Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: LED lighting and lighting contactors

User: KyleFowler, Location: Maryville, TN

Asked on: Saturday, November 23, 2024 at 5:03 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:36 am EST

Question: For the first time in a long time I had to buy a lighting contactor. My employer bought a surplus number of the "up to 30 amp per pole, up to 12 pole" GE/Seimens/Eaton style pre-LED rated version years ago and that surplus ran out. To my amazement / horror these contactors are now only rated for a measly 10 amp 120v / 3 amp 277v for LED loads. That's pretty worthless in the field. I've done alot of research and even Sq D with their up to 12 pole class 8903 contactors are only rated at 20 amp 120v apparently. There's no mention of even a LED rating above 120v for the 8903. What am I missing? I read the article Schneider put out in 2019 about LED's having huge but very short inrush currents so I get the problem but it seems no one is doing anything about making a product rated for real world applications. I just feel like I'm missing something

You're not missing much. You've accurately identified the core problem: LED lighting inrush current is a significant issue for contactors, and manufacturers haven't fully caught up with adequately rated products, especially for multi-pole applications.

Here's a breakdown of what's happening and why you're seeing these limitations: LED Inrush Current is the Culprit

As you noted, LEDs, especially when many are switched on simultaneously, generate a very high inrush current for a very short duration. This inrush can be many times the steady-state current draw, and can damage or weld the contacts of undersized contactors.


Legacy Contactors Weren't Designed for LED Loads

Traditional contactors were designed for incandescent, fluorescent, and HID lighting, which have significantly different inrush characteristics. The old "30A per pole" rating was likely based on resistive loads or the ballast characteristics of older lighting technologies.

Manufacturers are Playing it Safe

Given the potential for failure due to inrush, manufacturers are being conservative with their LED ratings. This is why you're seeing much lower amp ratings for LED loads compared to the legacy ratings. They don't want warranty claims and the associated reputation damage.


Voltage Matters

The higher the voltage, the more demanding the inrush current will be for a given amount of lighting power. That's why the LED rating at 277V is often lower than at 120V.

Multi-Pole Contactors Compound the Problem

When switching multiple poles simultaneously, the total inrush current becomes even more significant. This can be a challenge for contactor design.


Limited Product Options

You're right that finding a "real-world" rated contactor, particularly in multi-pole configurations, is difficult. Manufacturers are still developing and testing solutions.

What are your options?
1. Over-Sizing Contactors

This is the most common (and often only) solution. You must significantly over-size the contactor, often by a factor of 5-10x the steady-state current draw. This means calculating the steady-state current of all the LED fixtures on a circuit, multiplying that by the over-sizing factor, and then selecting a contactor with an LED rating at or above that value. For example, if you have a 10A steady-state LED load at 120V, you might need a contactor with a 50-100A LED rating.2.

Inrush Current Limiters

Using inrush current limiters (also called soft starters) for the lighting circuits can significantly reduce the inrush current. These devices gradually ramp up the current, protecting the contactor. They do add cost and complexity to the design. Common brands are Amptrol, Symcom and Eaton.3.

Sequenced Switching

If the application allows, consider sequencing the switching of the LED loads. Instead of turning on all circuits simultaneously, stagger the turn-on times to reduce the peak inrush current. This can be achieved with programmable relays or controllers.4.

Specialized LED Contactors

Some manufacturers (though they might be harder to find and more expensive) are beginning to offer contactors specifically designed for LED lighting. These will typically have higher LED ratings. Consult with suppliers to see if any are suitable for your needs.5.

Solid State Relays (SSRs)

For some applications, particularly where frequent switching is required, Solid State Relays (SSRs) can be a better alternative to electromechanical contactors. SSRs are more resistant to inrush current and have a much longer lifespan. However, they can be more expensive and might have other limitations (e.g., heat dissipation).6.

Engage with Manufacturers

Talk to the technical representatives from Square D, Eaton, GE, and other contactor manufacturers. Explain your application and the LED loads you're dealing with. They may have solutions or be able to provide more specific guidance. They also need feedback from the field to drive product development.7.

Review LED Fixture Specifications

Check the datasheets for your LED fixtures. Some manufacturers provide inrush current information, which can help you more accurately size the contactor. Look for a "Peak Inrush Current" or "Inrush Current Duration" specification.8.

Consider Using Lighting Control Panels

These specialized panels often have built-in inrush current limiting or use contactors specifically designed for lighting loads.9.

Double check the LED load

Many modern LED fixtures draw much less than the 10A and 3A values per pole you indicated above. It's possible over-sizing is not as critical as you suspect.

Example Application to Illustrate the Problem and Solution

Let's say you have a 6-pole contactor switching 6 separate lighting circuits, each with 10 LED fixtures drawing 0.5 amps each steady state at 120V.

Total Steady-State Current per Pole

10 fixtures
0.5 amps/fixture = 5 amps

Total Steady-State Current (6 Poles)

6 poles
5 amps/pole = 30 amps

If using a legacy 30A per pole contactor (rated for older lighting)

This would likely fail due to inrush.


Now, let's account for LED inrush

Assuming a conservative inrush multiplier of 10x:

Peak Inrush Current per Pole (momentary)

5 amps
10 = 50 amps

Total Peak Inrush Current (momentary)

6 poles
50 amps/pole = 300 ampsYou would need to select a contactor with a significantly higher LED rating, even though the steady-state current is only 5 amps per pole. You might need to go to a contactor with an LED rating of 50-100 amps per pole (or higher), or consider using inrush current limiters.

In summary:
You're facing a real challenge. LED lighting inrush current is a significant factor, and manufacturers are still developing products and ratings to adequately address it. Over-sizing contactors, using inrush current limiters, and sequencing switching are the most common solutions. Don't hesitate to consult with manufacturers and suppliers for guidance. And, as new products become available, the situation should improve. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question