Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Sizing a 3ph service

User: chewy6793, Location: Bay Area

Asked on: Tuesday, November 19, 2024 at 12:56 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:22 am EST

Question: I've been reading similar post here, but just wanted to run my understanding of the sizing a main service given a combination of single and three phase loads. I've put together some sample loads and a example main service below.Example Main Service3 Phase, 200A, 120/240V High Leg Delta --> (240V)(200A)(1.73) = 83040VA = 83.040kVA availableLoadsSingle Phase120V, 15 A, pf=0.9 --> (120V)(15A)/0.9 = 2000VA240V, 7A, pf=1 --> (240V)(7A)/1 = 1680kVAThree Phase3) 240V, 1.6A, pf=0.9 --> (240V)(1.6A)(1.73)/.9 = 738.1VA4) 240V, 4A, pf=0.85 --> (240V)(4)(1.730)/.85 = 1953.9VANow I sum all single and three phase VA.Total Used kVA: 6.37My final kVA is way smaller than my avaible, so can I safely say (in this bad example), that my service is adequate?Assuming all my loads are balanced the total max amperage I could see across any phase would be (1000)(6.37kVA)/((1.73)(240V)) = 15.3A. So I could theoretically have a 3ph 20A 120/240V service be adequate for the sample loads listed.Is my rough understanding of the process correct?I'm obviously not an electrician, just interested in understanding the process more. Thank you for taking the time to read through it all.

Okay, let's break down your calculations and understanding of service sizing. You're on the right track, but there are a few key areas where we can refine the approach and ensure accuracy.

Overall Understanding

Your general idea is correct:1. Calculate the VA (Volt-Amps) of each load

This is the apparent power, the total power being delivered before considering power factor.2.

Sum the VA of all loads

This gives you the total apparent power demand.3.

Compare the total VA demand to the service capacity (in VA)

If the demand is less than the capacity, the service is theoretically adequate.4.

Check the amperage per phase

While the total VA is important, you also need to ensure that no single phase is overloaded. This is particularly important with unbalanced loads (which are almost always the case in real-world scenarios).

Where We Need to Refine
1. Accuracy in VA Calculation (especially Single Phase)

While the three-phase calculations look good, it looks like one of your single phase calculations might have an error. I've broken down what your load calculations should be below.2.

Demand Factors & Diversity

You're calculating the absolute maximum load if everything ran at 100% simultaneously. In reality, this rarely happens. "Demand factors" (NEC Article 220) are multipliers that account for the fact that not all loads operate at their maximum capacity at the same time. "Diversity" is a similar concept, acknowledging that different types of loads tend to have peak demands at different times. This is crucial for realistic service sizing and often allows for a much smaller service than a simple sum of all loads.3.

NEC Requirements (Article 220)

The NEC (National Electrical Code) has specific rules for calculating service loads, especially for dwelling units (homes). You must follow these rules for code compliance. This includes:

General lighting and receptacle loads

Calculated based on square footage.


Appliance circuits

Specific requirements for kitchen, laundry, etc.

Large appliances (ranges, dryers, water heaters, HVAC)

Specific demand factors are often applied.


Motors

Sizing conductors and overcurrent protection for motors has very specific rules.

Electric Vehicle Chargers

Specific rules apply for EV chargers, as they present a large load that can run for extended periods.4.

Balancing Loads

While a perfect balance is unlikely, try to distribute single-phase loads as evenly as possible across the available phases to minimize the current imbalance.5.

Continuous Loads

Loads that operate continuously for 3 hours or more are considered "continuous loads" (NEC 210.19(A)(1) and 210.20(A)). The overcurrent device and conductors must be rated for at least 125% of the continuous load. This is typically achieved by limiting continuous loads to 80% of the circuit breaker's rating. This needs to be considered in your service sizing.

Corrected Load Calculations and Examples


Here's a breakdown of your example loads with corrections:
Single Phase 120V, 15A, pf=0.9: (120V 15A) / 0.9 = 2000VA 240V, 7A, pf=1: (240V 7A) / 1 = 1680VA Three Phase 3) 240V, 1.6A, pf=0.9: (240V 1.6A √3) / 0.9 = 738.1VA 4) 240V, 4A, pf=0.85: (240V 4A √3) / 0.85 = 1953.9VATotal VA

2000VA + 1680VA + 738.1VA + 1953.9VA = 6372VA = 6.372kVA

Your Calculation

Looks to be correct.

Example Using Demand Factors (Simplified)


Let's say, for the sake of example, that after applying NEC demand factors, your calculated load for lighting, receptacles, and small appliances is reduced to 50%. Let's also assume one of the three phase load is a continuous load. Here's how you might recalculate the service size:1. Adjusted Lighting/Receptacle Load

Assume a hypothetical 4000VA for general lighting and receptacles. After applying a 50% demand factor: 4000VA
0.5 = 2000VA2.

Continuous Load Sizing

The 240V, 4A, pf=0.85 three-phase load is considered a continuous load, so it must be multiplied by 1.25: 1953.9VA 1.25 = 2442.375VA3.

Total Adjusted Load

2000VA + 1680VA + 738.1VA + 2442.375VA = 6860.475VA = 6.86kVAIn this scenario, your load calculation will now be slightly higher due to the continuous load, however if we have applied a demand factor appropriately, we're still safely above the rating.

Important Considerations for High-Leg Delta
Phase Imbalance

High-leg delta systems are inherently unbalanced. Careful planning is needed to distribute single-phase loads to avoid overloading the "B" phase (the high leg), as it has a lower usable voltage to ground.

High-Leg Identification

The high leg MUST be identified by orange marking tape or paint wherever it is accessible.

Summary


Your understanding is good as a starting point. However, remember:
Don't forget Power Factor Follow the NEC

Service sizing
must be done according to the NEC, including demand factors.

Consider Continuous Loads

Factor these in appropriately.

Balance Loads

Try to distribute single-phase loads evenly.


High-Leg Delta Systems

Be very mindful of the voltage and limitations of the high leg.

This is a Simplified Overview:
Actual service sizing can be quite complex, particularly for commercial and industrial buildings. Consult with a qualified electrician for any real-world installations. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question