User: Cartoon1, Location: Florida
Asked on: Monday, November 25, 2024 at 1:45 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:38 am EST
Question: Hello. I have a long distance run to a equipment (exterior) that needs a 240V for input single phase. I'm running a 480V from the panel to a small 6KVA stepdown transformer near the equipment. This equipment draws 15Amps single phase at 240V. My understanding is the closest transformer to handle the load is a 5KVA transformer. I'm placing the transformer near the equipment after the long 480V run about (300Feet).Per Table 450.3(B):Primary: 5KVA / 480V = 13A * 1.25 = 13.02A. The closest breaker is a 15A breaker at the 480V panel.Secondary: 5KVA / 240V = 20.8A * 1.25 = 26.04A. I'm putting secondary disconnect switch rated (30A) with 25A fuse.Is my calculations okay? would it be better/permissible to change the breaker to 20A for primary? And do small transformers come with an integrated overload device?Thank you,
Let's break down your calculations and address your questions.
Analysis of Your Calculations and Choices Transformer Sizing
You're correct in choosing a transformer at least large enough to handle the load. A 5kVA transformer is the minimum necessary. However, a 6kVA transformer might be a better choice. I'll explain why later.
Primary Overcurrent Protection (480V Side)
Your initial calculation of 5kVA / 480V = 10.42A is correct. Table 450.3(B) allows you to use up to 125% of the rated primary current for overcurrent protection (OCPD) for transformers rated 600V or less on the primary side. This yields 10.42A 1.25 = 13.02A You've correctly rounded up to the next standard breaker size of 15A.
This is permissible. However
Going to a 20A breaker on the primary is also permissible and might be preferable (explained later).
Secondary Overcurrent Protection (240V Side)
Your calculation of 5kVA / 240V = 20.83A is correct. Applying the 125% rule, 20.83A 1.25 = 26.04A. Using a 30A disconnect switch with 25A fuses is permissible and a good choice. This protects the secondary conductors from overload.
Addressing Your Questions1. Is my calculation okay? Yes, your calculations are technically correct based on the minimum transformer size (5kVA). However, consider the points below regarding upsizing to 6kVA and using a 20A primary breaker.2. Would it be better/permissible to change the breaker to 20A for primary? Yes, it would be permissible and likely preferable to use a 20A breaker on the primary side, especially if you stick with the 5kVA transformer. Here's why: Inrush Current
Transformers draw a high inrush current when first energized. This inrush current can trip a breaker that is sized too close to the normal operating current. A 15A breaker might nuisance trip. A 20A breaker provides a larger margin for inrush.
Voltage Dip
If the transformer is loaded near its full capacity and the 480V source voltage fluctuates even a little, the 15A breaker on the primary could trip.
If you are using a 6kVA Transformer 6kVA / 480V = 12.5A 1.25 = 15.6A. A 20A is definitely permissible. 6kVA / 240V = 25A 1.25 = 31.25A. A 35A fuse can be used.
3. Do small transformers come with an integrated overload device? Typically, No. Most small, dry-type distribution transformers (like the ones you'd use for this application) do not have built-in overload protection. The overcurrent protection must be provided externally via fuses or a circuit breaker in the primary and secondary.
Recommendations1. Consider a 6kVA Transformer
While a 5kVA is just large enough, using a 6kVA transformer offers some advantages:
Headroom
It provides a small cushion against unexpected load increases or voltage fluctuations on the primary side.
Reduced Voltage Drop
Operating a transformer closer to its rated capacity can increase voltage drop. A 6kVA transformer will run cooler and maintain a more stable output voltage.
Inrush Current Margin
Larger transformers generally handle inrush current better.
Future Expansion
If there's any chance of adding a small additional load to this transformer in the future, the extra capacity of the 6kVA is beneficial.2.
Use a 20A Breaker on the Primary (480V) Side
Regardless of whether you stick with a 5kVA or go with a 6kVA transformer, a 20A breaker on the primary will give you a more robust and reliable installation. It provides extra tolerance for inrush and voltage fluctuations.3.
Confirm Transformer Impedance
The impedance of the transformer (expressed as a percentage) is important for calculating available fault current on the secondary side. Make sure you know the transformer's impedance when selecting the appropriate interrupting rating for your secondary disconnect switch/fuses.4.
Proper Wiring
Ensure you use appropriately sized wiring for the primary and secondary circuits, based on the ampacity requirements for each. Remember to consider voltage drop over the distance from the transformer to the equipment.
Summary of Recommended Changes Consider upsizing to a 6kVA transformer. Use a 20A breaker on the 480V primary side.* Continue to use the 30A disconnect with 25A fuses on the 240V secondary side (or possibly 35A if you chose 6kVA).
By implementing these changes, you'll have a more robust, reliable, and code-compliant installation. Remember to consult with a qualified electrician for the final installation and to ensure compliance with all applicable local codes and regulations. Flag for review