Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Meter Socket SCCR

User: Juandsriv, Location: Costa Rica

Asked on: Sunday, November 24, 2024 at 1:10 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:37 am EST

Question: ¡Claro! Aquí tienes la traducción al inglés de tu consulta:Hello, greetings from Costa Rica. I'm always very grateful for the valuable contributions I get from this forum.I have a case with a meter socket that is located very close to the source, a 75 kVA transformer, 240 V, with an impedance of 2.2. The meter base is a UL-listed Milbank Class 200, and right downstream of it is a 200 A, 22 kA Square D breaker, also UL-listed in its respective cabinet.The problem is that the calculated short-circuit current at the meter base location is around 13,200 A, while the meter base has a 10 kA SCCR. I have seen on some Class 200 meters that there is a note stating that the base can withstand up to 18 kA when paired with a 200 A breaker. However, it does not specify the interrupting rating that the breaker should have, nor whether the breaker must be from the same manufacturer, or if there is a list of compatible breakers for this meter socket.In summary, I would like to know if it is indeed safe to use this base in this scenario, considering the short-circuit values I have.In that case, Could this be related to the passing energy limitation that the breaker offers when tripping in a maximum of one cycle, versus the three cycles of support that the meter socket has at 10 kA?Thank you in advance for your help!

This is a well-written and important question. Here's the English translation, followed by some considerations for addressing the problem

English Translation (same as above, for clarity):

Hello, greetings from Costa Rica. I'm always very grateful for the valuable contributions I get from this forum.I have a case with a meter socket that is located very close to the source, a 75 kVA transformer, 240 V, with an impedance of 2.2. The meter base is a UL-listed Milbank Class 200, and right downstream of it is a 200 A, 22 kA Square D breaker, also UL-listed in its respective cabinet.The problem is that the calculated short-circuit current at the meter base location is around 13,200 A, while the meter base has a 10 kA SCCR. I have seen on some Class 200 meters that there is a note stating that the base can withstand up to 18 kA when paired with a 200 A breaker. However, it does not specify the interrupting rating that the breaker should have, nor whether the breaker must be from the same manufacturer, or if there is a list of compatible breakers for this meter socket.In summary, I would like to know if it is indeed safe to use this base in this scenario, considering the short-circuit values I have.In that case, Could this be related to the passing energy limitation that the breaker offers when tripping in a maximum of one cycle, versus the three cycles of support that the meter socket has at 10 kA?Thank you in advance for your help!Considerations for Addressing the Problem

Here's a breakdown of the key issues and possible solutions:

Safety is paramount

The first priority is ensuring the installation is safe and complies with local electrical codes. Exceeding the SCCR of the meter base is a serious safety hazard.


Understanding SCCR and Series Ratings

The Short-Circuit Current Rating (SCCR) is the maximum fault current a component can safely withstand. A "series rating" involves coordinating two or more components (like a breaker and a meter base) so that the upstream device (usually a breaker) limits the fault current seen by the downstream device (the meter base). This allows the downstream device to have a lower SCCR than the available fault current.

Investigating the 18kA Rating

The note stating the meter base can withstand 18kA with a 200A breaker is crucial. You need to definitively determine
under what conditions this rating is valid. Here's how to do that:

Contact Milbank directly

This is the most important step. Provide them with the exact model number of the meter base. Ask for documentation or a letter specifying the conditions under which the 18kA SCCR applies. They should be able to tell you: The specific interrupting rating required for the 200A breaker. Whether a specific breaker manufacturer or model is required. If there's a published list of compatible breakers (or a "series rating" document).

Check Milbank's website

Look for detailed product specifications and installation instructions for the meter base. They may have downloadable documents or FAQs that address this issue.

Review the UL Listing

The UL listing for the meter base should be available online or through UL themselves. This may shed light on the testing and conditions under which the 18kA rating was established.


Potential Solutions if the 18kA Rating Doesn't Apply

If Milbank cannot confirm the 18kA rating with your specific breaker, you have a few options:

Replace the Meter Base

The simplest and often safest solution is to replace the meter base with one that has a higher SCCR (at least 13.2kA). Consider a meter base with a 22kA or higher rating.


Current Limiting Breaker

Use a current-limiting breaker upstream of the meter base. These breakers trip very quickly and reduce the peak fault current and the total energy (I²t) that the meter base is exposed to. You would need to carefully select the breaker to ensure its current-limiting characteristics reduce the fault current at the meter base to below 10kA (or 18kA, if confirmed by Milbank). Consult with a breaker manufacturer's application engineer for assistance.

Series-Rated Breaker

If your local codes permit, you could consider a series-rated breaker system. This involves using a higher-rated breaker upstream of the existing 200A, 22kA Square D breaker. The upstream breaker must be listed in series with the downstream breaker and meter base. This is a complex solution that requires careful coordination and documentation. Check with your local authorities to see if this is an acceptable solution.


Understanding Breaker Clearing Time (Your Question)

You're correct in considering the breaker's clearing time and its effect on the energy let-through.

I²t (Let-Through Energy)

The energy dissipated in a fault is proportional to the square of the current multiplied by the time (I²t). A faster-clearing breaker reduces I²t.


Current-Limiting Breakers are Key

Standard breakers may not clear the fault fast enough to protect the meter base, even if they have a high interrupting rating. Current-limiting breakers are specifically designed to minimize I²t.

Manufacturer Data is Critical

You need to consult the breaker manufacturer's data sheets (specifically, "Let-Through Curves") to determine how much current is let through during a fault. You need to ensure that the I²t let-through of the breaker is within the meter base's withstand capability.


Consideration of the Transformer Impedance

While your transformer's impedance (2.2) is given, make sure you've included the impedance of all conductors (wires, busbars) between the transformer and the meter base in your short-circuit current calculation. Even short lengths of conductor can add significant impedance and reduce the fault current. Double-check your calculations.*

Code Compliance

Ensure that all work is performed in accordance with your local electrical codes and regulations. Involve a licensed electrician and/or electrical engineer in the design and installation.

In Summary: The most important next steps are


Contact Milbank.
Get definitive documentation on the 18kA rating.2. Review your short-circuit calculations. Double-check all impedances.3. Consider replacement if necessary. A meter base with a higher SCCR is the simplest and often best solution.4. Consult with electrical professionals. Involve licensed electricians and/or electrical engineers.Good luck with your project. Electrical safety is paramount! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question