Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: NEC CODE CONDUIT FILL

User: budman715, Location: phila.pa

Asked on: Friday, November 22, 2024 at 4:31 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:35 am EST

Question: I need a sanity check. We are installing a new 120/208 3P panel, and plan to pull all spare circuits out of the panel to a JB, so as to avoid the need for a shutdown in the future. I am being told its ok to pull (20) #10s (single phase 20A circuits) + (1) #10 G in a 2" EMT to a large JB 60' away from the panel. I know it's in the code book that states this is not code compliant, due to derating.My thought was to use (6) #10s + (1) #10G in 1" EMT for how ever many spares pulled out. Thank you for the response

Okay, let's break down the grounding requirements for a detached garage subpanel when fed with a 4-wire feeder from the main house panel.

Yes, you ARE required to have a grounding electrode system (which includes a ground rod or other approved grounding electrode) at the detached garage.

Here's why, based on the information you provided and standard electrical codes (primarily the National Electrical Code - NEC): Detached Building Requirement

The NEC (specifically Article 250) generally requires a grounding electrode system at a detached building (like your garage) when it is supplied by a feeder circuit.


4-Wire Feeder

The fact that you're using a 4-wire feeder (two hots, a neutral, and a separate equipment grounding conductor) is crucial. This configuration allows you to establish a separate grounding system at the garage. The equipment grounding conductor provides a fault current path back to the main panel, but it's not the sole means of grounding the garage.

Separated Neutrals and Grounds

You mentioned that you are separating the neutral and ground at the subpanel in the garage. This is
essential. The neutral bus bar in the subpanel must be isolated from the enclosure and the grounding bus bar. The equipment grounding conductors (the bare or green wires) connect to the grounding bus bar, which is then connected to the grounding electrode system (ground rod).

Details of the Grounding Electrode System



Ground Rod(s)

The most common and often simplest method is to install one or two ground rods. If using two rods, they must be at least 6 feet apart. The NEC specifies the requirements for the size and type of ground rods. A typical installation uses two 8-foot copper-clad steel ground rods.

Other Approved Electrodes

Other acceptable grounding electrodes include:
A metal underground water pipe (with specific requirements). A ground ring encircling the building. The concrete-encased electrode (a "Ufer" ground, if present).

Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC)

A properly sized grounding electrode conductor (typically copper wire) must connect the grounding bus bar in the subpanel to the ground rod(s). The size of this conductor is based on the size of the feeder conductors to the garage (check NEC Table 250.66).

Why is this important?
Safety

The primary reason for a grounding electrode system is safety. It helps to: Stabilize voltage to ground. Provide a low-impedance path for fault current to return to the source (the transformer supplying your house), allowing overcurrent protective devices (breakers or fuses) to trip quickly in the event of a fault. Minimize the risk of electric shock.

Code Compliance

Meeting the NEC requirements is essential for a safe and legal electrical installation.

Important Considerations



Local Codes

Always check with your local electrical inspector or building department. They may have specific requirements that are more stringent than the NEC.


Permits

You will likely need an electrical permit for this type of work.*

Qualified Electrician

If you are not comfortable working with electricity, it is highly recommended that you hire a qualified and licensed electrician to perform the work. Improper wiring can be dangerous and potentially life-threatening.

In summary: With a 4-wire feed and separated grounds/neutrals, a grounding electrode system (typically one or two ground rods) is required at your detached garage subpanel.
This is a crucial safety measure and a requirement of the NEC. Always consult with a qualified electrician and your local building department to ensure your installation meets all applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question