User: CypherKeyJ, Location: TN
Asked on: Friday, November 22, 2024 at 11:03 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:33 am EST
Question: Hello, I have a very unique situation that in my 20+ years have never came across. AHU= Air Handler UnitWe have a NEW Fire System installed in a Mini Storage Building where everything is metal. On the SLC circuit which is "disconnected from the panel" Using my meter on Ohms, I get nothing shorted across the pair and neither leg has any short to ground. However, when metering A/C voltage I get 0.030-0.125 VAC on either leg to ground. I have isolated the issue down to the AHUs. Here is what I am doing.All AHUs in the building have their breakers on at the electric panel. I have the disconnect at the AHU off on the AHUs creating the problem. In this scenario, I read NO A/C VOLTAGE to ground. BUT as soon as I turn on 1 or more of the problem AHUs I see the AC Voltage. Interestingly turning on several AHUs at the disconnect increases the voltage but then sometimes reduces the voltage. I'm not sure if it's because the inductance is getting dispersed or what.... Any thoughts on the cause of the Induced A/C Voltage? The Panel manufacturer says any A/C voltage on the SLC circuit for more than 30Sec can Blow the FACP.
Okay, this is a challenging situation and the manufacturer's warning about AC voltage is concerning. Let's break down the potential causes of induced AC voltage on your SLC loop and how to troubleshoot them.
Understanding the Problem
The fact that you only see AC voltage when the AHUs are connected and powered even with the disconnect switch opened (but breakers on) points to a classic case of capacitive or inductive coupling. Here's what that means: Capacitive Coupling
Think of the wiring inside the AHU (motor windings, power wires) as one plate of a capacitor, and the SLC wiring as the other plate. The insulation acts as the dielectric. When the AHU is powered, the AC voltage on the AHU wiring can "leak" onto the SLC wires through this capacitive coupling.
Inductive Coupling
The AC current flowing through the AHU wiring creates a magnetic field. If the SLC wiring runs parallel and in close proximity to this AHU wiring, the magnetic field can induce a voltage in the SLC wires, acting as a transformer.
Path of the "Induced Voltage" The SLC pair forms the conductor the induced current. Ground simply becomes the reference of this voltage.
Possible Causes and Troubleshooting Steps
Here's a systematic approach to identify and mitigate the problem.1. Confirm Good Grounding
Verify Grounding Electrode System
Ensure the electrical panel has a solid, code-compliant connection to a grounding electrode system (ground rod, water pipe). A poor ground creates a higher impedance path and increases sensitivity to stray voltages.
Check AHU Grounding
Verify that each AHU is properly grounded. Check the grounding conductor (usually green or bare copper) at each AHU disconnect and the electrical panel. Look for loose connections, corrosion, or damaged wires. A loose AHU ground can turn the building steel structure into a voltage "antenna."2.
Power Quality and Harmonics
Check Voltage at the Panel
Use a True RMS Multimeter to measure the voltage at the electrical panel supplying the AHUs. Look for voltage fluctuations, sags, swells, and harmonic distortion. AHUs with variable frequency drives (VFDs) can introduce harmonics into the electrical system, which can exacerbate capacitive and inductive coupling.
Harmonic Analysis
Consider using a power quality analyzer to measure the harmonic content on the electrical system. If you find high levels of harmonics, you might need to install harmonic filters.3.
SLC Wiring and Routing
Check Cable Shielding (If Applicable)
If the SLC wiring uses shielded cable, make sure the shield is properly grounded at one end only (typically at the fire alarm control panel). Do not ground the shield at both ends, as this can create a ground loop and increase noise.
Separate Wiring
Physically separate the SLC wiring from the power wiring as much as possible. Maintain a minimum separation distance of 12 inches (or more, if possible). Avoid running the SLC wiring parallel to power wires, especially those feeding the AHUs.
Use Conduit
Run the SLC wiring in a separate metallic conduit. The conduit will act as a shield to reduce capacitive and inductive coupling. Ensure the conduit is properly grounded.
Twisted Pair Wiring
Confirm that the SLC wire is twisted. The twisting helps to cancel out induced noise.4.
AHU-Specific Checks
Isolate AHUs Individually
Systematically disconnect each AHU (breaker OFF, then disconnect OFF) to see if you can identify one or more specific AHUs that are causing the problem.
Megger Test (Insulation Resistance)
With the AHU completely disconnected from power (breaker and disconnect OFF), use a megohmmeter ("megger") to test the insulation resistance of the AHU's motor windings and internal wiring to ground. A low insulation resistance indicates a possible insulation breakdown, which could be contributing to the AC voltage leakage. (Consult the AHU manufacturer's specifications for acceptable insulation resistance values.)
Filter the AHU's Ground
Consider adding a filter capacitor between the AHU's ground and the building steel/electrical ground. This might help to shunt some of the AC voltage to ground. (Consult with an electrical engineer about the appropriate capacitor value and safety considerations).5.
SLC Circuit Isolation
Isolate SLC Sections
If your SLC circuit is wired in a loop or a long run, try isolating sections of the circuit to see if you can pinpoint the location where the voltage is being induced. This will help you narrow down the area where the AHUs are causing the problem.
Add Isolation Devices
Consider adding isolation devices, such as isolator modules, on the SLC circuit to help prevent the induced voltage from propagating throughout the entire loop. (Refer to the FACP manufacturer's recommendations.)6.
FACP Grounding
Check FACP Ground
Ensure the FACP is properly grounded according to the manufacturer's instructions. A poor FACP ground can make the system more susceptible to noise.
Ground Loop Isolation
If you suspect a ground loop, consider using a ground loop isolator on the SLC circuit. (Again, refer to the FACP manufacturer's recommendations).7.
AHU VFD (Variable Frequency Drive) Considerations VFD Filters
VFDs are notorious for generating electrical noise. Ensure the AHUs with VFDs have proper line reactors and/or filters installed to minimize the noise injected back onto the power lines.
VFD Shielding
Make sure the VFD and motor cables are shielded and that the shields are properly terminated.
Important Considerations
Safety First
Always work on electrical equipment with the power off and properly locked out/tagged out. Use appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE).
Consult a Qualified Electrician
This type of troubleshooting requires a thorough understanding of electrical systems and safety procedures. If you are not comfortable performing these tasks, consult a qualified electrician or electrical engineer.
FACP Manufacturer's Recommendations
Always follow the FACP manufacturer's recommendations for wiring, grounding, and troubleshooting.
Code Compliance
Ensure that all work is performed in accordance with applicable electrical codes.
Explanation of why voltage increases and decreases with number of units
Capacitive and inductive coupling are complex phenomena.
Increasing Voltage
Adding more AHUs initially increases the induced voltage due to the cumulative effect of more potential coupling sources.
Decreasing Voltage: When multiple AHUs are on, they also create multiple potential pathways for the noise current. These pathways can sometimes interfere with each other destructively (like waves canceling out), leading to a reduction in voltage. Also, the impedance of the coupling paths might change as more AHUs are added, affecting the overall voltage.Let me know if you want to delve into any of these areas in more detail. Good luck! Flag for review