Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Welders & Article 630

User: Sparky2791, Location: Allentown, PA

Asked on: Sunday, November 24, 2024 at 5:17 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:37 am EST

Question: Looking for some back up on OCP & conductor calculations for a welder. Working on renovations to a welding lab. The new welders cut sheet shows the MIG welder @ 460V is 17.1A 60% Duty Cycle. Highlighted by me on page 4 of the cut sheet attached with this postI will not get the I1eff for the welder & this is a non motor generated welder. So…..Overcurrent17.1 x 200% = 34.2A - 35A is OCP size.Conductor17.1 x .78 = 13.338A…..#12 (20A) I am using 75deg. column since C/B/disconnect and receptacle will all be rated for 75deg. Although with #12 this does not matter.This also works with 630.12 (B) #12’s rated for 20A x 200% max = 40A Max C/B size permitted. Per above we are @ 35A.Design questionThe shop currently has a 277/480V switchboard with 60A C/B’s feeding existing welders. I would like to reuse these C/B’s to feed the disconnect switch (required per 630.13) with 40A time delay fuses in the disconnect switch. This disconnect switch would feed the welding receptacle.Any thoughts on this design consideration?Thanks for the replies

Okay, let's break down your calculations and design considerations for the welder circuit, focusing on NEC compliance and safety.

Analysis of Your Calculations Overcurrent Protection (OCP)

Your approach of multiplying the rated primary current (17.1A) by 200% is generally correct based on NEC 630.12(A). This allows for the inrush current common with welders. `17.1A 200% = 34.2A`. Rounding up to a 35A overcurrent device is a reasonable and code-compliant choice.

Conductor Sizing

Your calculation of the conductor ampacity based on the duty cycle is accurate: `17.1A 0.78 = 13.338A`. The 0.78 multiplier comes from Table 630.11(A) for a 60% duty cycle. Using #12 AWG conductors rated for 20A is sufficient and complies with the minimum ampacity requirement.

630.12(B) Check

You've correctly verified that your OCP device (35A) is below the maximum allowed by 630.12(B), which is 200% of the conductor ampacity (20A
200% = 40A).

Design Consideration: Reusing Existing 60A Circuit Breakers


This is where the design gets a little more involved, and where careful consideration of code rules is essential. NEC 630.13 Disconnect Switch

You are correct that a disconnecting means is required for the welder.


Upstream Protection (the existing 60A CB)

Here's the critical point. While you can protect the welder branch circuit with the 40A fuses inside your disconnect switch, the code doesn't allow you to ignore the overcurrent device ahead of that. The 60A breaker must also be considered. The concern is that a fault between the 60A breaker and the 40A fuses could damage the #12 conductors before either overcurrent device trips.

NEC 240.4(D)(3)

This is a crucial section. It specifically
prohibits you from using an overcurrent device larger than 20A to protect #12 AWG conductors (unless certain exceptions apply, which don't seem applicable here). The intent of this rule is to provide short circuit protection to the conductors. You will need to ensure that you are providing short circuit protection to the #12 AWG conductors downstream of the 60A C/B.

Solution

You could put a 20A fuse inside the disconnect switch and use the 60A C/B but this would likely lead to nuisance tripping.

Practical Considerations



Nuisance Tripping

Even with a properly sized overcurrent device (e.g., 35A), the existing 60A breaker could be more prone to nuisance tripping, especially during high-demand welding operations or if the breaker is old and its trip characteristics have drifted. However since we cannot use this size C/B due to the NEC, this point is moot.

Future Expansion

If you anticipate needing more power at this location in the future for larger welders, keeping the 60A capacity might be a benefit.

Recommendations and Solutions


Given the code constraints, here are the possible options:1. Replace the 60A Breaker with a 20A Breaker

This is the most code-compliant and safest approach. It ensures that your #12 conductors are properly protected against overcurrent and short circuits at all points in the circuit. You would then use the 20A time-delay fuses in the disconnect switch for welder overload protection.2.

Run Larger Conductors to the Receptacle

Replace the #12 conductors with a larger size (e.g., #10 AWG or #8 AWG) that can be protected by a 60A breaker. You would need to check the conductor ampacity tables in NEC Article 310 and derate for any applicable conditions (e.g., ambient temperature, number of conductors in a raceway). This allows you to keep the existing 60A breaker, but it will be a more expensive solution.3.

Install a New Dedicated Circuit

Run a new circuit with appropriately sized conductors and a breaker specifically sized for the welder. This is potentially the most robust solution, but it involves more work and material.

Summary
Your initial calculations for conductor sizing and overcurrent protection are correct, assuming the upstream protection is also appropriate. The primary issue is the existing 60A breaker and the NEC's limitations on protecting #12 AWG conductors with that large of an OCPD. Carefully consider the cost, effort, and future needs when deciding which solution to implement.

Important Considerations Local Amendments

Always check for any local amendments to the NEC that may be in effect in your jurisdiction.


Qualified Electrician

Have a qualified electrician perform the installation and verify that all work meets code requirements.*

Documentation:
Keep detailed records of all calculations, conductor sizes, and overcurrent device ratings for future reference and inspection purposes.I strongly recommend consulting with a licensed electrical contractor familiar with the NEC in your area to ensure that your design meets all applicable codes and is safe for operation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question