Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Square D breaker tripping

User: Electron_Sam78, Location: Palm Bay, FL

Asked on: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at 7:30 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:26 am EST

Question: I have a Square D Powerpact MJP36600 600 amp breaker that kept tripping with loaded or unloaded and with or without power. Upon dissecting the breaker, It turns out that the actuator/solenoid was tripping it due to continuous spring tension from the solenoid applied to the tripping mechanism. Does anyone know how the internals are supposed to work? It seems that the solenoid should have reverse spring tension keeping it in and that the trip unit should fire it upon a trip sense. I ended up removing the solenoid to get the panel back in service due to the high priority the fed equipment had and it is protected upstream at the switchgear. Picture of the solenoid attached.

You've uncovered a key element of the Powerpact MJP's tripping mechanism, and your observation that the solenoid seems to be acting in reverse is insightful. Here's a breakdown of how the internals are supposed to work and what might have gone wrong

Understanding the Powerpact MJP Trip System (General Principles):
Stored Energy Operation

The Powerpact MJP, like many molded case circuit breakers (MCCBs), employs a stored energy mechanism. This means the breaker is designed to be manually charged by pushing the handle up and down. This action compresses a spring or sets a mechanism that stores the mechanical energy needed for a fast and reliable opening.


Trip Unit Control

The trip unit (the electronic brain of the breaker) monitors current, voltage, and other parameters. When it detects an overcurrent, short circuit, ground fault, or other fault condition, it sends a signal to initiate the tripping process.

Solenoid (Shunt Trip/Undervoltage Release) Role

The solenoid you describe is likely either a shunt trip or an undervoltage release coil (or a combination of both, depending on the specific configuration). These are
optional features:

Shunt Trip

This allows the breaker to be tripped remotely by applying voltage to the solenoid. The signal originates from something like a fire alarm system, a remote control switch, or another protection relay.

Undervoltage Release

This trips the breaker when the voltage supplying the load drops below a certain threshold. It's a safety feature to prevent equipment from restarting unexpectedly after a power outage.


Normal Operation (Without Fault)

The breaker is closed (ON). The stored energy mechanism is charged.

Crucially, the solenoid (either shunt trip or undervoltage release) should normally be in a
resting state, not actively applying constant tripping force.
It should be held in place by either spring tension or a latching mechanism. A small mechanical latch (or other holding mechanism) keeps the tripping mechanism in a stable, "armed" position. Tripping Operation (With Fault)

The trip unit detects a fault. The trip unit energizes the solenoid (shunt trip) or de-energizes the solenoid (undervoltage release). The solenoid's action releases the stored energy mechanism. The stored energy mechanism rapidly drives the breaker contacts open, interrupting the fault current.

What's Likely Happened in Your Case

Given your description, it seems one of these has occurred:1.

Failure of a Holding Mechanism

The latch, spring, or other component responsible for holding the solenoid in its
resting position has failed or is broken. This is the most probable cause. Without that holding force, the solenoid is constantly pushing on the tripping mechanism.2.

Solenoid Coil Issue

It's possible (but less likely) that the solenoid coil itself has a problem causing it to be partially energized even when it shouldn't be. This could be due to shorted windings or insulation breakdown.3.

Trip Unit Malfunction

While you ruled out the trip unit by stating the tripping still occurred without power, it is possible that an internal component in the unit is sending a constant signal to the shunt trip or undervoltage release circuit.4.

Mechanical Binding

If the breaker has been subject to corrosion or abuse, there could be mechanical binding in the tripping linkage preventing it from operating freely, leading to a sensitive trip point.

Why Removing the Solenoid "Fixed" It

By removing the solenoid, you eliminated the constant force that was triggering the tripping mechanism. The underlying fault (the broken holding mechanism, etc.) is still present, but without the solenoid applying pressure, the breaker stays closed
until a genuine overcurrent or short circuit occurs.

Dangers of Operating Without the Solenoid



Loss of Remote Tripping (If it's a shunt trip)

The breaker can no longer be tripped remotely by a fire alarm or other emergency system.

Loss of Undervoltage Protection (If it's an undervoltage release)

The breaker will not trip on low voltage conditions, potentially damaging connected equipment during brownouts.


Compromised Safety

The breaker's overall protection scheme is no longer functioning as intended.

What You Should Do


Replace the Breaker

The safest and most reliable solution is to replace the breaker with a new or properly refurbished unit. Molded case circuit breakers are not typically designed for field repair of internal components.2.

Contact a Qualified Electrician/Square D Representative

Consult with a licensed electrician experienced with Square D Powerpact breakers. They can: Confirm the exact type of solenoid (shunt trip, undervoltage release, or both). Inspect the breaker more thoroughly to pinpoint the root cause of the failure. Advise on the best course of action (replacement, potential warranty claim, etc.).3.

Do Not Attempt Extensive DIY Repair

Disassembling and attempting to repair a large molded case circuit breaker yourself is extremely dangerous if you don't have the proper training and equipment. These breakers store significant energy and have complex mechanical components.

Important Safety Note:
Work on electrical equipment is inherently dangerous. Ensure the circuit is completely de-energized and locked out/tagged out before performing any inspection or maintenance.* Wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), including safety glasses and insulated gloves.In conclusion, your diagnosis is likely correct: the solenoid shouldn't be constantly applying tripping force. Replacing the breaker is the recommended course of action to restore full functionality and safety. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question