Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Article 250.64 (D) Multiple Disconnecting Means Seperate Enclosures

User: Bigbri0104, Location: New Jersey

Asked on: Sunday, November 24, 2024 at 10:46 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:38 am EST

Question: Hello Everyone,On a recent installation for a two-family dwelling 200-amp service upgrade. The job we were working on was flagged. The inspector is stating I need to install a grounding wire from each service disconnect enclosure to a common grounding electrode conductor. Our state NJ is on the 2020 NEC edition. The inspector cited article 250.64 section (D) (1) saying the grounding electrode tap shall extend to the inside or each disconnecting means enclosure. I've provided a picture of the installationThe installation of the grounding electrode conductor from the ground rods and the water bond is routed through 1/2 PVC and terminates onto a ground bar that is threw bolted in the wireway. From there a properly sized jumper/bonding wire terminates from the ground bar to the grounded (neutral) conductor via Ilsco tap in the wireway. Is this installation compliant with the grounding electrode conductor and water bond? If I'm reading the charging language correctly from 250.64 (D) it states the grounding electrode connections shall be made in accordance with 250.64 (D)(1), 250.64 (D)(2) or 250.64 (D)(3). Does the OR in that statement grant permission to use any of three methods (D) (1), (D) (2) or (D) (3)? If so then this installation would be compliant with 250.64 (D) (3) option (1) grounded service conductor,I have seen illustrations of this installation in the NEC Handbook.My goal is to understand if I'm interpreting the code correctly.Thanks

Okay, let's break down the situation and the relevant NEC articles, focusing on the 2020 NEC, which NJ is using.

Understanding the Inspector's Concern

The inspector's concern likely stems from a desire to ensure a robust and redundant grounding path for each service disconnect. He's interpreting 250.64(D)(1) as requiring a dedicated tap from the main grounding electrode conductor inside each disconnect enclosure, even if you have a common grounding point.

Analysis of Your Installation and NEC 250.64(D)

Here's a breakdown of your installation's compliance with 250.64(D): Your Description

You have a grounding electrode conductor (GEC) running from the ground rods and water bond to a ground bar in a wireway. From that ground bar, you're tapping to the neutral using an Ilsco connector.


NEC 250.64(D): Grounding Electrode Conductor Connection to Grounding Electrodes.
This section deals with how you connect the GEC to the electrodes and to the service equipment (neutral). The key is that either direct connections to the equipment or splicing is permitted under certain conditions. 250.64(D)(1) - (3) are all acceptable methods. The 'OR' is crucial. (D)(1) is what the inspector is citing

Requires the GEC to extend to
inside each disconnecting means enclosure. This would mean a separate tap running to each breaker box.

(D)(2) is the "single GEC" method

This involves running one GEC to the first disconnect, then tapping from that enclosure to the other disconnects. It is not your case

(D)(3): Common Grounding Electrode Conductor.
This is where your installation falls. (D)(3) permits tapping the GEC to a common busbar. This busbar MUST be connected to the grounded (neutral) service conductor. You are doing that. This common busbar must be located at or near the service.

Your Interpretation of the "OR" You are correct. The use of "OR" in the code language allows you to choose one of the methods (D)(1), (D)(2), or (D)(3). If you meet the requirements of any one of those, your installation is code-compliant, assuming all other grounding and bonding requirements are met.

Why Your Installation Likely Meets 250.64(D)(3)

Based on your description, your installation
appears to meet the requirements of 250.64(D)(3):1. Common Grounding Electrode Conductor

You have a single GEC from the electrodes to a ground bar.2.

Common Busbar

The ground bar in your wireway acts as the common busbar.3.

Connection to Grounded Conductor

You are bonding the ground bar to the grounded (neutral) service conductor using an Ilsco connector.4.

Location

The wireway is
presumably "at or near" the service equipment.

However, it's important to consider these points



Wireway Approval

Ensure the wireway is listed and suitable for use as a grounding/bonding conductor enclosure.

Physical Protection

Is the GEC adequately protected where it exits the PVC conduit and enters the wireway?


Sizing of Conductors

Ensure that the GEC and the tap to the neutral are properly sized according to NEC 250.66.

Torque Requirements

All connections must be properly tightened to the manufacturer's torque specifications.


Is the wireway truly 'at or near' the service?
This is somewhat subjective. Close proximity is requiredRecommendations to Resolve the Issue1. Documentation

Gather relevant documentation, including: Photos of your installation. The specific page in the NEC Handbook that illustrates the configuration you've used. Wireway listing information.2.

Communicate with the Inspector

Schedule a meeting with the inspector and politely explain your interpretation of 250.64(D) and how your installation complies with 250.64(D)(3). Provide the documentation.
3.


Highlight Key Arguments

Emphasize the "OR" in 250.64(D) allows for alternative methods. Demonstrate that your installation meets all requirements of 250.64(D)(3). Ensure the inspector understands the function of the ground bar as a common grounding point.

Important Considerations
Inspector's Authority

While you may be correct in your interpretation, the inspector has the final say on code compliance. Be respectful and try to work collaboratively.


Safety First

If the inspector remains unconvinced and requires the additional grounding electrode taps, it's often better to comply than to fight an extended battle. While you might believe your installation is compliant, adding the extra taps doesn't fundamentally compromise safety.

Alternative Interpretation

Sometimes, inspectors have differing interpretations, or there might be local amendments to the NEC. Understand the reasoning behind their interpretation.


Appeal Process:
If you strongly believe the inspector is incorrect and are unable to reach a resolution, you may have the option to appeal the decision to a higher authority within the inspection department.In conclusion, based on your description and understanding of the code, your installation appears to be compliant with 250.64(D)(3). However, it's essential to address the points mentioned above and communicate effectively with the inspector to resolve the issue. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question