User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at 10:19 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:27 am EST
Question: GC I'm bidding project to wrotew this in thier document and wants me to agree. I think it's BS. The engineer/PE should be responsible to show all required work. Thoughts?
You're right to be cautious. That statement sounds like a way for the GC to shift responsibility onto you, the subcontractor, for errors or omissions in the plans and specifications. It's a common tactic, but it can be very dangerous for you financially.Here's a breakdown of why it's problematic and what you should consider
Why it's BS (From Your Perspective):
Professional Responsibility Lies with the Engineer/PE
The Engineer of Record (the PE who stamped the drawings) is professionally and legally responsible for the accuracy, completeness, and constructability of the design. That responsibility should be clear. They are the ones who are expected to follow local building codes, design standards, and best practices.
Scope Creep and Unforeseen Costs
If you agree to be responsible for identifying missing work, you're potentially opening yourself up to:
Unpaid Work
Identifying something "missing" might mean you have to do it, and you may not get paid for it if it wasn't explicitly in your original bid.
Delays
Discovering missing work can lead to delays as you seek clarification and approvals.
Liability
If you miss something, the GC could argue you're responsible for any resulting problems or damages.
You're Not an Engineer
You're a subcontractor skilled in your trade. You're not being paid to be a second-guessing engineer. It's not your job to redesign the project.
Difficult to Quantify
How do you accurately price a bid when you are on the hook for unquantifiable missing work? You'll have to significantly increase the price to cover your risk, making the bid non-competitive.
What You Should Do
Identify the Exact Language
Copy and paste the specific clause into a message to me. This is crucial to give you the best possible advice.2.
Negotiate the Clause
This is essential. You need to push back on the GC. Here's how: "We are responsible for performing the work as detailed in the plans and specifications and per code requirements." State that you are not responsible for "errors or omissions" within the design. "Our bid is based on the assumption that the plans and specifications are complete and accurate." "We will promptly notify the GC and Engineer/PE of any apparent discrepancies, errors, or omissions we observe during our work." You're being reasonable by agreeing to flag issues you see, but you're not accepting responsibility for finding them all. "Any work required due to errors or omissions in the plans and specifications will be considered a change order and priced accordingly." Make sure you get paid for work that's beyond the original scope due to errors/omissions.3. Document Everything
If you proceed with the project (even after negotiating), keep meticulous records of: All communication with the GC and Engineer. Any discrepancies you identify. Any changes to the scope of work. Extra costs incurred due to errors or omissions.4.
Consider Your Relationship with the GC
How important is this project to you? Is this a GC you've worked with successfully before? If this is a toxic relationship from the start, it might be better to walk away.
Example of Negotiated Clause (Based on Assumptions)
Original Clause (Hypothetical): "The Subcontractor is responsible for identifying any missing work required for a complete and code-compliant installation, even if not explicitly shown on the plans and specifications."
Your Proposed Revision: "The Subcontractor is responsible for performing the work as detailed in the approved plans and specifications. The Subcontractor will promptly notify the General Contractor and Engineer of Record of any apparent discrepancies, errors, or omissions observed during the normal course of their work. Any additional work required due to errors or omissions in the plans and specifications, as determined by the Engineer of Record, will be considered a change order and compensated accordingly."In Summary:*Protect yourself. The GC is trying to push risk onto you. Acknowledge the need to notify for items discovered but don't accept the responsibility for the design team.Good luck! Flag for review