User: Tulsa Electrician, Location: Tulsa
Asked on: Saturday, November 23, 2024 at 2:55 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:35 am EST
Question: I have a job coming up ( 2020 NEC) which requires us to add a breaker in a main lug 125 amp panel being used as service equipment.Aka 6 handle rule.The panel is 12/24 which would allow more the 6 two pole breakers.The new service disc would be for a room addition feeder.(60 amp).The existing meter will be changed from 100 to 200.Which has a double lugged load side.By adding this main would it be a violation of service mains in the same enclosure?FYI, the other double lugged service conductors run inside to a main breaker panel.I see that as an issue as wellRight now the outside existing main lug has two AC units and back feed PV in it.I see the PV as a line side tap.Which is feed from a PV system on a detached structure( garage) with a separate service.There adamant this is ok to do.
Okay, this sounds like a complex situation with multiple potential code violations. Let's break it down step-by-step
1. Adding a Breaker in a Main Lug Only (MLO) Panel Used as Service Equipment (6-Handle Rule):
The 6-Handle Rule (230.71(A))
The 2020 NEC generally limits the number of service disconnecting means (breakers or fused switches) to six for each service. Since this is currently a MLO panel being used as service equipment, adding a 60A breaker would likely violate the 6-handle rule unless you take other steps to comply with 230.71(A).
Exception to the 6-Handle Rule
There are exceptions to the 6-handle rule. The most common exception that might apply is to install a main breaker ahead of this existing panel. This would make the MLO panel a subpanel and no longer subject to the 6-handle rule.
2. New 60A Feeder for Room Addition
This is perfectly acceptable provided the feeder is properly sized and protected and does not cause the load calculation for the service to exceed the rating of the service.
3. Meter Upgrade (100A to 200A) with Double-Lugged Load Side
Acceptable if Listed
Double-lugged meter sockets are commonly used. Ensure the meter socket itself is rated for 200A and the double lugs are properly listed and rated for the conductor size you're using. The lugs must be listed and identified for the number and size of conductors used.
Concern #1: Service Mains in the Same Enclosure
The fact that one set of conductors feeds the existing main breaker panel in the house is acceptable as long as the lugs are rated for the conductors that are tapped off of them.
4. The Existing Main Lug Panel Setup (AC Units, PV Backfeed)
PV as a Line-Side Tap (405.1)
This is the biggest area of concern. You mentioned the PV is a "line-side tap." This is allowed but has very specific requirements, including overcurrent protection requirements and marking/labeling, if installed per 405.1.
This is likely being done incorrectly. It’s highly questionable that a qualified professional would allow line-side taps in a MLO panel that is used as the main service. Feeding from a Detached Garage with a Separate Service
This complicates things significantly. A PV system on a detached building should not be connected to the main service conductors of the main dwelling, especially not without very specific overcurrent protection and disconnection means. This is very likely a code violation unless installed per 705.12(A).
NEC Requirements
705.12(A): Supply-Side Source Connections
Outlines the rules for connecting PV systems on the supply side of the service disconnecting means. These connections must comply with the rules for service conductors, including overcurrent protection and disconnecting means requirements. This is very likely not being met in your existing setup.
690.9 Overcurrent Protection
The PV system must have appropriate overcurrent protection devices.
690.13 Disconnecting Means
Suitable disconnects are required for the PV system.
690.14 Disconnecting Means for Buildings or Other Structures
If the PV system supplies a building or structure from a remote PV system, a readily accessible disconnect must be installed at or near the point of entry of the feeder or branch-circuit conductors.
Service Conductor Sizing
The service conductors and overcurrent protection must be sized appropriately for the combined load of the dwelling and the PV system's maximum backfeed current. This is complex and requires careful calculations.
5. Your Concerns and Their Insistence It's Okay
They Are Wrong (Likely)
It's highly probable that the existing installation is not compliant with the 2020 NEC, especially regarding the PV connection. Their insistence that it's okay is concerning.
Safety First
This setup, as described, could pose significant safety hazards (overloading, fire risk, improper protection).
Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)
The final say rests with your local electrical inspector (AHJ). Their interpretation of the code is what matters.
Recommendations
Stop Work and Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer or PV System Expert
Do not proceed until you have a clear plan and documentation that demonstrates compliance with the NEC. A qualified engineer can perform load calculations, design a compliant PV interconnection, and ensure the service is properly sized.2.
Document Everything
Take photos and document the existing wiring configuration, including the meter socket, MLO panel, PV connections, and any labeling.3.
Discuss with the AHJ Beforehand
It is recommended to consult with the AHJ before proceeding.
In Summary:
Adding the breaker may be possible if done carefully and in compliance with the 6-handle rule. However, the existing PV setup sounds like a major code violation. A thorough review and correction of the PV system interconnection is absolutely necessary before proceeding with any further work. The overall system needs to be brought up to code for safety and compliance. Ignoring this could result in failed inspections, red tags, potential fines, and, most importantly, safety hazards. Flag for review