Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Generator Contractor using sealing ring

User: Punkin, Location: Florida

Asked on: Thursday, November 21, 2024 at 3:00 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:31 am EST

Question: I have a generator contractor who wants to use a Bridgeport sealing ring on a PVC fitting. This would be entering on the top of a transfer switch. We requested the UL testing data which the contractor says they cannot get.Would you allow it as a electrical inspector or plans examiner?

Okay, let's break this down. As an AI, I can't allow or disallow anything. I can, however, give you the information and reasoning you need to make an informed decision as an electrical inspector or plans examiner. Here's a comprehensive look at the situation

Key Issues:

1. UL Listing and Approved Use

The cornerstone of electrical safety is adhering to the product's UL (or other NRTL) listing and intended use. If a product is not listed for a specific application, using it in that manner violates the NEC (National Electrical Code) and potentially voids the listing itself.2.

Bridgeport Sealing Rings

Bridgeport fittings are generally well-regarded for their quality. However, a "sealing ring" in this context likely refers to a ring used in liquid-tight fittings to create a waterproof seal. These are often specifically designed to work with metallic conduit fittings (e.g., liquid-tight flexible metal conduit - LFMC) to prevent water ingress.3.

PVC Fittings

PVC fittings are designed to be used with PVC conduit. They are generally joined using PVC cement, creating a fused, often watertight, connection. Some PVC fittings are manufactured with an integral gasket for liquid-tight applications.4.

Top Entry and Water Intrusion

Entering the transfer switch from the top immediately creates a higher risk of water intrusion than a side or bottom entry. This makes proper sealing critical.5.

Transfer Switch Listing

Transfer switches are also UL-listed (or listed by another NRTL). That listing will specify the types of conduit and fittings that are permitted to be connected to the enclosure. Modifying the transfer switch in a way not described in the listing could void the listing.

Why this is Problematic



Material Compatibility

PVC and metal have different expansion and contraction rates due to temperature changes. Using a metal sealing ring on a PVC fitting can create stress and potentially compromise the seal over time, especially in outdoor environments.


UL Listing Mismatch

It's highly improbable that a Bridgeport sealing ring (designed for metallic fittings) is UL-listed for use with PVC fittings. If the Bridgeport sealing ring is made out of metal, it introduces a metallic component in a non-metallic raceway system, which could create corrosion issues.

Potential for Damage

Over-tightening the fitting with a metal sealing ring onto a PVC fitting could damage the PVC fitting, especially in colder temperatures where PVC becomes more brittle.


"Field Modification"

Using a component in a way it was not intended/listed is essentially a field modification. Field modifications are often not permitted unless approved by the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) and documented by a qualified engineer.

Why the Contractor Can't Provide UL Data

The contractor can't provide UL data because it likely doesn't exist for this specific combination of products. UL tests specific product combinations.

NEC Considerations (Examples)



NEC 110.3(B)

"Equipment shall be installed and used in accordance with the instructions included in the listing or labeling." This is the core principle. If the Bridgeport sealing ring's instructions don't allow for use with PVC, it's a violation.


NEC 300.12: Mechanical Continuity - Raceways and Cables.
"Raceways and cable armor shall be mechanically continuous between cabinets, boxes, fittings, or other enclosures." While this focuses on continuity, it highlights the need for a proper and secure connection. NEC 300.15 Boxes, Conduit Bodies, or Fittings Where Required. This section requires boxes, conduit bodies, or fittings to be installed at conduit terminations to protect conductors from abrasion and to provide access for pulling conductors. NEC 314.17(C) (Example)

Covers the securing and supporting of conduit entering boxes. It often refers back to the manufacturer's instructions for acceptable methods.

NEC 352 (PVC Conduit) - Installation Requirements

This article specifies how PVC conduit systems must be installed, including the types of fittings and joining methods allowed.


NEC 408.5 Field Modifications.
Field modifications shall be permitted only where documented and approved engineering review determines that the modification results in equivalent safety as the original design and the inspection authority is advised of such changes.

Your Decision as an Inspector/Plans Examiner



You should most likely reject this proposed installation.


Here's the rationale you can use:1. Lack of UL Listing

The contractor cannot demonstrate that the Bridgeport sealing ring is UL-listed or approved for use with PVC fittings. The burden of proof is on the contractor to demonstrate code compliance.2.

Potential for Water Intrusion

Top entry increases the risk of water damage, and the proposed installation doesn't provide assurance of a watertight seal per the intended use and listings of the materials.3.

Potential for Material Incompatibility

Metal and PVC have different expansion rates, potentially compromising the seal.4.

Violation of 110.3(B)

The proposed installation violates the NEC because the equipment (the sealing ring) is not being used in accordance with its listing.5.

Potential Code Violation

If the installation were to fail, it would violate the requirement for maintaining a reliable electrical system.

What to Suggest to the Contractor



Use a Listed PVC Fitting

Advise the contractor to use a PVC fitting that is
specifically listed and designed for creating a watertight seal with PVC conduit. There are PVC fittings with integral O-rings or other sealing mechanisms that are appropriate for wet locations.

Use a Listed Hub

Some transfer switches have a threaded hub for accepting conduit. If so, use a PVC hub and appropriate sealant rated for use with PVC.

Consider a Side or Bottom Entry

If possible, redesign the installation to enter the transfer switch from the side or bottom. This reduces the risk of water entering directly into the enclosure. If a side or bottom entry isn't possible, consider a weather shield above the top entry.


Consult the Transfer Switch Manufacturer

The transfer switch manufacturer may have specific recommendations or approved fittings for making conduit connections to their equipment.

Use Listed Components

Ensure
all components used (conduit, fittings, sealing compounds) are listed and approved for the intended environment and application.

Documentation

Document your rejection of the proposed installation, citing the relevant NEC sections (especially 110.3(B)). Explain the reasons for your rejection clearly and concisely. Provide suggestions for alternative solutions that would meet code requirements.

In summary, allowing the proposed installation would be a significant risk. It's a clear violation of fundamental electrical safety principles and could lead to future problems.
You need to insist on a code-compliant solution using appropriately listed and approved materials. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question