Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Swapping Polarity on a CT - Metering Impact?

User: Lauren, Location: NH

Asked on: Monday, November 25, 2024 at 11:57 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:38 am EST

Question: I have a project where we installed a digital revenue meter (SEL-735) on a service entrance breaker, connected to a set of PTs (wye connected) and CTs (also wye connected). The power flow is from the utility to the load (no generation). The meter is currently reading positive kW. However, the customer is asking for the meter to read negative kW. There is no option to program this change in this specific meter, so a wiring change will be needed.I requested our contractor to swap the wiring directly on the meter to reverse the polarity of the CTs. However, I've received some pushback, stating that the power factor will be off due to this swap, and essentially putting the current 180 degrees apart from the voltage.I believe the swap will put both KVAR and KW into a negative quadrant, and thus creating an accurate PF, but I'd like some additional opinion if there is something that I'm missing in this analysis?

You are correct. Swapping the CT polarity at the meter terminals will result in negative kW readings, and the power factor will remain correct. Here's a breakdown of why, and why the contractor's initial concern is generally unfounded

Understanding the Problem
kW = V I cos(θ) Where: V is voltage I is current θ is the phase angle between voltage and current The meter calculates kW based on the voltage, current, and the cosine of the angle between them. A positive kW reading means power is flowing into the load. You want a negative kW reading to represent that same power flow, just with the sign flipped. The SEL-735 (and similar meters) uses the polarity of the CT signals to determine the direction of current flow and thus the sign of kW. Your customer wants negative kW to, presumably, align with their internal systems or preferences.

Why Swapping CT Polarity Works
CT Polarity Reversal

By swapping the CT leads at the meter (e.g., swapping the S1 and S2 leads for all three CTs), you are effectively inverting the measured current. Instead of seeing `+I`, the meter now sees `-I`.

kW Calculation Impact

Since `kW = V
(-I) cos(θ) = - (V I cos(θ))`, the kW reading becomes negative.

Power Factor Remains Correct

This is the crucial point. The power factor is determined by the angle between voltage and current (θ). Inverting the current also inverts the angle. Consider these two points: When kW is positive, the angle is from 0 to +90 degrees OR from 0 to -90 degrees (since cosine is positive in both these regions). When kW is negative, the angle is from +90 to +180 degrees OR from -90 to -180 degrees (since cosine is negative in both these regions).By inverting the direction of current flow, you are essentially inverting the angle of the current. If the initial angle was 30 degrees, you are now using -30 degrees in the meter's calculations. Because the cosine function is even (cos(x) = cos(-x)), the absolute value of the cosine does not change. As an example, say that the original angle between V and I was 30 degrees. The swapped CT wiring is telling the meter that the angle is now -30 degrees. However, the cosine of 30 degrees is the same as the cosine of -30 degrees (0.866).Essentially, swapping CT leads tells the meter to invert the measurement of current on each of the phases. This will result in the kW being negative while maintaining the same power factor as it was before.

Why the Contractor Might Be Concerned (And Why It's Likely Unfounded)
Misunderstanding of Phase Relationships

The contractor might be thinking that reversing the current leads introduces a
physical 180-degree phase shift between the voltage and current. This is incorrect. The actual phase relationship between voltage and current in the circuit remains unchanged. You are only manipulating the meter's interpretation of that relationship.

Legacy Metering Conventions

In older electromechanical meters, incorrect CT polarity could indeed mess up the power factor measurement. However, modern digital meters, like the SEL-735, are designed to handle CT polarity reversals correctly for the purpose of directional metering.

Potential for Errors if CT Burden is Exceeded

If the wiring changes significantly increase the burden (load) on the CTs, and if the CTs are already close to their saturation point, then there could be some degradation of accuracy, including the power factor measurement. However, simply swapping the leads at the meter terminals will not increase the CT burden.

What You Should Do
1. Confirm Meter Configuration

Double-check that the SEL-735 is configured correctly for the existing PT and CT ratios, and for the wiring configuration (Wye-Wye).2.

Explain to the Contractor

Explain the logic above to the contractor. Emphasize that the
physical phase relationship between voltage and current in the circuit does not change. You are only changing the meter's interpretation of the current direction.3.

Implement the CT Polarity Swap

Carefully and systematically swap the CT leads (S1 and S2) at the meter terminals for
all three phases.

Ensure the power system is de-energized before making any wiring changes.
4. Verify Operation

After the swap, carefully observe the meter readings:
kW should be negative. kVAR should also change sign (becoming negative if it was positive, and vice versa). Power factor should remain essentially the same (minor variations are possible due to meter resolution and slight changes in loading). Voltage and current readings should remain reasonable.5.

Document the Change

Clearly document the wiring change for future reference.

Important Cautions
Safety First

Always de-energize the equipment before making any wiring changes.

Accuracy Checks

If you are concerned about accuracy, consider a field calibration check of the meter after the wiring change. However, this is unlikely to be necessary.


Thorough Testing:
After making the changes, verify the readings under varying load conditions to ensure the meter is behaving as expected.By carefully implementing the CT polarity swap and verifying the operation, you should be able to achieve the desired negative kW readings without affecting the accuracy of the power factor measurement. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question