User: Bcat, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at 9:24 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:29 am EST
Question: I recently installed a sub-panel (rated at 125amp). It is supplied by #1 SER AL on a 100amp breaker in a 200amp sub panel. The inspector said the maximum breaker I can use is 90amp. Yet I've done the same setup before and passed. I know I can't put #2 SER AL on a 100amp breaker (changed breaker to 90amp to pass), and was told I had to use #1 SER AL. So now I'm confused, and frustrated. Which inspector do I believe? Do I just down size the breaker to 90amp to appease this inspector? Anyone, especially inspectors, care to weight in on this?
Okay, let's break down the situation and address your confusion. This is a common point of discussion, and it's good you're seeking clarity.
Understanding the Issue: Ampacity and Overcurrent Protection
The core principle here is ampacity. Ampacity is the current-carrying capacity of a conductor (wire). Overcurrent protection (breakers or fuses) are designed to protect the wire from overheating and causing a fire due to excessive current draw. The breaker's job is to trip before the wire's ampacity is exceeded.
Your Specific Situation: #1 SER Aluminum, 100A vs. 90A Breakers
Here's where things get specific and the code gets consulted: #1 SER Aluminum Ampacity
This is the crux of the matter. The ampacity of #1 SER Aluminum depends on the temperature rating of the terminations (the points where the wire connects to the breaker and panel). This is critical, and the inspector is focusing on this.
NEC Table 310.16 (2020 and later editions): This is the table used to determine ampacity. Look up #1 Aluminum conductor in the 75°C column. The ampacity will likely be 90 amps. Termination Temperature Ratings
This is the MOST important detail. According to NEC 110.14(C), conductors must be rated for the lowest temperature rating of the connected equipment (breakers, panels, etc.). Unless the breaker and panel are specifically marked for 75°C terminations, they are likely rated for 60°C. However, most modern breakers are rated for 75°C, but you MUST confirm this by looking at the breaker's markings. If the breaker is only rated for 60°C, then the ampacity of #1 Aluminum is only 80amps.
SER Cable Specifics
SER cable may have specific ampacity restrictions based on its construction. It's worth reviewing the cable manufacturer's specifications.
100A Breaker
If the #1 Aluminum's ampacity (at the correct termination temperature rating) is less than 100 amps, you cannot use a 100A breaker. That's the safety issue.
90A Breaker
If the #1 Aluminum's ampacity (at the correct termination temperature rating) is 90 amps, a 90A breaker is acceptable. It protects the wire.
125A Subpanel
The subpanel's rating (125A) is the maximum current it can handle. The breaker feeding it (100A or 90A) determines how much current is actually being supplied. The subpanel's rating is not a factor in the breaker size here.
Why the Discrepancy with Previous Inspections?
This is frustrating, but here are the likely explanations:1. Inspector Interpretation/Knowledge
Inspectors are human. Some may be more stringent or have different interpretations of the code. Some may not be as knowledgeable about the finer points of ampacity calculations.2.
Older Code Editions
The National Electrical Code (NEC) is updated every three years. Ampacity tables and rules can change. A previous installation done under a different code edition might have been allowed.3.
Oversight
The previous inspector might have missed the ampacity calculation or termination temperature rating issue.4.
Different Materials
You said this has happened before, but with #2 SER AL. You have to go by the wire size, material, and termination temperature ratings every time.
What to Do Now: A Step-by-Step Approach1. VERIFY TERMINATION TEMPERATURE RATINGS
This is the MOST important step.
Breaker
Examine the 100A breaker carefully. Look for markings that indicate its temperature rating (e.g., "Suitable for 75°C Conductors," or similar wording). If it only says 60°C, that's your answer.
Panel
Check the subpanel's label or documentation. It should specify the temperature rating of its terminals.2.
Consult NEC Table 310.16
Using the correct temperature rating (60°C or 75°C) from Step 1, look up the ampacity of #1 SER Aluminum in that table.3.
Manufacturer's Specifications
Double-check the SER cable's manufacturer's specifications. They might have additional ampacity information.4.
Code Edition
Determine which edition of the NEC is being enforced in your jurisdiction. This information is generally available from your local building department or electrical inspector's office.5.
Talk to the Inspector
Politely discuss your findings with the inspector. Show him the breaker's temperature rating and the relevant table in the NEC. Ask him to explain his reasoning. A collaborative discussion is often the best approach.6.
Appeal (If Necessary)
If you strongly believe the inspector is incorrect and you have solid code-based evidence to support your position, you usually have the right to appeal the decision to a higher authority within the building department.
Your Options Based on the Findings If #1 SER Aluminum ampacity at the applicable temperature rating is 90 amps
Install a 90A breaker. This is the safest and easiest solution.
If the breaker and panel are rated for 75°C and the ampacity is 100 amps
Show the inspector the documentation. If he still disagrees, you may have to go through an appeal process.
If the breaker and/or panel are rated for only 60°C and the ampacity is 80 amps
You must use an 80A breaker (or downsize the wire to a larger size).
Important Considerations Safety First
Never compromise safety to avoid a minor inconvenience. The overcurrent protection is there to protect your property and your life.
Documentation is Key
Keep records of all your calculations, code references, and discussions with the inspector. This can be helpful if you need to appeal.*
Professional Advice: If you're still unsure, consult a licensed electrical contractor. They can assess the situation, perform the calculations, and discuss the code requirements with the inspector on your behalf.Good luck, and I hope this helps clarify the situation! Flag for review