Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Two Structures: 230.2 allowance

User: augie47, Location: Tennessee

Asked on: Tuesday, November 19, 2024 at 4:36 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:25 am EST

Question: Please confirm my thinking....Existing Structure "A" has a 400 amp meter, a 200 panel and a 200 amp disconnect feeding Structure "B" via an underground 3" conduit.Contractor wants to add 2nd 200 amp panel at "B"(Total load on the two structures will be less than 400 amp)1st thought was two 200 amp feeders through the 3" conduit but 2017 Code will not allow 2 feeders to separate building.That led to Plan 1 to install one 400 amp feeder to a j box and tap to the two 200 amp M/B panels.Plan 2 is to come directly off the meter base installing service conductors to Building B using the Exception 3 to 230.40Question being:: Can 2 sets of service conductors be installed in the conduit with each set terminating in 200 amp adjacent panels based in the wording in 230.2 classifying two sets 1/0 and larger as one service

You've correctly identified some key issues and are thinking along the right lines. Let's break down your analysis and consider the viability of each plan

Understanding the Core Issues
Feeders vs. Service Conductors

This is crucial. Feeders originate
after the service disconnecting means. Service conductors run from the utility's point of connection (usually the meter) to the service disconnecting means.

Multiple Buildings

The NEC has specific rules about supplying multiple buildings from a single service. You're right to focus on 230.40 and related sections.

Conduit Fill

Even if the electrical plan complies with the NEC, you always must consider the physical fill capacity of the conduit.

Analysis of Your Proposed Plans
Original Thought: Two 200A Feeders

As you noted, 2017 NEC prohibits two feeders to a separate building. This is because two feeders are considered as two separate services and are not allowed without special permission.

Plan 1: Single 400A Feeder to a Junction Box



Feeder

If this is a feeder (originating after the main disconnect at Structure A), then a single 400A feeder is permissible.

Taps

Tapping the 400A feeder in a junction box to feed the two 200A panels is allowed,
provided you follow the tap rules in NEC 240.21. Key considerations:

Tap Length

The length of the tap conductors is critical. Shorter taps require less ampacity.

Overcurrent Protection

You must have overcurrent protection (200A breakers) at the end of each tap, located in the panelboards.


Physical Space

Ensure the junction box is adequately sized to handle the conductors and connections, and meets working clearance requirements.

Feeder Size
: The feeder must be sized to carry all of the load. A load calculation is mandatory. NEC Article 220 and 310 are important when determining the size of the feeder and the method of running the conductors. Plan 2: Two Sets of Service Conductors Directly from the Meter



NEC 230.2 and Exception 3

This is where it gets tricky. You're referencing the exception that might allow multiple sets of service conductors under certain conditions.

Your interpretation is incorrect.
While it's true that 230.2(A) (1) permits multiple sets of service entrance conductors from the meter, this still usually terminates into ONE service disconnect. You're aiming to terminate each service entrance conductor to a separate service disconnect and that is not typically permitted. 230.40 Exception 3 does permit more than one service to a single building. One use of the code is for large-capacity loads, or could allow two services for different purposes such as fire pumps or emergency systems. This might be used for large loads but that is not clear in the original question.

The Best Approach

Based on your description, Plan 1 (a single 400A feeder with taps) is likely the most practical and code-compliant solution if your total load is indeed within the 400A capacity of the existing service.Critical Steps to Take1. Load Calculation

Perform a thorough load calculation for both buildings. This calculation must demonstrate that the 400A service is adequate. Don't just assume. NEC Article 220 outlines the requirements for load calculations.2.

Feeder and Tap Sizing

Based on the load calculation, determine the correct size of the 400A feeder and the tap conductors, ensuring compliance with NEC 240.21.
3.


Conduit Fill Calculation

Verify that the conductors selected for the feeder (and any grounding conductors) will fit within the existing 3" conduit, adhering to NEC Chapter 9 tables.4.

Grounding and Bonding

Ensure proper grounding and bonding throughout the system, following NEC Article 250. This is critical for safety.
5.


Local Amendments

Check for any local amendments to the NEC in your jurisdiction. Local codes can sometimes modify or add to the national code.6.

Permitting and Inspection

Obtain the necessary permits and have the work inspected by a qualified electrical inspector.

In Summary
Avoid trying to run two sets of service conductors from the meter to separate panels in the second building without very specific justification under 230.40. It's complex and likely unnecessary. Focus on using a single feeder, properly sized and protected, with appropriate taps to the two 200A panels.* Prioritize a meticulous load calculation and code compliance.

Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance only. Consult with a licensed and qualified electrician or electrical engineer for design and installation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question