User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Tuesday, November 19, 2024 at 8:49 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:23 am EST
Question: On commerical project do you find outdoor receptacles are spec'ed more often to be in a pvc, aluminum or FS/FD box when having to use RGS conduit?I know's there are factors such as project location( near water etc.) and type of job.And I should add I'd imagine that most outdoor boxes for receptacles would have a female threded hub if RGS is being used?
You're right, there's no single "always" answer, and it depends on several factors. However, here's a breakdown of the common practices and why one might be chosen over another when using RGS conduit for outdoor receptacles in commercial projects
Common Scenarios and Box Choices
Aluminum Boxes
Advantages
Corrosion Resistance
Aluminum is very resistant to corrosion, especially in outdoor environments. It develops a protective oxide layer. This makes it well-suited for areas with moisture, rain, and some types of industrial pollutants.
Weight
Lighter than FS/FD or PVC-coated, making installation easier, especially when elevated.
Grounding
Aluminum boxes, when properly bonded, provide a good ground path.
Cost
Usually more economical than PVC-coated steel but can be similar to FS/FD depending on the size and features.
Disadvantages
Galvanic Corrosion
Aluminum can corrode if directly coupled with dissimilar metals (like steel) in the presence of an electrolyte (like water with salts). This is often mitigated by using proper fittings and isolating materials.
Strength
Generally not as physically strong as FS/FD or PVC-coated steel. Vulnerable to physical damage (impacts).
FS/FD Boxes
Advantages
Durability
Made of cast metal (usually iron or aluminum), FS/FD boxes are very robust and resistant to physical damage.
Watertightness
With proper gaskets and fittings, they can provide excellent protection against water ingress.
Threaded Hubs
Readily available with threaded hubs for RGS conduit connections.
Grounding
Good grounding characteristics due to metal construction.
Disadvantages
Corrosion
Ferrous metal FS/FD boxes must be properly finished and painted/coated to prevent rust. Aluminum is a much better choice if the budget allow.
Weight
Heavier than aluminum or PVC.
Cost
Can be more expensive than aluminum, especially if PVC-coated.
Aesthetics
More industrial look.
PVC Boxes
Advantages
Corrosion Resistance
PVC is completely resistant to rust and corrosion from most chemicals and environments, including saltwater.
Cost
Typically the least expensive option.
Weight
Very lightweight.
Disadvantages
Physical Strength
Less robust than aluminum or FS/FD. More susceptible to damage from impacts, temperature extremes (can become brittle in cold weather), and UV degradation (some PVC formulations).
Grounding
Requires a separate grounding conductor to be run to the receptacle. You cannot rely on the box itself for grounding.
Threaded Connections
Requires PVC-to-metal adapters for connecting to RGS conduit, which can be a point of potential water ingress if not installed correctly.
Aesthetics
May not be suitable for high-end architectural designs.
Factors Influencing the Choice1. Environment
Coastal/Saltwater
PVC or aluminum are generally preferred due to their superior corrosion resistance. If using aluminum, ensure proper isolation from dissimilar metals.
Industrial (Chemical Exposure)
Consider the specific chemicals present. PVC may be suitable for many chemicals, but check its compatibility. Aluminum may corrode with certain chemicals.
General Outdoor (Rain, Snow)
Aluminum or FS/FD are usually acceptable, with proper weatherproofing.
High Traffic/Vandalism Prone
FS/FD is often chosen for its durability.2.
Budget
PVC is generally the cheapest, followed by aluminum, and then FS/FD (especially if PVC-coated).3.
Aesthetics
Architectural considerations can play a role. Some clients prefer the look of metal boxes, while others want the less obtrusive appearance of PVC.4.
Mechanical Protection
How likely is the receptacle to be struck by vehicles, equipment, or vandalized?5.
Local Codes
Always check local electrical codes for any specific requirements or restrictions.6.
Specifications
Follow the project specifications meticulously. If they call for a specific box type, that takes precedence.
Threaded Hubs
Yes, you are correct. If using RGS conduit, the outdoor box for receptacles would most likely have a female threaded hub to directly accept the threaded end of the RGS conduit. This provides a secure and weatherproof connection. You can also use threadless compression connectors, with an appropriate adaptor.
In summary: For general outdoor use, aluminum is a very common and often preferred choice for its balance of cost, corrosion resistance, and weight. In harsh environments (coastal, industrial), PVC or high-quality aluminum with proper isolation are good options. For high-traffic areas where physical damage is a concern, FS/FD offers the best protection. Always use proper fittings, gaskets, and sealant to ensure a watertight installation, regardless of the box material. Prioritize safety by ensuring proper grounding of the receptacle and box. Consult local codes and project specifications.* Never mix metals without considering the risks of galvanic corrosion and using appropriate preventative measures. Flag for review