User: ocoee, Location: Golden Co
Asked on: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at 9:01 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:26 am EST
Question: I have a 120 208 three phase MDP. 1200 amp bussing. We could do a supply side connection but would rather not if there is a way around it.The MDP has no main breaker and is 25 years old and located in a large church. We would like to keep this equipment for the expenses of replacement make this project a non starter.My back feed breaker will be 300 amps. My buss bar is 1200 but no main breaker exists or is able to be installed. Is there a way to install my backed breaker when no main exists.Currently, in the MDP there is 700 amp breaker feeding some more distribution equipment. a 200 amp breaker feeding a panel. and 2. 100 amp breakers feeding other equipment. A total of four handles to disconnect the entire service.My guess is that I can not install a pv breaker in this situation. because..... A total of 1100 amp can be pulled through the bussing before any on the four load breakers would trip. plus the current on the back feed breaker 240 amp MAX I. would exceed the buss bar rating. Plus there is room for more load breakers to be added increasing the total load beyond what is there now.Thought?Thanks
You've correctly identified the problem. Let's break it down and explore your options.
The Problem: Overcurrent Protection and Busbar Rating
You've correctly pinpointed the core issue: Busbar Rating vs. Potential Current Draw
Your 1200A busbar could potentially be subjected to currents exceeding its rating if all loads and the backfed PV breaker are active simultaneously. While it's unlikely all loads will always be at their maximum, code requires you to design for worst-case scenarios.
No Main Breaker
Without a main breaker, there's no single point of overcurrent protection for the busbar. The existing breakers only protect their individual downstream circuits, not the bus itself.
NEC Requirements
The NEC requires that the sum of the overcurrent protection devices connected to the busbar (including backfed breakers) cannot exceed the busbar rating, or that engineering supervision determines the worst case load calculations and demonstrates the bus is suitable for the designed maximum load.
Why a Standard Backfeed Breaker Won't Work (As You Suspect)
You're right. A standard backfeed breaker installation, without addressing the potential for exceeding the busbar rating, is a code violation and a safety hazard.
Potential Solutions (Ordered from Best to Worst)
Engineering Supervision with a Load Study
Detailed Load Study
A qualified electrical engineer can perform a comprehensive load study of the church's electrical usage. This involves: Analyzing historical utility bills to determine peak demand. Surveying all existing loads, their typical usage patterns, and their maximum potential draw. Accounting for any future planned load additions.
NEC Article 705.12(D)(2)
Allows for a properly designed and installed system, under engineering supervision, where the sum of overcurrent devices exceeds the buss rating when the calculated load does not exceed the ampacity of the busbar.
Engineering Certification
The engineer would provide calculations and documentation demonstrating that, even with the backfed PV breaker, the busbar will never be overloaded under any realistically foreseeable operating conditions. This may involve assumptions about diversity (not all loads being on at once) and demand factors.
Important Considerations
This approach relies heavily on the accuracy of the load study and the validity of the engineer's assumptions. It might require ongoing monitoring of load usage to ensure compliance.
Pros
Potentially the least expensive option.
Cons
Risky and reliant on engineering calculations and assumptions. Requires ongoing monitoring. Might not be acceptable to the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction).2.
Line Side Tap (Supply Side Connection)
Connect upstream from the MDP
This involves tapping into the service conductors before they enter the MDP.
Requires proper overcurrent protection
A fusible disconnect or circuit breaker would be required at the tap point.
Utility Coordination
Requires coordination with the utility company, as it affects their service equipment.
NEC Article 230
Governs service equipment and conductors.
Pros
Safest option from a code compliance and overcurrent protection standpoint. Completely bypasses the limitations of the existing MDP.
Cons
Most expensive option. Requires utility involvement and potentially new equipment.3.
Load Reduction with Backfeed Breaker Sizing
Aggressive Load Reduction
Identify and reduce existing loads on the MDP. This might involve replacing energy-intensive equipment with more efficient alternatives or relocating circuits to other panels.
Downsize Backfeed Breaker
Reduce the size of the backfeed breaker to a point where the sum of the existing breakers and the backfeed breaker is within the 1200A busbar rating.
Extremely Limited
This approach is only feasible if you can significantly reduce existing loads and still achieve a meaningful PV system size.
Pros
Potentially less expensive than a full system upgrade or line-side tap.
Cons
Requires significant load reduction, which might not be practical. Limits the PV system size.4.
(NOT Recommended) Ignoring the Issue
Installing the Backfeed Breaker without Addressing the Busbar Capacity
This is a violation of the NEC and creates a significant safety hazard. It is not a viable option.
Recommendations
Contact a Qualified Electrical Engineer
The first step is to consult with a licensed electrical engineer experienced in PV system design and NEC compliance. They can perform a load study and assess the feasibility of option #1.2.
Discuss with the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
Before proceeding with any solution, discuss your plans with the local electrical inspector. They will have the final say on what is acceptable.3.
Get Bids for All Viable Options
Obtain bids for both the load study and the line-side tap solution to determine the most cost-effective and code-compliant approach.
Important Considerations
Age of Equipment
The 25-year-old MDP is nearing the end of its useful life. While you want to avoid replacement now, factor in potential future maintenance costs.
Future Load Growth
Consider any plans for future electrical load additions in the church.
Documentation: Thorough documentation, including load studies, calculations, and engineering certifications, is crucial for code compliance and future reference.In summary, you cannot* simply install a 300A backfeed breaker into your existing MDP without addressing the busbar capacity and ensuring code compliance. Your choices are to engineer the system with an extensive load study, reduce loads to accommodate a smaller PV system, or upgrade to a supply side connection. The first step is to consult with a qualified electrical engineer and discuss your options with the AHJ. Good luck! Flag for review