Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: NEC 250.24(A)(5)

User: david luchini, Location: Connecticut

Asked on: Monday, November 18, 2024 at 5:47 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:21 am EST

Question: I am working on a project where the owner has generators connected through a distribution switchboard that feeds multiple ATS's as a non-separately derived system. The existing ATS's are all 3 pole. The generators are reaching end-of-life and they would like to install new generators (building exterior) connected through a new generator distribution switchboard in an adjacent building, back-feed the existing generator distribution switchboard, and backup the adjacent building's service from the same generators.As the existing ATS's in Building #1 are 3 pole, the new generators will not have a neutral-ground bond.If the new ATS in Building #2 is also 3 pole, the neutrals of the 2 services would be ties together. Is this a violation of 250.24(A)(5)?Can the new ATS in Building #2 be 4 pole with a switched neutral, making the distribution section of Building #2's service switchboard a separately derived system with the neutral-ground bond at Building #2's service disconnect when the ATS is in Normal position, and the neutral-ground bond at Building #1's service disconnect when the ATS is in Emergency position?

Okay, this is a common and tricky situation. Let's break it down and address your questions.

Understanding the Problem: Paralleled Neutrals & Code Violations

The core issue here is paralleling neutrals in a multi-building system where you are trying to share generators. The NEC (National Electrical Code) generally prohibits paralleling neutrals because it can lead to circulating currents, overheating, and potentially dangerous voltage differences between neutral points. The relevant section you mentioned, 250.24(A)(5), speaks to this issue.

Analysis of the Existing System (Building #1) Non-Separately Derived System

You correctly identify that the existing system in Building #1 is a non-separately derived system (NSDS) because the generators backfeed the service entrance equipment. This is why the original installation likely used 3-pole ATSs and did
not have a neutral-ground bond at the generator distribution switchboard. The neutral-ground bond would be located at the service disconnect.

Analyzing Your Proposed Changes
1. 3-Pole ATS in Building #2 (No Switched Neutral)

This is where you'll likely run into a code violation of 250.24(A)(5). If you simply tie the neutral from the generators to the service neutral in Building #2 with a 3-pole ATS, you are effectively paralleling the neutrals of the two services (Building #1 and Building #2)
during normal operation and during generator operation. This is a violation because the normal source neutrals are tied together, and the generator neutral is tied back to both of them.2.

4-Pole ATS in Building #2 (Switched Neutral)

This is a better approach, but you need to get the implementation
exactly right to avoid creating other issues. Let's analyze this option:

ATS in Normal Position (Utility Power)

When the ATS is in the normal position, the neutral-ground bond must be present at Building #2's service entrance equipment. The 4-pole ATS must close the neutral connection between the utility service and the distribution panel in Building #2.

ATS in Emergency Position (Generator Power)

When the ATS is in the emergency position, the 4-pole ATS must
open the neutral connection between the utility service and the distribution panel in Building #2. The generator neutral is then connected to the distribution panel in Building #2. The neutral-ground bond will remain at the building #1's service entrance switchboard.

Important Considerations and Recommendations
Coordination and Interlocks

Implement mechanical or electrical interlocks to ensure that the neutral-ground bond in Building #2 is only present when the utility power is connected and that it is disconnected before the generator connects in emergency mode. This is absolutely critical.

Load Calculations

You
must perform thorough load calculations for both buildings and the generators to ensure the generators are adequately sized and the distribution equipment is properly rated. Consider future load growth.

Selective Coordination

Implement a system of selective coordination. This means that an overcurrent condition is isolated to the nearest upstream device.

Short-Circuit and Coordination Study

Get a short circuit and coordination study for the system. This is especially critical for a multi-building system and will ensure that your overcurrent protective devices (breakers, fuses) are properly sized and coordinated to protect the equipment and personnel.


Ground Fault Protection

Ensure proper ground-fault protection is in place, especially on the service disconnects and the generator distribution switchboard.

Professional Engineering Review

This type of system design is complex and requires careful consideration.

It is strongly recommended that you have a licensed professional engineer (PE) with expertise in electrical power systems review and stamp the design.
They can ensure compliance with all applicable codes and standards and provide specific recommendations tailored to your installation. AHJ Approval

Obtain approval from the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) before starting any work.

Summary
Using a 3-pole ATS in Building #2, which ties the neutral of both services together, will likely violate 250.24(A)(5) and is generally not permitted. Using a 4-pole ATS with a switched neutral in Building #2 is a viable solution if implemented correctly. The key is to ensure the neutral-ground bond is only present at Building #2 when the utility is connected and at Building #1 when the generator is connected.By carefully addressing these points and obtaining professional engineering review, you can design a safe and code-compliant system. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question