User: Sparky2791, Location: Allentown, PA
Asked on: Monday, November 25, 2024 at 6:21 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:39 am EST
Question: I found an old thread (2013) that was closed on this which helped a little but thought I would bring it up for discussion.From my research of NFPA20 due to the by-pass handle required per NFPA20 10.5.3.2 on the controller the generator needs to be size for across the line starting. NFPA20 9.6.5 has explanatory paragraph A.9.6.5 which specifically states this. See attached snipWhen you have a 200HP fire pump that is not going to be a small generator. One of those worst case scenarios we need to plan for that would only happen if we did not. We've all been there.I understand the 15%VD requirement of NFPA20 9.4.1 does not apply when in manual bypass per 9.4.2 & 9.4.3 but you still need to demonstrate the gen set can start with the fire pump and any additional load it carries. 'Ignoring' the 15% VD is nice but in the end it will really help a whole lot. Ill be looking to work with a supplier to size it but wanted to see if anyone had any comments on this.IMO this requirement really sells the use of a diesel FP for those large HP pumps unless you can meet the NFPA requirements of a reliable source of power and get the AHJ to agree. Something I have done only 2 times in my 25 plus years doing this.Thanks for the replies!
You've hit on a critical and often overlooked aspect of fire pump system design with emergency generator backup. Your assessment of NFPA 20 and the implications for generator sizing are accurate. Let's break down the points and add some considerations
Your Points, Re-emphasized:
Bypass Handle and Across-the-Line Starting
NFPA 20, section 10.5.
3.2 mandates a bypass handle that allows the fire pump to be started manually, bypassing the controller's normal starting sequence. This is for emergencies where the controller might be malfunctioning.
Generator Sizing Implications
The bypass handle essentially forces across-the-line starting. A.9.6.5 clarifies this, stating that the generator must be sized to handle the inrush current of the fire pump motor during across-the-line starting. This starting method will create a huge amount of locked rotor amps (LRA).
Large Fire Pumps, Large Generators
As you pointed out, with larger fire pumps (like 200HP), the generator size becomes significantly larger to accommodate the inrush. This directly impacts cost and physical space requirements.
Voltage Drop Considerations
While NFPA 20 allows ignoring the 15% voltage drop limitation (9.4.1) in bypass (9.
4.2, 9.4.3), the generator must still be capable of starting the fire pump and carrying the entire load without collapsing. Simply ignoring the voltage drop doesn't mean the generator can't be overloaded. It just means a slightly lower initial voltage dip is acceptable.
Diesel Fire Pumps as a Solution
This situation makes dedicated diesel engine-driven fire pumps a more attractive option, especially for larger horsepower requirements. The elimination of the generator and its associated complexities, including sizing and maintenance, can be a significant advantage.
Reliable Power Source as an Alternative
You're also right that a truly reliable utility source can potentially negate the need for an emergency generator. However, as your experience demonstrates, getting AHJ approval for this can be exceptionally challenging, and for good reason. Utility power outages, even brief ones, are common enough to raise concerns about fire protection reliability.
Additional Considerations and Points for Discussion
Motor Starting Methods
While the bypass necessitates across-the-line starting, consider other starting methods when the pump is not in bypass (i.e., normal operation). Reduced voltage starters (soft starters, auto-transformers, part-winding starters) can significantly reduce the inrush current during normal operation.
NFPA 20 and Reduced Voltage Starting
NFPA 20 allows reduced voltage starters (see Section 9.6.2), but they must be bypassed when the manual bypass handle is engaged*. This is because the bypass is intended to be a failsafe mechanism, and the reduced voltage starter is a potential point of failure.2.
Generator Transient Performance
Don't just focus on steady-state generator capacity. Pay close attention to the generator's transient voltage dip and frequency dip specifications. These parameters describe how the generator responds to sudden load changes, like the fire pump starting. A generator with poor transient response might sag excessively, potentially causing problems with other connected loads.3.
Generator Sizing Software
Utilize generator sizing software (offered by manufacturers like Cummins, Caterpillar, etc.) to accurately model the fire pump starting and the overall load profile. These tools can often predict voltage and frequency dips and help you select an appropriately sized generator.4.
Coordination with the Fire Pump Controller Manufacturer
Communicate closely with the fire pump controller manufacturer. They can provide valuable information about the fire pump's starting characteristics (LRA, starting time), and they may have experience with generator compatibility.5.
Load Shedding
Consider load shedding strategies. Can non-essential loads be automatically disconnected when the fire pump starts to reduce the generator's burden? This can sometimes allow for a smaller generator.6.
AHJ Consultation
Engage the AHJ early in the design process. Discuss the generator sizing methodology, the load calculations, and the justification for any assumptions made. This can help avoid surprises and delays later on. Document everything and present the information clearly.7.
Testing
Conduct thorough testing during commissioning. Verify that the generator can start and run the fire pump under full load conditions without excessive voltage or frequency drop.8.
Code Interpretations
NFPA codes are often subject to interpretation. Keep an eye out for interpretations, tentative interim amendments (TIAs), and future editions of NFPA 20, as they may clarify or change these requirements.9.
UPS Systems Although most controllers are connected to a battery, some very large controllers or controllers with many connected devices may have a UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply) instead, in the event of a power failure.
In summary, you are correct in identifying the importance of accounting for across-the-line starting when sizing a generator for a fire pump system. The manual bypass provision in NFPA 20 effectively mandates this consideration. Careful planning, coordination with equipment manufacturers, and early engagement with the AHJ are crucial for a successful and compliant installation. Don't underestimate the impact of the fire pump's starting characteristics on the overall generator sizing requirements. Flag for review