Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 400 amp busbar BUT 300 amp line rating

User: Anvilsbeme, Location: New Mexico

Asked on: Thursday, November 21, 2024 at 10:00 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:32 am EST

Question: We have a grid tied PV system backfeeding a main panel in which we have an inspector giving us fits concerning the 120% rule. We have a Schneider Electric panel (model #QONQ42MS300) which is a 400 amp panel that can be fitted with a 300 or 400 amp main breaker. The UL sticker lists the line rating but not the busbar rating. I called Schneider and they said the busbar rating is not stated on the sticker because both options (whether a 300 or 400 amp main breaker) are built with a 400 amp busbar.The inspector insists on using the line rating in his 120% calculations. Schneider sent me an email stating the busbar rating but he won't accept this because I might have "doctored" up the numbers. When Schneider emailed him directly, he did not accept their email because it now needed to be sent by someone stating their first and last name, engineering title, with a physical signature, and then scanned and emailed.Any suggestions on how to prove to him this panel has a 400 amp busbar?Thanks in advance for any help!

This is a frustrating situation, but it's unfortunately a common one. The inspector is being unnecessarily difficult and adhering strictly to a literal interpretation of the code, even when the manufacturer has provided supporting information. Here's a breakdown of how to address this, in order of increasing escalation

1. Go Back to the Code Itself (and Related Interpretations):
NEC 705.12(B)(2)(3)

This is the relevant section regarding backfed breakers and the 120% rule. Re-read it carefully. Focus on the
intent of the rule, which is to prevent overloading the busbar.

Look for Official Interpretations

States and municipalities often have official interpretations of the NEC. See if there's anything in your area that clarifies how the 120% rule applies when the manufacturer specifies a busbar rating separate from the line rating. Your local electrical board (or the inspector's supervisor) might have guidance on this.

2. Document Everything!
Your Schneider Communication

Keep a detailed record of every conversation (phone calls, emails) you've had with Schneider. Note the date, time, name (if you have it), and the content of the conversation.


Inspector Communication

Document every interaction with the inspector. Include dates, times, what was said, and any specific code sections he cited.

Photos

Take pictures of the panel itself, the UL sticker, and any markings you can find.

3. Attempt to Satisfy the Inspector's Requests (While Pushing Back)



Meet Schneider's Request

It's annoying, but have Schneider provide exactly what the inspector wants: a formal letter, on company letterhead, signed with a physical signature, scanned, and emailed, from an engineer stating their full name, title, and clearly stating the busbar rating is 400 amps for that model number. This should explicitly state that the panel is designed to handle a 400 amp busbar regardless of the installed main breaker (300A or 400A). Stress to Schneider the importance of the verbiage; it should be unambiguous and directly address the inspector's concerns about the 120% rule.

Cover Letter from You

When you submit Schneider's letter, include a cover letter from your company that summarizes the situation, references the NEC code, and explicitly states that you are providing this documentation as proof that the panel is compliant with the 120% rule, using the 400 amp busbar rating as confirmed by the manufacturer.

4. Engage with the Inspector's Supervisor (if necessary)



Politely Escalate

If the Schneider letter, properly formatted and signed, still doesn't satisfy the inspector, politely ask to speak to their supervisor. Explain the situation calmly and logically. Present your documentation and explain why you believe the inspector is being overly rigid.

Focus on Safety and Code Intent

Emphasize that you are committed to safety and code compliance, but you are also relying on the manufacturer's expertise and documentation. The intent of the 120% rule is to prevent overloading the busbar, and the manufacturer has clearly stated the busbar is rated for 400 amps.

5. Appeal to the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)



Formal Appeal

If the supervisor is unhelpful, you may need to file a formal appeal with the AHJ (usually the city or county building department). This process varies depending on your location.

Document EVERYTHING

Keep meticulous records of all communication and the steps you've taken. A clear, well-documented appeal has a better chance of success.

6. Consider a Second Opinion (if time allows)



Consult another inspector

See if a more experienced or senior inspector can review the situation. Sometimes, a fresh perspective can help resolve the issue.

Consult an Electrical Engineer

A professional engineer's stamp on the calculations and a letter stating the system's compliance can carry significant weight. This is especially helpful if the AHJ is hesitant to overrule their inspector.

Why this is happening (and how to address it)



Liability

Inspectors are understandably cautious. If something goes wrong, they could be held liable. This can lead to overly conservative interpretations of the code.

Lack of Familiarity with PV

Some inspectors aren't as familiar with grid-tied PV systems and the nuances of the 120% rule.


The "Letter of the Law" vs. "Spirit of the Law"

The inspector is focusing on the "letter of the law" (the literal wording of the code), while you are trying to apply the "spirit of the law" (the underlying intent of the code to ensure safety).

Important Considerations



Remain Professional and Respectful

Even though the inspector is being frustrating, maintain a professional and respectful demeanor. Arguing or becoming angry will likely make the situation worse.


Document Everything

This cannot be stressed enough. Detailed documentation is your best defense if you need to escalate the issue.*

Be Patient

Resolving this kind of issue can take time. Be prepared for a potentially lengthy process.

In summary, focus on providing definitive documentation from Schneider, escalating to the inspector's supervisor if necessary, and, as a last resort, formally appealing to the AHJ. Good luck!
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question