User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Tuesday, November 19, 2024 at 8:57 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:25 am EST
Question: Having argument with GC as phase conductors shorted an caused a small fire.Existing 208v 3P-40A breaker feeding a disconnect switch with 30A fuses for a food warmer. The existing wiring is #8's.We had to relocate the kitchen warmer about 20' away to a temporary location. They wanted the disconnect relocated along with the warmer and a splice box where the disconnect was to extend the wiring to the new disconnect/warmer temp location.We did not relocate the disconnect and left it in it's existing location and ran new wiring(#10's) from the load side of the disconnect to the new(temporary) location for the warmer.We took the stance that the 40a breaker on the panel should have tripped. And also it would be a code violation to splice the existing #8's to #10's and run from splice box and extend them to the new temporary disconnect switch location. We said leaving the 30a fused disconnect in place and running #10' from the load side to the new warmer location was code compliant.Does this make sense???
Okay, let's break down this situation. You're correct to be concerned about the safety and code compliance of this modification. Here's an analysis of your argument and the relevant NEC considerations
Your Stance: Correct and Defensible
Your position is sound. Leaving the existing fused disconnect in place and running new #10 wire from the load side of the disconnect to the relocated warmer is generally a safer and more code-compliant approach than splicing #8 to #10. Here's why:1. Overcurrent Protection at the Warmer
You're relying on the 30A fuses in the disconnect to protect the #10 wiring. Since #10 copper wire is typically rated for 30 amps at 75 degrees Celsius, you are compliant with the use of #10's on a 30 amp fused disconnect.2.
Splicing Wire Sizes (NEC 110.14(A) and associated tables)
You're absolutely right. Splicing #8 to #10 wire and then protecting that entire run with a 40A breaker is problematic. If a fault occurs on the #10 portion of the circuit before reaching the 30A fuses, the 40A breaker might not trip quickly enough to protect the #10 wire from overheating and potentially causing a fire. Technically, the NEC doesn't explicitly prohibit splicing different wire sizes. However, 110.14(A) requires that connections be made to be electrically and mechanically sound. The NEC requires the ampacity of the smaller conductor to be protected by the correct OCPD. This requirement makes it a defacto code violation due to safety concerns.
3.
Selective Coordination (Limited Consideration in this Case)
While not a primary concern here, your approach helps maintain some level of selective coordination. The 30A fuses in the disconnect should trip before the 40A breaker in the panel in most fault scenarios affecting the warmer. Splicing and running #10 all the way back would eliminate that benefit.4.
The 40A Breaker
The 40A breaker is indeed oversized for the #10 wiring if it were directly connected to the panel. However, it's protecting the #8 wire run to the disconnect, which is acceptable.
Why Their Proposed Solution is Problematic
Lack of Protection for Smaller Conductor
The main issue is that the #10 wire is not adequately protected against overcurrent before it reaches the 30A fuses. A fault on the #10 portion of the circuit would be cleared by the 40A breaker which is an overcurrent situation for the #10 wire.
Potential for Overheating
As mentioned, the #10 wire could overheat and become a fire hazard before the 40A breaker trips.
NEC Considerations (Key Sections)
NEC 240.4(D): Protection of Conductors. This section is critical. It generally requires that conductors be protected at their rated ampacity. Your proposed method complies because the #10 wire is protected by the 30A fuses. NEC 110.14(A): Electrical Connections. As noted above, connections must be electrically and mechanically sound. NEC 210.20(A): Overcurrent Protection. Overcurrent devices must be rated or set to protect the circuit they serve. The 40A breaker is acceptable for the #8 conductors, and the 30A fuses are acceptable for the #10 conductors downstream of the disconnect.
In summary
You are correct in your assessment. Your solution is the safer and more code-compliant option. Running new #10 from the load side of the fused disconnect provides proper overcurrent protection. The proposed alternative of splicing #8 to #10 and relying solely on the 40A breaker for protection is a code violation and a potential fire hazard.
Recommendation
Document your reasoning and cite the relevant NEC articles. Explain the safety concerns clearly to the GC and the customer. If necessary, involve an electrical inspector to resolve the disagreement and ensure the installation is safe and compliant.
Important Note: This is a general analysis based on the information provided. Always consult the most recent edition of the NEC and local amendments, and seek the opinion of a qualified electrical inspector for specific projects. Electrical work can be dangerous, so ensure that all work is performed by qualified individuals and in accordance with applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review