User: electricalintern, Location: PA
Asked on: Tuesday, November 19, 2024 at 1:29 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:24 am EST
Question: The electrical room houses a main service disconnect serving 10 tenants—5 on the lower level and 5 on the upper floor—along with a separate house panel.My tenant is taking over two tenant spaces:Space A has a 400 AMP, 208V, 3-phase service.Space B has a 200 AMP, 208V, 3-phase service.Both panels in the tenant spaces are MLO (Main Lug Only).The base building engineer prefers not to combine the services into a single 600 AMP, 208V, 3-phase service.Is it acceptable for the panels to remain as MLO?Additionally, the 400 AMP service will supply two subpanels, each rated at 125 AMP.
Let's break down the situation and address each question
1. MLO Panels Acceptance
Yes, it is generally acceptable for the panels to remain as MLO (Main Lug Only) in this scenario, provided they meet code requirements and are properly protected by upstream overcurrent devices. Here's why: Code Compliance (NEC)
The NEC (National Electrical Code) allows for MLO panels when they are properly protected by an overcurrent device (like a breaker or fuses) at their point of supply. This means the upstream disconnect (likely in the electrical room) is providing the overcurrent protection.
Existing Installation
Since the existing installation presumably passed inspections and complies with the code at the time of installation, changing to a main breaker panel isn't necessarily required just because the tenant is expanding.
Engineering Preference
The engineer's preference to avoid combining the services likely stems from factors like:
Cost
Combining services involves new conduit runs, potentially larger conductors, and a more substantial disconnect switch, which is expensive.
Disruption
Combining services usually requires an extended outage to the affected tenant spaces, impacting operations.
Capacity
If the existing main service is near its capacity, adding a 600A service might require upgrading the entire service, which is a very costly and disruptive project.
Important Considerations for MLO Panels
Clear Labeling
Absolutely essential! The MLO panels MUST be clearly and permanently labeled to indicate their source of power (the disconnect switch in the electrical room) and the rating of the overcurrent device protecting them. This labeling is critical for safety and future maintenance.
Accessibility of Overcurrent Device
The disconnect switch/breaker that feeds the MLO panel MUST be readily accessible to the tenant. This allows them to safely shut off power to the panel in case of an emergency.
Proper Wiring & Connections
Ensure all connections within the MLO panel are properly torqued and that conductors are appropriately sized and rated for the load.
2. 400A Service Supplying Two 125A Subpanels
This is generally acceptable, but requires careful consideration: Load Calculation
The most critical factor is whether the actual load connected to the two 125A subpanels combined will exceed 400A. A proper load calculation is mandatory to ensure the 400A service is sufficient. This calculation must account for all connected loads, their demand factors (i.e., how much power they draw simultaneously), and any future expansion plans.
Overcurrent Protection
Each 125A subpanel must be protected by a 125A breaker or fuses in the 400A panel. This is non-negotiable. This protects the subpanel and the conductors feeding it.
Conductor Sizing
The conductors feeding each 125A subpanel MUST be sized appropriately to carry the 125A load (after derating for temperature, conduit fill, etc.).
Conduit Sizing
The conduit or raceway between the 400A panel and each 125A subpanel must be properly sized to accommodate the conductors.
Summary of Requirements for Your Situation
Clear Labeling
MLO panels MUST be clearly and permanently labeled with the source of power and the overcurrent protection rating.2.
Accessibility
The tenant must have easy access to the disconnect/breaker feeding the MLO panels.3.
Load Calculation
A thorough load calculation is required to ensure the 400A service can handle the two 125A subpanels.4.
Overcurrent Protection
Each 125A subpanel must be protected by a 125A breaker in the 400A panel.5.
Conductor and Conduit Sizing
All conductors and conduits must be properly sized for the loads and in accordance with the NEC.6.
Inspection
This work will require inspection by the local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). Be sure to obtain all necessary permits and schedule inspections.7.
Documentation
Keep all load calculations, panel schedules, and other relevant documentation on file for future reference and potential inspections.
Recommendations
Engage a Licensed Electrical Contractor
Hire a qualified and licensed electrical contractor to perform the work and ensure it is done safely and to code.
Review with Base Building Engineer
Have the electrical contractor review the plans with the base building engineer to ensure they are comfortable with the proposed solution.
Obtain AHJ Approval: Before starting any work, obtain the necessary permits and approvals from the local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). They will be the final arbiter of code compliance.By addressing these considerations, you can ensure a safe and compliant electrical installation for your tenant. Good luck! Flag for review