User: Tainted, Location: New York
Asked on: Thursday, November 21, 2024 at 10:38 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:33 am EST
Question: I am designing (14) 2 inch underground duct bank concrete encased RGS conduits. 7 conduits on top and 7 conduits on the bottom. The voltage is low at 208VHow far apart must these conduits be? Annex B and figure 310.60 suggesting they must be 7.5 inches center to center however I think this is overkill for this voltageCan these 2 inch conduits be 3 inches apart from each other? This will make them 5 inches center to center. Or are there other factors I'm missing here?
You're right to question the 7.5" spacing derived from Annex B. That spacing is primarily for heat dissipation in high-voltage installations. At 208V, heat generation is significantly less of a concern.Here's a breakdown of what the NEC says and how to approach this, along with other factors to consider
NEC Considerations:
310.15(B)(3)(a)(1) (Adjustment Factors)
This is the core section that applies to conductor ampacity adjustment factors due to multiple conductors in a raceway or cable. It directs you to Table 310.15(B)(3)(a). Note that the table only applies to
30 conductors or less based on note 1. 310.15(B)(3)(c) (Raceways and Cables Exposed to Sunlight on Rooftops)
This isn't directly applicable for underground duct banks, but it highlights the consideration of heat gain.
310.15(C) (Underground Installations)
While this section discusses ampacity adjustments, it doesn't explicitly dictate conduit spacing. It mainly refers to burial depth.
310.15(B)(2) (Engineering Supervision)
An option under the NEC is to have a qualified engineer design this duct bank.
Annex B: Engineering Information for Calculating Ampacity
This section is informative, not mandatory. Figure B.310.6 shows how to determine the RHO of the soil.
B.310.11, 310.15(B)(3) Adjustment Factors. This is where the calculation for heat dissipation comes into play. Note the reference to higher voltages and cable types that generate more heat.
Why 5" Center-to-Center (3" Clear Spacing) Could Be Acceptable for 208V
Low Voltage
The primary concern with close conduit spacing is heat build-up, which significantly reduces the ampacity of the conductors. At 208V, the current is relatively lower compared to medium or high voltage installations, leading to less heat generation in the conductors.2.
RGS Conduit
Rigid Galvanized Steel (RGS) conduit provides excellent heat dissipation compared to other materials like PVC. Steel helps conduct heat away from the conductors.3.
Underground Installation
The earth acts as a heat sink, helping to dissipate heat from the duct bank. Soil temperature is generally more stable than ambient air temperature.4.
Load Factors
Consider the actual anticipated load on each circuit. Are they likely to be fully loaded continuously? If the circuits are lightly loaded or have a low duty cycle, the heat generation will be much lower.
Factors You MUST Consider
Conductor Size and Ampacity
What size conductors are you using in the 2" conduits? What is their ampacity? You need to ensure that even with some derating due to proximity, the conductors can still carry the required load.2.
Soil Thermal Resistivity (Rho)
This is critical. The higher the soil's thermal resistivity (poor heat conduction), the more heat will build up in the duct bank. Conduct a soil test to determine the actual Rho value for your location. Do NOT assume a default value.3.
Ambient Earth Temperature
What is the average maximum earth temperature at the depth of your duct bank? This will affect the base operating temperature of the conductors.4.
Conductor Insulation Type
Check the temperature rating of the conductor insulation (e.g., THHN, XHHW). Make sure the conductor's maximum operating temperature is not exceeded.5.
Depth of Burial
This influences the ambient temperature and how effectively the earth can dissipate heat.6.
Code Compliance
While Annex B is not mandatory, your local electrical inspector may still have concerns. Be prepared to present your calculations and justification.
Steps to Take
Calculate Ampacity Adjustment Factors
Using Table 310.15(B)(3)(a) to adjust for the number of conductors. Note: this table only allows for 30 or less current carrying conductors.
2.
Conduct Soil Testing
Get a soil sample tested to determine its thermal resistivity (Rho).3.
Determine Ambient Earth Temperature
Find the average maximum earth temperature for your location at the burial depth.4.
Ampacity Calculation
Determine the ampacity of your conductors before any derating. Calculate the ampacity adjustment factor from 310.15(B)(3)(a) if you have 30 or less current carrying conductors. Multiply the conductor ampacity by the adjustment factors to get the derated ampacity. Ensure the derated ampacity is still sufficient for the load.5.
Documentation
Keep detailed records of all calculations, soil test results, ambient temperature data, and conductor specifications.6.
Consult with an Electrical Engineer (Recommended)
It's highly recommended to consult with a qualified electrical engineer, especially given the number of conduits and the potential for heat buildup. They can perform a detailed analysis and provide documentation to support your design.7.
Discuss with the Electrical Inspector
Talk to the local electrical inspector early in the design process to get their feedback and ensure they will accept your proposed conduit spacing. Present your calculations and justifications.
In summary
While 5" center-to-center spacing might be acceptable for your 208V duct bank, you
must perform thorough calculations and consider all the factors mentioned above. Soil thermal resistivity is the most critical parameter. Document everything and consult with a qualified electrical engineer and your local inspector. Choosing a larger conduit size or increasing the spacing can mitigate the need for ampacity derating. Flag for review