Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Old GE panel

User: junkhound, Location: Renton, WA

Asked on: Sunday, November 24, 2024 at 9:28 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:37 am EST

Question: 1950s GE panel in church parsonage. 30A tied handle bolt on breaker.What I have never seen before is a GE breaker trip and one side not make internal contact without a few cyclings of hte handles. Hard to find these old GE breakers, left the one in place after getting a 240V output.Am the guy pastor call when something goes bad. 1 year old Vevor cooktop, no heat. Yes, pastor did check breakers and flipped on an off a few times.So, meter shows 120V each side at cooktop, but no 240 V, figure the 120 on one side is just capacitve coupling. I had installed the cooktop last year and knew the 10awg was continuous from the panel.Old 30A GE breaker, tied handles, open up and no 240V although breaker not 'tripped". Meter on breaker, flip a few times and lo and behold, 240 does finally appear.240V not at cooktop, but the 1 YO vevor glass top resistance cooktop is dead.Replaced with standard hotpoint 4 burner cooktop I had in the shop. Have not yet tried to troubleshoot the Vevor for why it tripped the breaker and is now 'dead'.

Okay, this sounds like a classic case of an aging electrical system with a failing component. Here's a breakdown of what happened and things to consider

Diagnosis of the Problem:
Failing GE Breaker

The intermittent failure of the old GE breaker is the primary culprit. The fact that you had to cycle it multiple times to get 240V output is a clear indication of internal contact corrosion or wear. These old breakers were designed to last, but time takes its toll. The spring mechanism can weaken, and the contacts can become corroded or pitted, leading to poor connections. Even though the breaker
looked like it was on, one pole was not making consistent contact.

"Capacitive Coupling" / Phantom Voltage

You're right on the money. The 120V reading you were seeing at the cooktop without a proper 240V circuit is likely phantom voltage (capacitive coupling). This happens when a wire runs parallel to another energized wire (even if it's off), and a small voltage is induced. This is not enough to power anything.

Dead Vevor Cooktop

The fact that the cooktop is dead
after the breaker issue suggests it could have been damaged by under-voltage, voltage spikes, or arcing as the breaker failed intermittently. However, it is also possible the cooktop simply failed on its own. Vevor, while often inexpensive, sometimes has questionable quality control.

Steps Taken & Recommendations



Smart to Replace the Cooktop

Getting the church back up and running quickly was the right call. Installing the Hotpoint solves the immediate problem.

Replacement Breaker

As others have said, getting a replacement for the old breaker would be ideal. You may be able to find new old stock (NOS) or a refurbished breaker that would fit.

However, I would consider replacing the entire panel if funds permit.
Troubleshooting the Vevor

Before assuming the Vevor is completely toast, consider:

Visual Inspection

Open it up (carefully!) and look for any obvious signs of damage: burnt components, loose wiring, swollen capacitors, etc. If you're comfortable with electronics, start with a visual inspection.


Check the Internal Fuse

Many cooktops have an internal fuse (usually in the control board area). If you can locate it, check its continuity with a multimeter.

Check the Heating Elements

Use a multimeter to check the resistance of the heating elements. If the resistance is infinite, the element is likely burned out. (Of course, do this with NO POWER connected!).


Panel Replacement

The aging panel is the underlying issue. While hunting down a replacement breaker might seem easier in the short term, a panel replacement is a more comprehensive solution that will improve safety and reliability in the long run. Modern panels offer better protection and may be required for new appliances in the future. If the panel is original to the 1950s, the insulation on the wires feeding the panel will be deteriorating and you will be needing to deal with that soon.

Consider a Professional Electrical Inspection

Given the age of the system, it would be wise to have a licensed electrician perform a thorough inspection of the entire electrical system. This can identify other potential problems, such as:


Deteriorating wiring

Old wiring insulation can become brittle and crack, posing a fire hazard.

Loose connections

Loose connections can cause arcing and overheating.


Overloaded circuits

Overloaded circuits can trip breakers and potentially cause fires.

Grounding issues

Improper grounding can create shock hazards.

Additional Notes



Safety First

Always disconnect power at the main breaker before working on any electrical equipment.

Documentation

Keep a record of all work performed, including any parts replaced.


Know Your Limits

If you're not comfortable working with electricity, it's always best to call a qualified electrician.*

Consult a Professional Regarding Code:
Electrical codes change over time. Consult with an electrician to ensure that any work performed meets current codes and is done safely. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question