User: HuntNJ, Location: NJ
Asked on: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at 6:36 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:28 am EST
Question: A customer is renovating a loft above a barn to basically a small house. The barn is currently fed with 1AWG copper under a 125amp breaker from the main house which is about 400 ft away if not more. I did an optional load calculation which came out to 91amps. Should I be concerned with the load under a 125amp breaker and also voltage drop? Using a calculator by cerro wire i get the following. 400ft at 50 amps = 6.2v dropped at 120 and 240. I chose 50 because of load demand.
Yes, you definitely have reasons to be concerned about both the load under the existing 125A breaker and the potential voltage drop, especially with a 400+ ft run. Here's a breakdown of the issues and what you need to consider
1. Load Calculation and Breaker Size:
Optional Load Calculation
You've performed an optional load calculation and arrived at 91 amps. This is a demand calculation, meaning it's an estimate of the maximum current the barn loft will draw at any given time. This is crucial for determining the appropriate feeder size.
80% Rule
NEC (National Electrical Code) generally requires feeders and overcurrent devices to be sized such that the continuous load does not exceed 80% of the conductor's and breaker's ampacity. A load of 91 amps is very close to the 125 amp breaker size and doesn't leave much room for expansion. While the breaker might not trip immediately, it's a stress on the system.
Future Expansion
Consider whether the customer plans any future additions or increased load in the loft. Electrical needs tend to grow over time. If there's a possibility of future additions, planning for a larger feeder now can save headaches later.
Code Compliance
Always verify your calculations and decisions against your local electrical codes.
2. Voltage Drop
Importance of Voltage Drop
Excessive voltage drop can cause various problems, including: Dimming lights Appliances running inefficiently (or not at all) Overheating of motors Reduced lifespan of electrical equipment Misoperation of sensitive electronics
Acceptable Voltage Drop
The NEC recommends limiting voltage drop to 3% for feeders and 5% overall (feeder + branch circuits). For a 240V system, a 3% drop is 7.2V. Your calculation of 6.2V at 50 amps seems acceptable if you only draw 50 amps. However it's still a bit high considering you will be closer to 90 amps.
Voltage Drop Increases with Load
Voltage drop is directly proportional to the current. If your actual load demand is closer to 91 amps (as your calculation suggests), your voltage drop will be significantly higher than the 6.2V you calculated. To get a better estimate you would use Ohms law to find the resistance of 400ft of 1 awg and multiply that by 91 amps.
Calculator Considerations
While online voltage drop calculators are helpful, ensure they are using accurate impedance values for the wire type and installation conditions. Some calculators use simplified models.
3. 1 AWG Copper
Ampacity
1 AWG copper wire typically has an ampacity of around 110-130 amps, depending on the insulation type and installation method (e.g., in conduit, free air). Check the NEC ampacity tables for the specific conditions.
Recommendations
Upgrade the Feeder
Given the long run (400+ ft) and the 91A calculated load, upgrading the feeder to a larger wire size is highly recommended. Consider these options:
Copper
2/0 AWG or 3/0 AWG copper. This will provide significantly better ampacity and reduce voltage drop.
Aluminum
Aluminum is a more cost-effective option, but you'll need a larger size to achieve the same ampacity and voltage drop performance as copper. 4/0 AWG aluminum would be a possibility. Make sure to use appropriately rated connectors (AL-CU rated) for the transition from copper at the main house to aluminum at the barn.*
Note
When increasing the wire size, be sure that the existing breaker panel in the main house and in the loft are rated to accept the larger sized wires. This could require you to upgrade the breaker panel in the barn, and replace the existing breaker in the main house.2.
Increase Breaker Size
If you upgrade the feeder, you can then appropriately upsize the breaker. Choose a breaker size that matches the ampacity of the new feeder wire and is suitable for the load you calculated. Be sure the breaker does not exceed the busbar ratings of the panelboard it will be installed in.3.
Accurate Voltage Drop Calculation
Using the new feeder size, recalculate the voltage drop at your maximum estimated load (91 amps) and ensure it's within the acceptable range (under 3% for the feeder).4.
Local Codes and Inspections
Contact your local electrical inspector or authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). They can provide guidance on local codes and requirements and may have specific rules regarding long feeder runs and voltage drop.5.
Document Everything
Keep a detailed record of your calculations, decisions, and the materials used. This documentation will be helpful for inspections and future reference.
Example Scenario (Illustrative - Consult NEC and Local Codes)
Let's say you decide to upgrade to 3/0 AWG copper. According to NEC tables, 3/0 AWG copper may have an ampacity of 200 amps (depending on insulation and installation). You could then safely use a 125 or even a 150 amp breaker, as your calculated demand load is less than 80% of the breaker's rating. Recalculate the voltage drop at 91 amps with 3/0 AWG copper to ensure it's within acceptable limits. If the voltage drop is still too high, you might need to consider even larger wire or other voltage drop mitigation techniques.
Important Safety Note: Electrical work can be dangerous. If you're not a qualified electrician, it's best to hire a licensed professional to perform the work. Flag for review