User: SoonerEE, Location: Edmond, OK
Asked on: Monday, November 25, 2024 at 7:10 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:39 am EST
Question: I have a 480V, 3-phase triplex pump with a listed "Enclosed Industrial Control Panel" containing VFDs. The panel is marked with FLA = 88.8A. There is no MOCP marking, and panel does not have a "main" OCPD or disconnect (field wiring terminates to a power distribution block).Question 1 - How do we determine the upstream OCPD for this circuit? I have seen the suggestion that it be calculated based solely on the marked FLA with a 125% factor.88.8A * 1.25 = 111A, round up to 125A circuit breakerQuestion 2 - How do we size the circuit conductors to the panel? I have seen the suggestion that ampacity be calculated based solely on FLA with a 125% factor.88.8A * 1.25 =111A @ 75C -> #2 copper.Question 3 - The sizing rules in Article 409 depend heavily on knowing the individual loads downstream of the control panel. Is the intent of Article 409 to dig into the panel shop's design, categorize each load, and calculate OCPD and conductor size? Or does the panel shop take all of these calculations into account when determining the panel FLA, and we should not apply a 125% factor and size OCPD and conductor using the FLA value directly (i.e. 90A breaker and #3 conductor @75C)
Okay, let's break down the code requirements for sizing conductors and overcurrent protection for your industrial control panel with VFDs. You're right to be questioning this, as it involves several interacting sections of the NEC.
Key NEC Sections to Consider
Article 430
Motors, Motor Circuits, and Controllers
Article 409
Industrial Control Panels
Article 215
Feeders
Article 310
Conductors for General Wiring
Understanding the Interplay
The intent is not to completely reconstruct the panel shop's design and recalculate everything if the panel is properly listed and marked. The panel shop should have considered all downstream loads and the appropriate demand factors. However, the marked FLA on the panel is a critical starting point, and you do need to apply a 125% factor in some cases, depending on the specific application and continuous load.
Answer 1: Upstream OCPD (Overcurrent Protective Device) NEC 409.21
This section provides the rules for Overcurrent Protection for Industrial Control Panels. If the control panel does not have a marked MOCP, the upstream overcurrent protection is determined by 409.21(B).
NEC 409.21(B)
This is where you will find instructions for an industrial control panel that has not been marked with a MOCP.
NEC 409.21(B)(1)
The minimum circuit ampacity and maximum rating of overcurrent protective devices shall be based on the downstream load in accordance with parts II, III, and IV of Article 430. This includes calculating the branch-circuit, feeder, and short-circuit protection for each load downstream of the industrial control panel.
NEC 409.21(B)(2)
The calculated values, shall not exceed the FLA shown on the industrial control panel.Based on this information, you will need to perform a comprehensive load calculation of all equipment downstream of the control panel. You must size the conductors per Article 430 Part II and overcurrent protection per Article 430 Part III. If the calculated load is less than the FLA marked on the nameplate, then you would use the calculated load as the basis for sizing. If the calculated load is greater than the FLA marked on the nameplate, the FLA marked on the nameplate would become the maximum calculated load.
Important Note
If your pumps are considered "continuous duty" (operating for 3 hours or more), or if there are other significant continuous loads within the panel, then
you MUST factor those loads at 125% before doing any of these calculations per 215.2(A)(1). If all of your loads are non-continuous, then the 125% factor will not be required until you calculate the feeder.Here's a general outline:1. Identify each load (VFD, pump motor, control power transformer, etc.)2. Determine if any loads are continuous.
3. If there are continuous loads, multiply those load's current by 1.25 (125%).
4. Calculate the total load of the panel, using the full current value for any noncontinuous loads, and the 125% value of the continuous loads.5. If the calculated current load exceeds the FLA marked on the panel, you must use the panel FLA as the basis of your calculation.
6. Size the upstream overcurrent protective device based on this value, in accordance with Article 430 Part III.
Answer 2: Conductor Sizing NEC 409.21
This section provides the rules for conductor sizing for Industrial Control Panels. If the control panel does not have a marked MOCP, the upstream conductor sizing is determined by 409.21(A).
NEC 409.21(A)
This is where you will find instructions for an industrial control panel that has not been marked with a MOCP.
NEC 409.21(A)(1)
The minimum circuit ampacity shall be based on the downstream load in accordance with parts II, III, and IV of Article 430. This includes calculating the branch-circuit and feeder current for each load downstream of the industrial control panel.Based on this information, you will need to perform a comprehensive load calculation of all equipment downstream of the control panel. You must size the conductors per Article 430 Part II. If the calculated load is less than the FLA marked on the nameplate, then you would use the calculated load as the basis for sizing. If the calculated load is greater than the FLA marked on the nameplate, the FLA marked on the nameplate would become the maximum calculated load.
Important Note
If your pumps are considered "continuous duty" (operating for 3 hours or more), or if there are other significant continuous loads within the panel, then
you MUST factor those loads at 125% before doing any of these calculations per 215.2(A)(1). If all of your loads are non-continuous, then the 125% factor will not be required until you calculate the feeder.Here's a general outline:1. Identify each load (VFD, pump motor, control power transformer, etc.)2. Determine if any loads are continuous.
3. If there are continuous loads, multiply those load's current by 1.25 (125%).
4. Calculate the total load of the panel, using the full current value for any noncontinuous loads, and the 125% value of the continuous loads.5. If the calculated current load exceeds the FLA marked on the panel, you must use the panel FLA as the basis of your calculation.
6. Size the upstream feeder conductors based on this value, in accordance with Article 430 Part II.
Answer 3: Intent of Article 409 You're right to be concerned about the depth of analysis. Article 409 doesn't generally intend for you to completely reverse-engineer the panel design if the panel is properly listed and marked. Panel Shop's Responsibility
The panel shop should be doing all the necessary calculations, load classifications, demand factors, and component selection to arrive at the FLA and any MOCP markings. They're responsible for internal wiring within the panel.
Your Responsibility
You are responsible for sizing the upstream conductors and overcurrent protection based on the panel's markings and the type of load being served. You do need to understand if the loads are continuous or non-continuous to apply the appropriate 125% factors per 215.2(A)(1).
Key Takeaways1. Continuous vs. Non-Continuous
This is crucial. If the pump operates for 3 hours or more at a time, it's a continuous load.2.
Panel Markings
Rely on the listed FLA. Do not size conductors or OCPD smaller than what the marked FLA indicates.3.
MOCP
If there is a marked MOCP, use that value. If there isn't, you'll need to perform a detailed load calculation and size upstream protection based on Article 430, while ensuring it doesn't exceed the panel's FLA.4.
Consult the Panel Shop
If you have any doubts or uncertainties about the panel's design, demand factors, or intended use, contact the panel shop that built it. They are the best resource for understanding their design choices.5.
Local AHJ
Ultimately, the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) has the final say. It's a good idea to discuss your approach with them, especially on a complex installation like this.
Example Scenario (Assuming Continuous Load)
Let's assume the triplex pump is a continuous load.1. FLA
88.8A2.
Continuous Load Factor
88.8A 1.25 = 111A3.
Conductor Sizing
111A (minimum ampacity) -> #2 AWG copper THHN (at 75°C termination rating)4.
OCPD Sizing
111A. The maximum breaker size would be 125A (rounding up to the next standard size) however, a smaller breaker of 110A could also be used as long as it will start the pump without tripping.
Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and should not be used as a substitute for consulting with a qualified and licensed electrical engineer or electrician.* Always consult the NEC, local codes, and the manufacturer's instructions for the specific equipment. Flag for review