Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 210.25 (A) branch circuits , more than one occupancy. ‘Loads associated with’

User: Snowbound, Location: Alaska

Asked on: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at 8:13 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:28 am EST

Question: There is a single family home(A) with an apartment(B). The boiler is located in (A) but supplies water to (B). It is fed from a panel in (A) the ’Load’ is in (A) but the ‘or loads associated only with that unit, is problematic. No common areas, single meter. Does hot water running through (B) make it a load associated with both units? Seems unreasonable to bring the breaker outside to the meter to comply with NEC. What might the purpose be that someone in B needs to turn off the boiler but not have access to it? thoughts?

Okay, this is a tricky situation that highlights the complexities of multi-family dwellings within single-family structures and how that interacts with the National Electrical Code (NEC). Let's break down the issues

Understanding the NEC Issue

The heart of the problem is likely NEC 230.71(B) and 230.72(C) specifically related to disconnecting means for each occupant. The goal is to have a readily accessible disconnect so a tenant can de-energize their unit. NEC 230.71(B) - Maximum Number of Disconnects

This limits the number of disconnects allowed per service. This is a safety provision.


NEC 230.72(C) - Access to Occupants

States that each occupant shall have access to the disconnecting means serving their dwelling unit or it is located in a common space.

Why is this problematic in your case?


Because:1. Single Meter

Since there's only one meter, the entire electrical service technically belongs to the owner of house (A).2.

Boiler Location

The boiler, essential for both units, is located and controlled within unit (A).3.

Apparent Need to De-Energize

Someone has identified a potential scenario where the occupant of (B) needs to be able to de-energize the boiler without needing to access unit (A).

Analyzing the "Load" of the Boiler
Is hot water running through (B) a load associated with both units? Technically, yes. The boiler's output is providing a service (hot water) to both units. Even though the electricity to run the boiler is pulled from unit (A)'s panel. Reasonable to Bring Breaker Outside? Highly impractical and likely a misinterpretation of the code. Running a breaker for the boiler outside and adjacent to the meter is usually only done for the entire service. Moving the boiler breaker out is not what the code is designed to accomplish.

Possible Reasons for Needing a Boiler Disconnect in (B)

Without knowing the exact circumstances, here are some potential reasons why someone in unit (B) might want to de-energize the boiler: Emergency Shutdown

In case of a leak, malfunction, or fire related to the hot water system within (B), the occupant might want to shut down the heat source quickly. Imagine a pipe bursts while the owner of (A) is away.


Maintenance/Repair (Rare)

While unlikely, perhaps the occupant of (B) is occasionally responsible for minor maintenance on a portion of the hot water distribution system within their unit and wants to ensure the boiler can't activate during this time.

Fear/Mistrust

Tenant may fear a system malfunction.


Avoidance of Contact

Tenant wants to avoid having to deal with landlord in case of emergency.

Possible Solutions (Consult with a Qualified Electrician!)


Here's the key: You need to find a solution that is safe, code-compliant, and practical for your specific situation. I highly recommend contacting a licensed electrician who understands local codes in addition to the NEC.Here are some potential options to discuss with them:1. Submetering/Separate Service

The most comprehensive (and likely most expensive) solution is to have a separate electrical service installed for unit (B). This would involve a separate meter and panel, giving (B) complete control over their electricity. A submeter could be used so the tenant could pay the property owner.2.

Common Area Disconnect

Could the boiler be considered a common area item? This may not be the intent of the code, however, a common area disconnect may be the most appropriate for the hot water heater since both units use it.3.

Educate tenant.
Ensure they know who to call in an emergency and do not make it their responsibility to turn off the power to the heater.4. Dedicated Boiler Disconnect Within (A), Shared Responsibility

This solution requires clear communication and agreement. A readily accessible, lockable disconnect switch (a simple "kill switch") could be installed near the boiler in unit (A). The occupant of (B) would be given a key to access this disconnect switch only in an emergency.

This solution works if the owner of (A) is on site.5.


Add a Shut-Off Valve in (B)

Install a shut-off valve on the main hot water supply line entering unit (B). That will allow the tenant in (B) to turn off the water, but not the boiler.

Important Considerations


Local Codes and Inspections

Remember, local codes may be stricter than the NEC. A local electrical inspector will have the final say.

Communication is Key

Whatever solution you choose, clear communication between the owner of (A) and the occupant of (B) is crucial. Everyone needs to understand the system, how it works, and what to do in case of an emergency.


Safety First: Always prioritize safety when dealing with electrical systems. Don't attempt any work yourself unless you are a qualified electrician.In summary, your situation is complex. The NEC isn't intended to create unreasonable burdens. A qualified electrician can help you find a compliant and practical solution that addresses the concerns of both parties. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question