrical codes. Many jurisdictions are becoming more stringent about Zinsco and FPE equipment and may require replacement upon any electrical work being performed.


Insurance

Many insurance companies are aware of the risks associated with Zinsco and FPE panels and may require replacement as a condition of coverage.*

Liability

As the electrician, you have a responsibility to inform the building owner/management of any potential safety hazards. Document everything clearly to protect yourself from liability in case of a fire or other electrical incident.

In Summary:


The Zinsco 5MRT meter assembly should be considered a potential fire hazard due to the known issues with Zinsco breakers and the age of the equipment. Replacement is the best course of action to ensure the safety of the building and its occupants. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question