Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: MCC Inspection

User: AGK, Location: Omaha NE

Asked on: Tuesday, November 19, 2024 at 10:15 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:23 am EST

Question: A client has an old MCC (Ca 1949) that has been electrically locked out for about 2-1/2 years. The reason it was locked out can be basically summarized as "someone thought" it was unsafe and made the comment to management. As a result, the maintenance superintendent had it locked out. In his words, it was done "out of an abundance of caution". I would like to have the MCC inspected by an independent qualified party to determine if it is safe to return to service or not. This is beyond my expertise so I am looking for suggestions on what qualifications are needed and where to begin my search. Thanks in advance.

Okay, that's a tricky situation. You're doing the right thing by seeking an independent assessment. Here's a breakdown of the qualifications you should look for in an inspector, where to find them, and what to ask for

Essential Qualifications for the Inspector:
Licensed Professional Engineer (PE)

A PE license demonstrates competence and accountability. Specifically, you want a PE licensed in

electrical engineering
and ideally experienced with industrial power systems. They should be able to stamp the inspection report, providing added credibility.
Extensive Experience with Old Motor Control Centers (MCCs)

This is CRITICAL. Modern MCCs are built to different standards and use different components. Someone who primarily works on new installations may not be familiar with the specific failure modes, obsolescence issues, and maintenance requirements of a 1949 MCC. Look for experience troubleshooting, maintaining, and/or retrofitting MCCs from the mid-20th century.

Thorough Knowledge of Applicable Codes and Standards

While some modern codes may not directly apply to an existing 1949 installation (grandfathering), the inspector should understand the
original codes in place when the MCC was installed (likely based on NEMA and/or early versions of the NEC). They also need to know how modern safety practices (e.g., NFPA 70E - Electrical Safety in the Workplace) would apply if the MCC is returned to service.

Experience with Arc Flash Studies

If the MCC is returned to service, you'll need an arc flash hazard analysis conducted. Ideally, the inspector would be qualified to perform this study, or at least be able to recommend someone reputable. Arc flash risk assessment wasn't a consideration in 1949!

Familiarity with Older Components

They should be able to identify obsolete components, understand their failure characteristics, and suggest appropriate replacements or workarounds. Think about things like:
Starter contactors (likely very different from modern designs) Overload relays (thermal vs. electronic) Wiring insulation (rubber or cloth-based, likely degraded) Bus bar integrity (corrosion, loosening)

Independent and Impartial

The inspector should have no vested interest in selling you equipment or services for the MCC. Their primary goal should be to provide an unbiased assessment of its condition.

Where to Find Qualified Inspectors



Electrical Testing Companies

These companies specialize in testing, maintenance, and inspection of electrical equipment. Look for NETA (InterNational Electrical Testing Association) accredited companies. NETA accreditation demonstrates adherence to specific standards and practices.
Crucially, verify their experience with old MCCs.

Engineering Consulting Firms

Many engineering firms have power systems engineers with experience in industrial settings. Again, emphasize the need for experience with vintage equipment.

Retired Electrical Engineers/Technicians

A retired engineer or technician who worked extensively with older equipment may have the necessary knowledge. However, make sure they are still up-to-date on current safety practices and have professional liability insurance. Check references very carefully.


Industry Associations

Contact relevant industry associations (e.g., IEEE - Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) and ask for referrals to qualified consultants.

Local Electrical Contractors (with a caveat)

Some established electrical contractors, particularly those who have been around a long time and work in industrial settings, may have experience with older MCCs.
However, carefully assess their qualifications and ensure they are truly independent. You don't want someone who will simply recommend replacing the entire MCC without a thorough assessment.

What to Ask Potential Inspectors (Key Questions)


"What experience do you have specifically inspecting and evaluating motor control centers from the 1940s and 1950s?"
(Listen carefully to their response. This is the most important question).2. "Can you provide references from previous clients where you have inspected similar equipment?"3. "What codes and standards will you be using as a basis for your inspection?" (They should be able to articulate the relevant historical and modern codes/standards).4. "Will you provide a written report with detailed findings, including photographs and recommendations?"5. "What is your professional liability insurance coverage?"6. "What is your approach to assessing the safety of the MCC, considering its age and potential obsolescence?"7. "What are your fees for the inspection and report?" (Get a clear breakdown of costs).8. "Are you able to perform an arc flash hazard analysis, or can you recommend someone who is qualified?"9. "What potential challenges do you anticipate with inspecting such an old MCC?" (This shows their awareness and experience).10. "What are your qualifications in electrical engineering, including licenses, certifications, and relevant training?"What the Inspection Should Include



Visual Inspection

A thorough visual inspection of all components, looking for signs of: Corrosion Damage (cracks, breaks, etc.) Overheating (discoloration, melting) Loose connections Deteriorated insulation (cracking, crumbling) Evidence of rodent or insect infestation

Insulation Resistance Testing (Megger Testing)

This tests the integrity of the insulation on wiring and components.


Contact Resistance Testing

Checking the resistance of contacts in starters and breakers.

Component Verification

Identifying all components and determining if they are still functional and meet the original specifications. Identifying obsolete components and potential replacements.


Bus Bar Inspection

Checking for corrosion, loose connections, and proper grounding.

Grounding System Verification

Ensuring the grounding system is intact and effective.


Safety Interlock Testing

Verifying that all safety interlocks (e.g., door interlocks) are functioning correctly.

Documentation Review

Reviewing any available documentation (drawings, manuals, maintenance records) to understand the MCC's original design and history.


Load Calculation Review

Checking if the existing connected loads are within the MCC's rated capacity.

Arc Flash Hazard Assessment (or Recommendation)

A critical step to determine the potential arc flash hazards and required PPE if the MCC is returned to service.


Written Report

A detailed report summarizing the findings, including photographs, recommendations for repairs or upgrades, and a conclusion regarding the MCC's safety and suitability for return to service.

Important Considerations



Cost vs. Risk

Returning a 75+ year old MCC to service can be risky and expensive. Even if the inspection determines that it
can be made safe, the cost of repairs, upgrades, and ongoing maintenance may be higher than replacing it with a modern MCC. Weigh the costs carefully.

Obsolescence

Many components in a 1949 MCC will be obsolete and difficult or impossible to replace. This means that even minor failures could result in extended downtime.

Safety Culture

The fact that the MCC was locked out "out of an abundance of caution" suggests that there may be a safety concern. Address those concerns before returning the MCC to service. Consider involving the employees who raised the initial concerns in the inspection process.


Documentation

It's highly likely that the original documentation (drawings, manuals) is incomplete or missing. This will make the inspection and any subsequent repairs more challenging.

Modern Alternatives

Explore modern MCC alternatives. Solid State relays, soft starters and variable frequency drives can provide better performance and protection at a reasonable cost.


Consider staged replacement
. If the full replacement of the MCC will break the budget, consider having a qualified tech remove and replace one or two buckets in the MCC per year.

In summary, finding the right inspector with the right experience is absolutely critical. Don't rush this process. Thoroughly vet potential inspectors to ensure they have the knowledge and expertise to assess the safety and suitability of your 1949 MCC. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question