User: gene6, Location: NY
Asked on: Friday, November 22, 2024 at 3:09 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:34 am EST
Question: Got a call from an HVAC guy, gas appliance was replaced and the new appliance has a short 'flex line' connection, the old one had a solid black pipe connection. The remaining black gas line in the building is now not bonded to the electrical other than thru the flex gas line that hits the unit frame.Inspector is saying the flex line is not approved for grounding.HVAC is asking for a 'bonding jumper' from the appliance jbox to the black pipe,There is some other electrical work for me to do there and HVAC guy is asking me to do this while I am there.Circuit is a 20A so can I just wirenut some #12 green on the equipment ground in the jbox and jump to a standard 'water pipe clamp' on the black pipe? Or do I need a special clamp?Or do I need to run a #6 from the GEC to the black pipe out at the gas meter?Thanks allHappy Friday
Okay, this is a common situation with some nuances. Let's break it down
Understanding the Problem:
Gas Pipe Bonding
The purpose of bonding the gas piping system is to provide a path for fault current back to the electrical service, minimizing the risk of electric shock if a fault occurs. The gas piping can become energized if a live wire accidentally contacts it.
Flex Lines and Grounding
Flexible gas connectors are not designed or intended to be a grounding path. They are not rated for carrying fault current, and a fault could cause them to melt, arc, and potentially ignite the gas. The inspector is absolutely correct that the flex line cannot be relied upon as the grounding path.
Code Requirements
NEC 250.104 covers bonding of gas piping systems. Specifically:
250.104(B) Other Metal Piping
"Other metal piping systems that are likely to become energized shall be bonded to the service equipment enclosure, the grounded conductor at the service, the grounding electrode conductor where of sufficient size, or to the one or more grounding electrodes used."
Bonding Jumper Size
250.102(C)(1) generally guides the sizing.
Your Proposed Solutions and Analysis
#12 Green Wire to Water Pipe Clamp
Likely Insufficient
While a #12 green wire might seem adequate at first glance, it's almost certainly undersized for the bonding jumper. The minimum size of the bonding jumper is usually determined by the size of the circuit supplying the equipment. Since it's a 20A circuit, a #12 is likely too small to ensure that enough current can pass safely through a fault.
Water Pipe Clamp
"Water pipe clamps" are for connecting to WATER PIPES (Metallic water supply system). They are not designed or listed for bonding to gas piping and have different standards to follow. It is usually a poor choice to use for this application as the clamp teeth can easily cut into the gas pipe wall potentially causing a gas leak.
More Info Needed
What is the size of the gas meter supply pipe and the associated supply piping? It is also code to size the bonding based on the size of the service conductors and or GEC as well if those are smaller than the circuit supplying the equipment.2.
#6 from GEC to Gas Meter
This is the better and more code-compliant option This provides a robust bonding connection back to the grounding electrode system and ensures that the gas piping is effectively grounded. You'll need to use an approved clamp
A listed clamp for bonding gas piping is required. These clamps are specifically designed to make a secure and reliable connection to the gas pipe without damaging it. They are typically bronze or copper.
Location
Connecting at the gas meter outside is a common and effective location. It bonds the entire gas piping system.
Here's what I Recommend
Consult NEC 250.104 and 250.102(C)(1)
Carefully review these code sections. Determine the correct size of the bonding jumper based on the size of the service conductors or the GEC.2.
Install a Dedicated Bonding Jumper
Run an appropriately sized solid or stranded copper bonding jumper from the grounding electrode conductor or service equipment enclosure.
Use a Listed Clamp
Install a listed grounding/bonding clamp designed for gas pipe. Ensure it's properly tightened. Make sure the surface of the pipe where the clamp will be is clean and free of corrosion.3.
Connect to the Gas Piping
Connect the other end of the bonding jumper to the gas piping, ideally near the gas meter.4.
Avoid Flex Line Reliance
Absolutely do not rely on the flex connector for grounding.
Example Scenario
Let's say you determine that a #6 copper bonding jumper is required. Run the #6 copper wire from the GEC in the service panel. Attach a listed gas pipe bonding clamp to the gas pipe near the meter. Securely connect the #6 wire to the clamp.
Important Considerations
Local Codes
Local codes might have stricter requirements than the NEC. Check with your local AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction) for any specific requirements in your area.
Gas Company Requirements
Some gas companies have specific requirements about bonding to their gas lines. Check with the gas company for their policies.
Professional Advice
If you are unsure about any aspect of this work, consult with a qualified electrical engineer or master electrician.
In Summary:
While jumping from the J-box to the gas pipe might seem like a quick fix, it's likely insufficient and potentially unsafe. The proper approach is to install a dedicated* bonding jumper of the correct size, using listed hardware, from the GEC or service equipment to the gas piping system. Connecting near the meter is generally a good practice. Always prioritize safety and code compliance.Good luck with the job! Flag for review