User: electrofelon, Location: Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
Asked on: Sunday, November 24, 2024 at 8:35 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:37 am EST
Question: This would be code compliant correct? Example: Ground mount array with microinverters. Inverter output(s) run inside building. Only one pole per circuit is opened by RSD initiating device on outside of building. No other device that can serve as RSD initiation such as outside service disconnect. 2017 NEC.
Okay, let's break down this scenario based on the 2017 NEC and analyze its code compliance.
Understanding the Key Elements Ground Mount Array with Microinverters
This means each PV panel has its own microinverter directly attached, converting DC to AC at the panel.
Inverter Output(s) Run Inside Building
The AC output from the microinverters (likely a multi-wire branch circuit) is routed into the building.
One Pole Opened Per Circuit
The Rapid Shutdown (RSD) initiation device, when activated, only opens one leg (one "hot" wire) of each AC circuit coming from the microinverters.
RSD Initiation Device Outside Building
There's a single, dedicated device located outside the building that activates the Rapid Shutdown function.
No Other RSD Initiation Devices
Specifically, you state the service disconnect is NOT designed to initiate rapid shutdown.
2017 NEC
We are referring to the 2017 National Electrical Code
Analysis Under 2017 NEC (Primarily Article 690)
The key section of the NEC relevant here is 690.12, which covers Rapid Shutdown of PV Systems.
690.12(B) requires controlled conductors to be limited to no more than 30 volts within 30 seconds.The question of whether only opening one pole is compliant depends on a number of factors: How are you achieving voltage reduction within 30 seconds? Even with microinverters, merely opening one pole may not reduce the voltage adequately. Open Pole Voltage If the voltage on the opened pole exceeds 30V within 30 seconds, this would be a code violation. Microinverter Listing
The most important point to check here is the listing of the microinverters themselves. Do the microinverters, as tested and listed by a nationally recognized testing laboratory (NRTL) such as UL, require that BOTH poles of the AC circuit must be opened to achieve rapid shutdown functionality? If the listing requires that both poles be opened, then opening only one is a violation of 110.3(B). This is where the devil lies!
Labeling
If the microinverters have a rapid shutdown initiation requirements, that needs to be reflected on labels.
Issues and Potential Violations1. Incomplete Shutdown
Only opening one pole may NOT sufficiently de-energize the circuit to meet the intent of rapid shutdown. Even with microinverters, opening only one leg will still leave the circuit energized from the grid side up to the point of the open, and potentially even from other microinverters if they can "backfeed" somehow. This could create a hazard for firefighters or other responders.2.
Voltage Reduction
Rapid shutdown is intended to reduce the voltage in the array to a safe level quickly. Simply opening one pole of the AC circuit does not guarantee a fast voltage reduction. The microinverters may continue to operate, or there may be backfeed from other sources.3.
110.3(B) - Instructions
Equipment must be installed and used according to the manufacturer's instructions and listing. If the microinverter's listing requires that both poles must be opened to achieve rapid shutdown functionality, opening only one pole is a violation of 110.3(B). This is where the devil lies!
In SummaryNo, this is likely NOT code-compliant. While the 2017 NEC allows for flexibility in how rapid shutdown is implemented, merely opening one pole of the AC circuit does not guarantee the voltage reduction required. The installation would need to demonstrate that the open pole would reduce the voltage of the circuit within 30 seconds to 30V or less, in the affected area. The microinverter's listing requirements is where most plans will fail if only one pole is opened.
Recommendations
Consult Microinverter Documentation
Thoroughly review the microinverter manufacturer's installation instructions and listing information. Does the microinverter, as tested and listed by a nationally recognized testing laboratory (NRTL) such as UL, require that BOTH poles of the AC circuit must be opened to achieve rapid shutdown functionality?
Double-Pole Disconnect
Use a double-pole disconnect switch for rapid shutdown to ensure both legs of the AC circuit are interrupted.
Alternative Methods
Explore other methods of rapid shutdown that are compliant with the 2017 NEC, such as solutions that use PLC (Power Line Communication) or other communication methods to shut down the microinverters directly.
AHJ Consultation
Discuss your proposed design with your local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) before installation to ensure they agree with your interpretation of the code and that your chosen solution meets their requirements. This is CRITICAL.*
Consider Current Code
If possible, consider adopting a newer NEC edition (2020 or 2023) as they have made rapid shutdown requirements clearer.
Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide definitive legal or electrical code advice. Consult with a licensed electrician and your local AHJ for final approval and compliance. Flag for review