Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Does the code defy it's own definition of the word feeder?

User: jes25, Location: Midwest

Asked on: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at 4:20 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:28 am EST

Question: I present to you an excerpt 695.6(A)(2):(2) Feeders.Fire pump supply conductors on the load side of the final disconnecting means and overcurrent device(s) permitted by 695.4(B) or conductors that connect directly to an on-site standby generator shall comply with.........My question is, by definition how can conductors on the load side of the final disconnecting means and overcurrent device(s) be a Feeder as the heading indicates?

That's a very astute observation, and you're right to question that seeming contradiction in the wording of 695.6(A)(2). Here's a breakdown of why it appears contradictory and the most likely explanation for the NEC's choice of words

The Core Issue: Feeders vs. Branch Circuits
Feeder

A feeder is defined as all circuit conductors between the service equipment, the source of a separately derived system, or other power supply source and the final branch-circuit overcurrent device. It's the circuit
before the final overcurrent protection for a specific load.

Branch Circuit

A branch circuit is the circuit conductors between the final overcurrent device protecting the circuit and the outlet(s). It's the circuit after the final overcurrent protection for a specific load.Based on these definitions, the conductors on the load side of the final disconnecting means and overcurrent device shouldn't technically be called a "feeder." They would be part of a branch circuit feeding the fire pump.

Possible Explanations for the NEC's Terminology Choice


Common Usage/Industry Jargon

The NEC, while striving for precision, sometimes adopts terminology that is commonly used in the industry, even if it doesn't perfectly align with strict definitions. It's possible that in the context of fire pumps, electricians and engineers often refer to all conductors supplying the pump as "feeders," regardless of where the final overcurrent protection is located.2.

Focus on Reliability

The NEC 695 is primarily concerned with the reliability of the fire pump circuit. The rules are designed to ensure the pump continues to run even under fire conditions. Perhaps the focus is less on strict definitions and more on ensuring those conductors after the final disconnect/OCPD are treated with the same high standards for protection (e.g., fire resistance, physical protection) as typical feeders. The phrase "Feeders" highlights the importance of that circuit, even if technically after the final OCPD.3.

Historical Context/Evolution of the Code

Sometimes code language is the result of gradual changes and additions over time. The terminology might have made more sense in a previous edition of the code and hasn't been updated to perfectly reflect current definitions.4.

Simplified Application
: Calling it a feeder could simply be an effort to make the application of the rule easier and more straightforward. Instead of creating a separate category for the conductors after the disconnect but before the pump, they're just included with the more general "feeders" for code application.

In Practical Terms

Despite the potentially confusing terminology, the intent of 695.6(A)(2) is clear: the conductors between the final disconnect/OCPD and the fire pump, and the conductors directly connected to the on-site generator, must be installed with a high degree of reliability and protection, as specified in the subsequent requirements of 695.
6. You should treat those conductors with the same level of care and protection as you would a typical feeder.


In Summary:


While the term "feeders" in 695.6(A)(2) may be technically inaccurate based on standard definitions, it's likely a product of industry usage, the NEC's focus on reliability, and a desire for simplified application. The important takeaway is to understand the intended meaning of the rule and to ensure that the conductors supplying the fire pump meet the stringent requirements of 695.6, regardless of whether they are technically "feeders" or not. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question