Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: stairwell in electrical room??

User: SeniorElectricalEngineer, Location: VA

Asked on: Friday, November 22, 2024 at 2:28 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:34 am EST

Question: Greetings everyone,I was wondering if a stairwell is allowed by the NEC in an electrical room as referenced in the attached photo? If so, what kind of electrical equipment if any can be placed underneath the stairwell taking into account the electrical equipment required dedicated and working spaces as per NEC 110.26? Perhaps, only distribution transformers can be placed there since they generally would not have any conduits going up? I am working on a project where an architect requested this layout for a new electrical room.

You are right to be concerned about this layout. Having a stairwell inside an electrical room, or above electrical equipment, presents some significant challenges in complying with the NEC.Let's break it down

Is a Stairwell Allowed in an Electrical Room?
NEC Doesn't Explicitly Prohibit It

The NEC doesn't have a blanket statement saying "no stairwells in electrical rooms." However, compliance with Article 110 (Requirements for Electrical Installations), specifically 110.26 (Spaces About Electrical Equipment), and other relevant articles, is
extremely difficult to achieve with a stairwell encroaching on the required working space.

Practical Concerns

Stairwells introduce several practical concerns:

Maintenance

Maintenance on equipment under the stairwell becomes awkward and potentially dangerous.


Safety

Trips and falls are a major safety concern.

Egress

A stairwell in an electrical room can hinder safe egress in an emergency.


Physical Protection

Equipment under the stairwell can be easily damaged by things falling from the stairwell (dropped tools, debris, etc.).

Challenges with NEC 110.26 (Spaces About Electrical Equipment)


NEC 110.26 is the crux of the problem. It mandates clear working space in front of electrical equipment that requires examination, adjustment, servicing, or maintenance while energized. Depth of Working Space (110.26(A)(1))

The required depth depends on the voltage to ground and the condition of the opposing surface (grounded, insulated, or exposed live parts). Even with insulated surfaces, you likely need at least 3 feet of clear depth in front of equipment. The stairwell
will intrude into this space, making compliance almost impossible.

Width of Working Space (110.26(A)(2))

A minimum of 30 inches wide or the width of the equipment, whichever is greater, is required. The stairwell support structure or stringer could easily encroach on this width.

Height of Working Space (110.26(A)(3))

The working space must be at least 6.5 feet high or the height of the equipment, whichever is greater. The underside of the stairwell, or even the stairs themselves, will almost certainly be below this height, especially closer to the wall.


Dedicated Equipment Space (110.26(E))

This part of the code is very important and very prohibitive when considering putting something above an electrical room, or inside an electrical room that is not related to electrical equipment.

What Electrical Equipment COULD Potentially Be Placed Underneath the Stairwell?
Distribution Transformers (Maybe)

You mention transformers.
Potentially, if the transformer is completely sealed (no access required for servicing), does not require ventilation, and has all its connections (conduits, etc.) on the opposite side from the working space, it might be acceptable. However, even this is highly questionable and will depend on the specific AHJ's interpretation. Furthermore, transformers often require periodic inspection and testing, which would necessitate access. This is even more true if there are any connections that are not fully visible for maintenance.

Nothing that Requires Servicing or Access

The key is to only place equipment under the stairwell that absolutely, positively never needs adjustment, servicing, or examination while energized. This severely limits your options.

Recommendations
1. Push Back on the Architect

This is the most important step. Explain the NEC requirements and the practical safety and maintenance issues. Convince them to relocate the stairwell. Provide concrete examples of how the stairwell violates 110.26.
2.


Consult the AHJ

Discuss this specific layout with the local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) before proceeding with the design. Get their official interpretation. Their word is the only one that matters.3.

Consider Alternatives



Relocate the Stairwell

The best solution.


Increase the Electrical Room Size

If the stairwell is unavoidable, make the electrical room significantly larger to compensate. Ensure ample working space is available despite the stairwell's presence.

Raise the Stairwell

If feasible, raise the entire stairwell higher to maintain the required 6.5 feet of headroom. This will likely be architecturally difficult and require significant structural changes.


Use a Different Type of Stairwell

A spiral stairwell might be able to encroach less on the floor space. But it would still need to adhere to the code requirements and may not be able to adhere to the ADA requirements.

In Summary


While not explicitly prohibited, a stairwell in an electrical room makes NEC compliance extremely difficult, particularly regarding working space (110.26). The architect's request is highly problematic and should be strongly challenged. Consult with the AHJ immediately. The best solution is to relocate the stairwell entirely. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question