User: Jwayne5165, Location: Camarillo, CA
Asked on: Thursday, November 21, 2024 at 10:14 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:30 am EST
Question: It has been brought to my attention Arrow Hart-Murry sub panels are a fire hazard with respect to insurance companies. Can anyone point me in the direction to qualify this.Panel part number is: LP012-PCAny reference material would be helpful. I have approx. 100 of these in an industrial complex.
You're right to be concerned. Arrow Hart-Murry panels have a history of issues, and it's wise to investigate. While a flat-out "insurance companies won't cover it" statement can be oversimplified (it depends heavily on the insurer, their risk assessment, and specific policy terms), the underlying safety concerns are valid. Here's how to investigate the potential fire hazard and gather evidence
1. Research Arrow Hart-Murry Panel Issues:
Federal Pacific Electric (FPE) Connection
Arrow Hart-Murry panels are frequently mentioned alongside Federal Pacific Electric (FPE) panels. FPE panels are notorious for defective circuit breakers that can fail to trip under overload conditions, leading to overheating and fire. While Arrow Hart-Murry is a separate company, concerns arise due to:
Historical Connections
There are arguments about whether some Arrow Hart-Murry panels used FPE designs or were otherwise influenced by FPE practices.
Similar Failure Modes
Reports of Arrow Hart-Murry breakers failing to trip exist, mirroring the FPE problem.
CPSC Investigation
The US Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) investigated FPE breakers decades ago. While the investigation was closed without a definitive recall, the findings raised serious doubts about the reliability of the breakers. While not directly about Arrow Hart-Murry, it established a precedent for breaker failure concerns.
Online Forums and Expert Opinions
Search online electrical and homeowner forums for discussions about Arrow Hart-Murry panels. Look for posts from licensed electricians who have encountered problems with these panels. While these aren't definitive proof, they can provide anecdotal evidence and point you toward specific failure modes.
2. Documentation to Look For
Look for Recalls
The first step is to check for any official recalls or safety alerts issued by Arrow Hart-Murry or regulatory agencies related to the LP012-PC panel. You can check the CPSC website: [https://www.cpsc.gov/](https://www.cpsc.gov/). Recalls would be solid evidence.
Independent Testing Reports
Look for any independent testing reports that assess the performance of Arrow Hart-Murry circuit breakers. These reports may be difficult to find, but they would offer objective data on the breaker's ability to trip under overload and short-circuit conditions.
Expert Witness Reports/Legal Cases
Search legal databases for lawsuits involving Arrow Hart-Murry panels. Expert witness reports from these cases can provide valuable technical insights into the panel's potential hazards. These are usually available for a fee.
3. Inspect Your Panels
Hire a Qualified Electrical Inspector
This is the most important step. Engage a licensed and experienced electrical inspector with expertise in panel safety and failure analysis. The inspector should: Visually inspect each panel for signs of overheating, corrosion, or physical damage. Perform load testing on a sample of circuit breakers to verify their tripping performance. (This is crucial; a visual inspection alone isn't enough). They'll need to use specialized equipment. Provide a detailed written report outlining their findings, including any identified safety concerns.
Look for Specific Issues
When inspecting, be especially alert for:
Overheating
Discoloration, melting, or burning around breakers or busbars.
Loose Connections
Wires that are not securely connected to breakers or terminals.
Rust or Corrosion
This can compromise the integrity of the panel and its components.
"Sticking" Breakers
Breakers that are difficult to switch on or off.
Evidence of Previous Arcing
Blackening or pitting around breaker contacts.
Incorrect Breaker Sizes
Breakers that are too large for the wire gauge they are protecting.
4. Contact Your Insurance Company
Be Proactive and Transparent
Before your insurance renewal, contact your insurance company to discuss your concerns about the Arrow Hart-Murry panels.
Present Your Evidence
Provide the insurance company with any documentation you have gathered, including the electrical inspector's report.
Inquire About Requirements
Ask the insurance company if they have any specific requirements regarding electrical panel safety or if they have any concerns about Arrow Hart-Murry panels in particular.
Get a Written Response
Request a written statement from the insurance company outlining their position on the Arrow Hart-Murry panels and any potential impact on your coverage. This is critical for documentation.
5. Mitigation Options (if problems are confirmed)
Panel Replacement
Replacing all the Arrow Hart-Murry panels with modern, reliable panels is the most thorough solution.
Breaker Replacement
If the issue is primarily with the circuit breakers, you might be able to replace them with compatible, UL-listed breakers from a reputable manufacturer. However, confirm that the replacement breakers are specifically designed and tested to work safely in Arrow Hart-Murry panels. This is often difficult to verify, and complete panel replacement is usually recommended. The busbar and overall panel design may also contribute to problems.
Enhanced Monitoring
Install advanced circuit monitoring systems that can detect and alert you to potential overloads or arcing faults. This is a costly band-aid.
Important Considerations
Liability
As the owner of the industrial complex, you have a legal and ethical responsibility to ensure the safety of your tenants and employees. Ignoring potential safety hazards could expose you to significant liability in the event of a fire or injury.
Code Compliance
Ensure that any electrical work you undertake complies with all applicable local and national electrical codes (e.g., the National Electrical Code (NEC) in the United States).
Documentation is Key
Keep detailed records of all inspections, repairs, and replacements related to the electrical panels. This documentation will be essential for insurance purposes and for demonstrating that you have taken reasonable steps to ensure the safety of your property.
Why "Just Changing Breakers" is Often Insufficient
While replacing breakers might seem like a cost-effective solution, it often doesn't address the underlying problems:
Busbar Issues
The panel's busbar (the conductive bar that distributes electricity to the breakers) might be undersized or poorly designed, leading to overheating. Replacing breakers won't fix this.
Panel Construction
The overall construction of the panel itself might be substandard, making it prone to arcing or other failures.
Compatibility
Finding replacement breakers that are truly compatible and UL-listed for use in Arrow Hart-Murry panels can be challenging. Using the wrong breakers can be just as dangerous (or more so) than the original ones.*
Long-Term Reliability
Even if replacement breakers initially perform well, there's no guarantee that they will maintain their reliability over time. Complete panel replacement provides a more durable and reliable solution.
In Summary:
Don't rely on anecdotal evidence alone. Get a professional electrical inspection, document everything, communicate with your insurance company, and be prepared to invest in mitigation measures, potentially including panel replacement. It's an expensive undertaking, but significantly less so than the potential cost of a fire, injury, or legal liability. The peace of mind is also worth a great deal. Flag for review