User: ptonsparky, Location: NE (9.06 miles @5.9 Degrees from Winged Horses)
Asked on: Thursday, November 21, 2024 at 7:14 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:29 am EST
Question: An AB 1500 I installed 25 years ago has lost its programming twice in the last month and appears to be associated with a rebar driven into one of the 480 volt Cu feeder conductors. Not a failure but a ground fault. It has been dry since the 1st of September with only two rains. Each program loss coincided with the rain. The rebar caused fault was found during the 2nd rain.The extremely expensive second PLC battery installed a few years ago has good voltage.Would a SPD installed on the 1KVA(?) secondary feeding the PLC and associated controls help?
Okay, let's break this down and analyze the situation, then address the SPD question.
Understanding the Problem PLC (Programmable Logic Controller) Losing Programming
This is a major problem. PLCs are the brains of automated systems, and losing programming can shut down processes, cause errors, and potentially damage equipment.
Association with Ground Fault & Rain
This is a critical clue. It strongly suggests a transient voltage issue, most likely a surge or "spike" related to the ground fault caused by the rebar. The rain acts as a conductor, exacerbating the ground fault and potentially creating a path for surges to enter the PLC's power supply.
Rebar-Induced Ground Fault
A rebar physically contacting a 480V conductor is dangerous and can induce voltage changes on the ground itself. It's possible the rebar is acting like an antenna for transient voltages.
Battery Voltage OK
While good battery voltage is reassuring, it doesn't rule out power quality issues. A surge or transient can overwhelm even a battery-backed system.
AB 1500 Age
25 years is a long lifespan for a PLC. Components degrade over time, making it more susceptible to power quality problems. The age of the PLC can also affect the support availability and repair options.
Likely Scenario
The most probable sequence of events is:1. Rain Occurs
Water increases the conductivity between the rebar and ground.2.
Ground Fault
The rebar makes contact with the 480V feeder, creating a ground fault.3.
Surge/Transient
The ground fault generates a voltage transient or surge on the electrical system. This could be a high-frequency transient or a more sustained voltage spike.4.
PLC Vulnerability
The surge enters the PLC's power supply (either directly through the 120V AC input or indirectly through control signals). The surge overwhelms the PLC's protection circuitry.5.
Memory Corruption
The voltage transient corrupts the PLC's memory, leading to program loss.
Why the Battery Isn't the Entire Solution
The battery's primary purpose is to maintain power to the PLC during a complete power outage. It's not designed to handle high-voltage transients or surges. Think of it like this: a battery provides backup power, but it doesn't filter out noise or protect against lightning strikes.
SPD (Surge Protective Device) ConsiderationsYes, installing an SPD on the 120V AC secondary (feeding the PLC and controls) is highly recommended. Here's why
Targeted Protection
An SPD specifically designed for 120V AC power will clamp (limit) transient voltages to a safe level, preventing them from reaching the PLC's sensitive electronics.
First Line of Defense
It acts as the primary barrier against surges originating from the ground fault and other sources.
Cost-Effective Insurance
Compared to the cost of downtime, reprogramming, or even replacing the PLC, an SPD is a relatively small investment.
Important Considerations When Choosing and Installing an SPD
SPD Type
Look for a
Type 2 SPD. Type 2 SPDs are installed after the main circuit breaker panel and are designed for protecting downstream equipment. A Type 1 SPD is designed for installing before the service entrance and is primarily intended to protect the building infrastructure from external surges such as lightning strikes. Voltage Protection Rating (VPR) / Let-Through Voltage
This is the key specification. It indicates the maximum voltage that the SPD will allow through to the protected equipment. Lower is better. Aim for a VPR as low as possible, but typically no higher than 330V.
Surge Current Capacity
This indicates how much surge current the SPD can handle (measured in kA - kiloAmps). Higher is generally better. A 40kA or higher surge current rating is generally recommended.
Installation Location
Install the SPD as close as possible to the equipment you want to protect (the PLC's 120V AC power supply). Minimize the length of the wiring between the SPD and the equipment.
Grounding
Proper grounding is absolutely critical for an SPD to function effectively. Follow the manufacturer's instructions carefully. Ensure the SPD has a dedicated ground wire connected to a proper grounding electrode system. The SPD should be installed in a location with a low impedance ground path to the electrical panel's ground bus.
Monitoring/Status
Consider an SPD with indicator lights or remote monitoring capabilities to confirm it's still functioning properly. Some SPDs have audible alarms or contacts that can be wired to a monitoring system.
Reputable Brand
Choose an SPD from a reputable manufacturer known for quality and reliability. Look for UL 1449 certification.
Coordination
Ideally, the SPD should be coordinated with other surge protection devices in the facility. A cascading approach (with SPDs at multiple levels of the electrical system) provides the best protection.
Professional Installation
Have a qualified electrician install the SPD.
Additional Recommendations Beyond the SPD Address the Ground Fault
The primary goal must be to eliminate the rebar contacting the 480V conductor. This is a serious safety hazard. Immediately disconnect the power to the faulty feeder, isolate the rebar, and repair the damaged insulation on the 480V conductor.
Inspect the Wiring
Carefully inspect the wiring for the PLC's power supply and control signals for any signs of damage or insulation breakdown. Replace any damaged wiring.
Grounding Audit
Have a qualified electrician perform a thorough grounding audit of the entire system, including the PLC's power supply, control panels, and grounding electrode system. Ensure all grounding connections are tight, clean, and corrosion-free.
Consider Power Line Conditioning
In addition to the SPD, a power line conditioner can provide even better power quality. Power line conditioners filter out noise and regulate voltage fluctuations, providing a cleaner power source for the PLC.
Data Logging
Consider using a power quality analyzer to monitor the voltage, current, and harmonics of the power feeding the PLC. This can help identify any underlying power quality issues that may be contributing to the problem.
PLC Upgrade
Given the age of the AB 1500, consider upgrading to a newer PLC model. Modern PLCs are more robust and have better surge protection built-in. While this is a significant expense, it may be a necessary investment to ensure reliable operation.
Review PLC Program
After the PLC has lost its programming, it is important to load the most recent program, but before doing that, it would be a good idea to review the PLC's program for any potential issues.
In Summary
An SPD is a necessary addition to help protect the PLC, but it's not a standalone solution. The root cause – the rebar contacting the 480V conductor – must be addressed first. Combine the SPD with a thorough inspection, grounding audit, and potentially a power line conditioner or PLC upgrade for the best long-term reliability. Prioritize safety and consult with qualified professionals for electrical work. Flag for review