User: g-and-h_electric, Location: northern illinois
Asked on: Sunday, November 24, 2024 at 10:24 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:37 am EST
Question: Hey all, I need some input on this.Just had an a/c disconnect which was feeding and EV charger burn up ( pictures on request). The wiring is #6 copper THHN in 3/4 EMT all the way to the panel with a 60 Amp breaker on it ( I personally installed this last spring). Anyway since it is a warranty call back, I am trying not to re-pull all the #6. I have a deep 11-B box which I can easily splice in. So I am looking for thoughts as to do we think a 2 port "polaris" is as good or better than a split bolt. For 2 connections I am not too worried about an extra 10 min to tape the split bolts, just dont need a repeat of something burning up.The disconnect WILL be replaced with a "knife switch" style as I no longer trust the pullout style a/c disconnects.Just looking for a few thoughts here. Again all conductors are #6 copper in EMT conduit.Howard
Okay, Howard, let's break down your situation and figure out the best approach for this repair. You're right to be concerned about a repeat failure, so focusing on a solid, reliable connection is key.
Understanding the Failure
Before we dive into connector types, let's briefly consider why the disconnect burned up. While a faulty disconnect is likely, possible underlying causes could include: Loose Connection
A loose connection at any point in the circuit creates resistance, which generates heat, leading to failure. This could be in the breaker panel, at the disconnect, at the EV charger terminals, or even within the splices you're considering.
Overloading
Even though you have a 60A breaker and #6 wire (which should be adequate for most EV chargers), it's essential to verify the charger's actual current draw. Some chargers can be configured to draw more current than the circuit is rated for if not properly set up.
Manufacturing Defect
Sometimes, electrical components simply fail due to manufacturing defects.
Environmental Factors
Extreme temperatures or humidity can contribute to corrosion and connection issues. (less of a factor with copper in conduit, but still something to be aware of).
Connector Options: Polaris vs. Split Bolt
Let's directly compare Polaris connectors and split bolts in your application: Polaris Connectors (Insulated Multi-Tap Connectors)
Pros
Insulation
Polaris connectors are fully insulated, providing a safer and cleaner splice. This eliminates the need for extensive taping.
Ease of Installation
Installation is straightforward – insert the wires into the ports and tighten the set screws with an Allen wrench.
Inspectable
With some Polaris connectors, you can periodically check the torque of the set screws.
Vibration Resistance
Generally, Polaris connectors offer better vibration resistance than split bolts.
Cons
Cost
Polaris connectors are generally more expensive than split bolts.
Size
They can be bulkier than split bolts, which could be a factor in a crowded junction box, but you indicated you have a deep 11-B box, so that should not be an issue
Split Bolts
Pros
Cost
Split bolts are significantly cheaper than Polaris connectors.
Proven Technology
They have been used for decades and, when properly installed, are a reliable connection method.
Cons
Taping Required
Proper insulation with electrical tape is critical. This is time-consuming and requires skill to do correctly to avoid future problems.
Corrosion
Split bolts are susceptible to corrosion, especially in damp environments. Anti-oxidant compound (like Noalox or Penetrox) is essential for copper-to-copper connections.
Torque Sensitive
Overtightening or undertightening can lead to connection failures. Torque recommendations for split bolts are critical.
More Difficult to Inspect
Once taped, it's difficult to visually inspect the connection.
RecommendationFor your application, I strongly recommend using a 2-port Polaris connector (or equivalent insulated multi-tap connector).
Here's why: Reliability
Polaris connectors offer a more reliable connection with better resistance to loosening and corrosion, which are critical for a high-current EV charger circuit.
Safety
The full insulation of a Polaris connector significantly reduces the risk of accidental shorts or ground faults.
Ease of Installation
While you're comfortable taping split bolts, a Polaris connector is faster and less prone to error, ensuring a consistent and professional-grade connection. Given this is a warranty callback, you will be happier with the long term results.
Important Considerations1. Torque
Regardless of whether you use Polaris connectors or split bolts,
absolutely use a torque wrench to tighten the set screws or bolts to the manufacturer's specified torque value. This is crucial for a reliable connection. Undoing and retightening a standard screwdriver is a good way to improperly torque a lug or screw.2. Anti-Oxidant Compound
If you opt for split bolts, use a generous amount of anti-oxidant compound (like Noalox or Penetrox) on the conductors before* tightening the split bolt. This prevents corrosion and ensures a good electrical connection. While it is less needed with a Polaris connector, it does not hurt to coat the wire before installation.3.
Proper Taping (If Using Split Bolts)
If you use split bolts, use high-quality electrical tape (3M Scotch 33+ is a good choice) and apply it in overlapping layers, starting well back from the bolt and extending beyond the ends of the wires. Build up a thick layer of insulation, and ensure there are no exposed metal parts.4.
Inspect Existing Wiring
Carefully inspect the remaining #6 wire for any signs of damage, overheating, or corrosion. If you find any issues, replace the entire run of wire.5.
Verify Charger Settings
Confirm that the EV charger's current draw settings are appropriate for the 60A circuit.6.
Check Breaker
Ensure the 60A breaker is in good condition and properly seated in the panel. You might even consider replacing the breaker as a preventative measure.7.
Knife Switch Disconnect
Your decision to use a knife switch disconnect is excellent. These are much more reliable than the pull-out style.
Installation Steps (Polaris Connector Example)
Turn off the breaker. Double-check with a non-contact voltage tester to ensure the circuit is dead.2. Prepare the Wires
Carefully strip the insulation from the ends of the existing wires and the new wires, ensuring you strip the correct amount for the Polaris connector.3.
Apply Anti-Oxidant (Optional)
Apply a small amount of anti-oxidant compound to the stripped conductors (even with a Polaris connector, it can't hurt).4.
Insert Wires
Insert the wires fully into the Polaris connector ports.5.
Torque Set Screws
Use a torque wrench to tighten the set screws to the manufacturer's specified torque value.6.
Inspect
Visually inspect the connection to ensure the wires are securely held and the insulation is intact.7.
Close the Junction Box
Carefully arrange the wires in the junction box and close the cover securely.8.
Test
Turn on the breaker and test the EV charger to ensure it is functioning correctly.
In summary, while both options can work, the Polaris connector offers a more reliable, safer, and easier-to-install solution for your EV charger circuit repair. Focus on proper torque, quality materials, and careful inspection to ensure a long-lasting and trouble-free connection. Flag for review