Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: UL 508a transformer and power supply sizing

User: AJElectric, Location: Iowa

Asked on: Monday, November 25, 2024 at 3:27 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:39 am EST

Question: New to 508a here in our shop. I know how to do basic load calculations, but I'm wondering if there are any requirements by UL for sizing these components for control wiring.Control Transformer - I can't find any sizing requirements (only circuit conductor sizing, bonding, and OCP requirements)As an example, currently working on a project where the sum of all 120VAC loads is about 850W; plus two devices nameplate 3.0A (but in reality they're just a timer & solenoids total 50W max); plus a 120V convenience outlet with 3A OCP.The loads are all controlled by a PLC and would never all operate at the same time. The max would be maybe 500W. I intend to use a 750VA transformer with 8A MEN fuse on the secondary, and 14AWG conductors on all secondary circuits. Would this meet UL 508A standards?Power supplies - 42.2.3 max 50% load unless it meets UL61010 etc. and then 42.2.3.2 sizing the overcurrent protection. This is all pretty clear that if the sum of all loads is above P.S. rating then you need OCP. Sounds like it would be OK to have qty. 50 of 10-watt relays and indicator lights on a 120W power supply, as long as there is proper OCP on the circuit(s).A similar but separate question - 49.2 wording "sum of all current ratings...that are able to be operated simultaneously..." does this mean mechanically interlocked to prevent running at the same time? Or hard-wired relay logic? Or is PLC control adequate?

Okay, let's break down the UL 508A considerations for your control panel design, addressing your questions about control transformers, power supplies, and simultaneous operation.

Control Transformer Sizing (and your specific example)



UL 508A Doesn't Explicitly Mandate VA Rating

You're right. UL 508A primarily focuses on proper overcurrent protection (OCP), conductor sizing, and bonding for the
secondary circuits of the control transformer. It doesn't dictate the minimum VA rating of the transformer itself.

The Implied Requirement: Prevent Overload

The unspoken rule is that the transformer must be adequately sized to handle the potential load connected to its secondary. UL's focus on OCP assumes you've chosen a transformer that won't be significantly overloaded by the connected devices. A grossly undersized transformer could lead to voltage drops, erratic operation, and potential overheating, creating a safety hazard, which UL is ultimately concerned with.

Your Example: 750VA Transformer Seems Adequate (with Caveats)



Worst-Case Load vs. Typical Load

You've identified a total connected load of 850W + 50W + 3A (approx 360W) = 1260W. However, you anticipate a maximum simultaneous load of 500W. This is KEY.

Inrush Current

This is the BIGGEST factor that UL doesn't explicitly address, but you MUST consider. Solenoids, small motors (even in the convenience outlet), and electronic devices often have a significant inrush current when energized. This inrush can be several times the steady-state current. The transformer must be able to handle this inrush without excessive voltage sag.


Transformer Regulation (Voltage Drop)

Transformers have a voltage regulation specification. This tells you how much the output voltage will drop under load. If your devices are sensitive to voltage fluctuations (PLCs usually aren't, but solenoids and timers might be), this is a factor.

Convenience Outlet

The convenience outlet with 3A OCP is a potential wildcard. While you hope nobody plugs in a high-draw appliance, the fact that it
could happen needs to be considered. The 3A OCP is protecting the branch circuit, not the transformer itself.

Your Proposed Design Assessment



750VA Transformer

At 120V, 750VA translates to roughly 6.25 Amps. If your
simultaneous, steady-state load is truly capped at 500W (around 4.2 Amps), this seems adequate if you can manage inrush current.

8A MEN Fuse

This should provide adequate protection for the transformer against overloads, but also needs to be rated to handle potential inrush current (slow blow fuse might be required)

14 AWG Conductors

14 AWG is rated for at least 15 Amps, so it's sufficient for an 8A overcurrent device and well above the 6.25 Amp max of the 750VA transformer.


Recommendation

Since you have a convenience outlet in the circuit, consider increasing the transformer size to 1000VA or more. If not, maybe a warning label indicating current limit on the receptacle would satisfy an inspector? Monitor the voltage on the secondary side under your maximum anticipated simultaneous load, including turning on the loads with the highest inrush current. If the voltage sags excessively (more than 5-10%), consider a larger transformer.

UL Inspector Perspective

An inspector will look at your transformer size, the connected load, the OCP, and the wire sizes. They'll primarily want to ensure that the wiring is adequately protected and that the transformer doesn't appear to be grossly undersized for the intended application.

Power Supplies and UL 508A



You're Correct

You have a good grasp of UL 508A section 42.2.3 and 42.
2.3.2. The key is: If the power supply doesn't meet the requirements of UL 61010-1 (or other relevant standards), you MUST limit the load to 50% of the power supply's rating or provide OCP to protect the power supply. If the power supply does meet UL 61010-1, you still need OCP sized according to 42.2.
3.2.


Your Example: 50 Relays/Indicators on 120W Power Supply

Perfectly acceptable
if you have appropriate OCP and the power supply meets UL 61010-1. The OCP protects the wiring and the power supply.

Simultaneous Operation (UL 508A 49.2)

This is a crucial point for cost optimization, and where PLC control can be used to its advantage.


"Sum of All Current Ratings...That Are Able to Be Operated Simultaneously..."
This is the key phrase. You don't have to size components based on the absolute worst-case scenario where everything is on at once if you can guarantee that certain combinations will never occur. Acceptable Methods to Prevent Simultaneous Operation



Mechanical Interlocks

This is the most robust method. If two contactors are mechanically interlocked, they cannot both be energized at the same time. UL accepts this without question.

Hard-Wired Relay Logic

This is also very reliable. If you use relays to prevent two devices from being energized simultaneously, UL generally accepts this. The logic must be robust and fail-safe (i.e., a single relay failure shouldn't allow both devices to operate).


PLC Control

Here's where it gets a bit nuanced. UL does accept PLC control as a means of preventing simultaneous operation, but with some considerations:

Software Integrity

The PLC program must be robust and well-documented. You need to demonstrate that the software logic
reliably prevents the simultaneous operation.

Fail-Safe Design

Consider what happens if the PLC fails. Will the outputs default to a safe state that prevents the conflicting devices from operating? You might need to add external relays to ensure this fail-safe behavior. Watchdog timers and error handling are important.

Documentation

Your control panel documentation should clearly explain how the PLC logic prevents simultaneous operation and include the relevant sections of the PLC program.


Potential for Human Error

Consider any human interface (HMI, etc.). Could a user override the PLC logic and force both devices on simultaneously? You might need to implement software interlocks and security measures to prevent this.

PLC Certification

If the PLC itself is UL-certified (e.g., listed under UL 508), this provides additional confidence in its reliability.


In summary,
PLC control is acceptable if it's implemented with a robust, well-documented, and fail-safe design. Inspector Perspective

An inspector will review your documentation and PLC program (or at least a high-level overview) to understand how simultaneous operation is prevented. They'll be looking for potential points of failure and whether the design is sufficiently robust.

Key Takeaways:
UL 508A is primarily concerned with safety. Focus on proper OCP, conductor sizing, and preventing hazards due to overload or short circuits. Inrush current is a critical factor in transformer sizing that is not explicitly addressed in UL 508A. Account for it! PLC control is acceptable for preventing simultaneous operation, but it requires a robust and fail-safe design. Document everything clearly.By carefully considering these factors, you can create a UL 508A-compliant control panel that is both safe and cost-effective. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question