Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Alternate Point of View? Preying on Homeowners

User: paullmullen, Location: Wisconsin

Asked on: Thursday, November 21, 2024 at 9:48 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:30 am EST

Question: My relative called me asking for me to play my Master Electrician card and talk with an another electrician who was proposing a lot of changes as part of a free safety inspection in a home built 15 years ago. Note that there were no Here were the proposals... all of them totaling to $20k in parts and service:1) Replace all of the receptacles because they were installed using backstab instead of under-the-screw2) Replace all of the Leviton switches because they're all arcing and near end of life.3) Replace all of the 110V breakers with ACFIs4) Add a whole-home surge protector5) Bring two kitchen receptacles (dishwasher and refrigerator) up to code with GFCIs6) Replace the breaker panel because it is 15 years old and (therefore) approaching end of life.I'm not asking for a solution, I'm just venting. I can imagine the GFCI updates and maybe the whole house surge protection, but after that, it feels like preying on an easily worried homeowner.I'm not licensed in the State of Washington - Wisconsin starts with the same letter, maybe they'd let me slide in under reciprocity ;-) - otherwise I'd fly out and re-assess it myself. OK. I'm done.Anyone want to take an alternate perspective? Am I just too cynical?Paul

Paul, I completely understand your frustration. That quote definitely raises some red flags and smells like someone trying to pad the bill significantly. Here's a breakdown of why each point is questionable, along with a more balanced perspective

1. Replace all receptacles due to backstabbing:
Why it's questionable

While
under-the-screw connections are generally considered more reliable in the long run, properly installed backstabbed connections can be safe and compliant, especially if the house is only 15 years old. A blanket replacement without evidence of actual failure (loose connections, overheating, signs of arcing) is unnecessary.

Alternate Perspective

Backstab connections are sometimes associated with a higher failure rate over time. A conscientious electrician might recommend replacing them as a preventative measure, but the cost should be much less than a full home rewire. Suggesting a handful of replacements based on a spot inspection would be more reasonable.

2. Replace all Leviton switches because they're arcing and near end of life



Why it's questionable

Saying ALL switches are arcing is highly suspect. Switches
do wear out, but not usually across the entire house simultaneously after only 15 years. Arcing would be visually evident (burn marks, melted plastic) and usually accompanied by other issues like flickering lights.

Alternate Perspective

Switches are mechanical devices and can fail. However, replacing them en masse based on a general claim of arcing is a hard sell. An electrician should be able to show your relative specific switches with visible damage or failing function.

3. Replace all 110V breakers with AFCIs



Why it's questionable

While AFCI protection is a valuable safety upgrade, requiring it for all 110V circuits in a 15-year-old house
retroactively isn't necessarily required unless there's been a major remodel or addition that triggered the current code requirements. Also, AFCI breakers can sometimes be overly sensitive and cause nuisance tripping, so you'd want to consider if that's happening before a full replacement.

Alternate Perspective

Depending on the jurisdiction's code adoption, certain circuits (bedrooms, living rooms, dining rooms) might require AFCI protection if work is being done on them. This electrician might be trying to bring the whole house up to current code.

4. Add a whole-home surge protector



Why it's less questionable (but still should be discussed)

Whole-home surge protectors are a good idea to protect sensitive electronics.


Alternate Perspective

This is probably the most legitimate suggestion. Surge protection is becoming increasingly important. However, the price should be reasonable (installed cost, including a quality surge protector, is typically $200-$400).

5. Bring two kitchen receptacles (dishwasher and refrigerator) up to code with GFCIs



Why it's less questionable

GFCI protection for kitchen receptacles near sinks is typically code-required.


Alternate Perspective

This is also very likely a valid code update. The cost depends on whether the receptacles need new wiring back to the panel.

6. Replace the breaker panel because it is 15 years old and approaching end of life



Why it's highly questionable

Breaker panels do not typically have a 15-year lifespan. They can last much longer with proper maintenance. Unless there are clear signs of damage (rust, corrosion, overheating, breaker malfunction), replacing it solely based on age is a rip-off.


Alternate Perspective

In some cases, a panel replacement might be necessary. However, the electrician should be able to provide concrete reasons beyond just the age, such as physical damage, a panel recall, or a history of breaker failures. Also, maybe the panel isn't large enough for the existing loads and any future increases.

In summary

You are NOT being too cynical. This electrician is likely taking advantage of your relative's lack of electrical knowledge and fears about safety. A legitimate electrician would: Provide a detailed explanation of the issues they found. Show concrete evidence of any problems (e.g., photos of damaged switches, tripped breakers). Offer a range of solutions, from simple repairs to more comprehensive upgrades, with clear explanations of the pros and cons of each option. Not pressure your relative into making a decision on the spot.

What your relative should do:
Get at least two more quotes from other licensed electricians. Ask each electrician to clearly explain the reasons for their recommendations and to provide specific examples of the issues they found. Research typical costs for electrical work in their area. Contact their local licensing board or consumer protection agency if they suspect they are being scammed.You're right to be suspicious. Hopefully, your relative will get a second opinion. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question