User: mchmela, Location: Florida
Asked on: Tuesday, November 19, 2024 at 12:44 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:24 am EST
Question: Hello,I'm currently working on a project for a school where we're remodeling the chiller yard. We have 3 pumps in the chiller yard that originate in the existing MDP, the MDP is pad mounted and the conduits come into the bottom through the slab. We've installed a second MDP in the chiller yard and need to relocate the circuits to that one but are trying to re-utilize the existing underground conduits.My foreman wanted to run LFNC as a sleeve through the old MDP to reroute the circuits but the inspector told us we can't do that. He said there's a way to do it but won't give us any information as to how it can be done without chipping up the concrete and rerouting them. Does anybody have any clue how we can do this?I hope I've been clear in the situation and any information received is appreciated.
Okay, this is a common problem, and there are a few code-compliant ways to handle it. The inspector is likely balking at the LFNC because it's not suitable as a permanent raceway inside a panelboard (MDP). The LFNC would be a violation of 312.5(C). Here's a breakdown of the likely methods, what the inspector might be looking for, and things to consider
The Key Principle: Maintaining Raceway Integrity
The fundamental goal is to maintain a continuous, code-compliant raceway system from the original underground conduits, through the existing MDP enclosure, and into the new MDP. You need to avoid using the MDP enclosure itself as a raceway (which is what the LFNC idea likely implied).
Possible Solutions (and considerations)
Nipple and Coupling Method (The Most Likely Solution)
Concept
Extend rigid metal conduit (RMC or IMC) directly through the existing MDP enclosure. Think of it like a bridge.
Procedure
Carefully disconnect the conductors from the existing pump circuits within the old MDP. Verify dead with a meter! This is critical.2. Remove the breakers, lugs, or anything else that would obstruct a clear path through the enclosure.3. Determine conduit size
Use calculations based on the wire size and number of conductors to ensure the existing conduits and new conduits meet NEC requirements.4.
Cut and Thread RMC/IMC
Cut lengths of rigid metal conduit (RMC or IMC) to extend completely through the existing MDP. The conduit needs to extend far enough on both sides to properly connect to the existing conduits outside of the panel.5.
Install Couplings and Locknuts
Use appropriate couplings (e.g., rigid couplings, set-screw couplings) and locknuts to connect the new RMC/IMC sections to the existing underground conduits outside the bottom of the old MDP. The couplings need to be accessible.6.
Secure the Conduit
Secure the rigid conduit sections to the enclosure of the existing MDP using locknuts on both sides of the panel wall, ensuring good mechanical connection. This essentially makes the existing MDP a "junction box" that the conduits pass through.7.
Pull Conductors
Carefully pull the conductors through the newly installed rigid conduit. Use pulling lubricant.8.
Terminate in New MDP
Terminate the conductors in the new MDP on properly sized breakers or lugs.9.
Bonding and Grounding
Crucially, properly bond the rigid conduit system according to NEC 250.92. Use bonding bushings and grounding jumpers as needed to ensure a continuous ground path. Check the requirements based on the voltage.
10.
Inspect
The inspector will likely want to see that the conduits are properly supported, the connections are tight, and the grounding/bonding is correct.
Why this is likely the answer
This method maintains a continuous, approved raceway system. The existing MDP is simply acting as a pass-through point. It avoids the prohibited use of LFNC as a permanent raceway inside the panel.
Considerations
Space
Ensure you have enough physical space within the old MDP to work and run the conduit without damaging existing components that are not being relocated.
Conduit Alignment
Precise measurement and cutting are essential for proper alignment. A conduit bender might be needed for slight offsets.
Existing Conduit Integrity
Inspect the existing conduits for damage or corrosion. If they are significantly damaged, this method may not be viable.
Support
Ensure adequate support for the rigid conduit system, both inside and outside the MDP.2.
Junction Box Above the MDP (Less Likely, but Possible)
Concept
Install a large junction box above the existing MDP. Cut the existing conduits just below the MDP. Run new RMC/IMC from the existing conduits into the junction box. Then, run new RMC/IMC from the junction box to the new MDP.
Why it's less likely
This method involves more cutting and splicing of conductors, which is generally avoided if possible. It also requires finding a suitable location and mounting the junction box.
Considerations
Accessibility
The junction box must be accessible.
Fill Calculations
The junction box must be sized according to NEC requirements based on the number of conductors and conduit entries.
Splices
All splices must be made in the junction box using approved methods (e.g., wire nuts, crimp connectors).
Cost
Added cost of the junction box and materials.3.
Custom Transition Piece (Highly Unlikely, and Potentially Expensive)
Concept
A fabricator could potentially create a custom metal "transition piece" that bolts to the bottom of the old MDP and provides a smooth, code-compliant transition to the new conduits.
Why it's highly unlikely
This is a very specialized solution and would likely be expensive. It would require precise measurements and engineering to ensure it meets all code requirements. The inspector would likely scrutinize this very carefully.
Why the Inspector Rejected LFNC
NEC 312.5(C)
"Cables and conductors installed in cabinets, cutout boxes, and meter socket enclosures shall comply with 312.5(C)(1) through (C)(6) as applicable. ...
(C)(1) Cables shall be secured to the cabinet, cutout box, or meter socket enclosure. (C)(2) Raceways shall terminate at the cabinet, cutout box, or meter socket enclosure." The LFNC doesn't really terminate at the cabinet in a way that the NEC intends, it would have to be routed through it. Suitability
LFNC is not typically considered a permanent raceway solution in this type of application. It's more often used for flexible connections to motors or equipment.
Mechanical Protection
LFNC doesn't provide the same level of mechanical protection as rigid metal conduit.
Misuse
The inspector likely interpreted the use of LFNC as using the panelboard itself as a raceway, which is a violation.
Key Things to Discuss with the Inspector
Your Proposed Method
Clearly explain exactly how you plan to run the conduit and terminate it in both MDPs. Provide sketches if necessary.
Materials
Specify the type of conduit (RMC or IMC) and fittings you intend to use.
Grounding/Bonding
Detail your grounding and bonding plan.
Ask for Clarification
Politely ask the inspector for clarification on exactly what he/she finds objectionable. Sometimes, understanding their specific concern can help you tailor your solution. Say something like, "Inspector, we appreciate your guidance. Could you please elaborate on what specific code section you feel is being violated by our proposed method?"
Important Safety Note
De-energize and Lockout/Tagout
Always de-energize and lockout/tagout all circuits before working on any electrical equipment. Verify dead with a meter!
Qualified Personnel:* All electrical work must be performed by qualified and licensed electricians.Good luck with your project! Let me know if you have any other questions. Flag for review