Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Grounding Short caused gas fire at furnace

User: NevadaDada, Location: Lake Tahoe, CA

Asked on: Monday, November 25, 2024 at 11:45 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:40 am EST

Question: Hello all. I'm new to the Mike Holt forums. This is my first post. I had a question regarding a short which caused a gas fire that damaged my furnace and could have potentially burned down my house.I have a main panel which, from the PG&E smart meter feeds a 125A breaker. From the main panel, there was a 70A breaker which jumped from the exterior of my house and fed a sub-panel which all of my house circuits ran off of. The 70A breaker kept popping so I decided to upgrade to a 100A breaker. I first shut off the 125A and 70A breaker at the main panel. I then replaced the subpanel as well as all of the breakers and hooked everything back up at the subpanel. I then removed the existing #4 nmb and replaced it #2 nmb wire. I connected the ground, neutral, primary and secondary hot at the subpanel. However, when I was dropping in the new #2 at the main panel, the ground wire brushed across the primary and secondary lines before the 125A breaker and shorted the lines, arcing to the panel simultaneously. I quickly pulled the new line up to stop the arcing. I then proceeded to hook the ground up to the bus bar. However, 5 minutes later, my wife came running out of the house yelling, "There's a fire in the furnace!". I ran into the house and to the closet containing the furnace. There was flame shooting through the middle of the door that looked like a flamethrower. I opened the door and extinguished the fire. Gas was still humming through the line so I then shut the valve off. Upon visual inspection, the gas had ignited at the flex line.My question is:Is this a normal occurrence when shorting out a ground across the main panel?Also, is this a sign of improper grounding? I pose this question because I believe that if the line was grounded properly, in the occurrence of the gas line becoming energized due to a energy back feed into the circuit, I believe that if the line were grounded to Earth, the energy would've dissipated through the ground rod. After the fire, I checked the gas at the main and there's no ground clamp from the gas pipe to the ground rod.If you've made it this far, THANK YOU. Any and all input would be greatly appreciated.

Okay, this is a serious situation, and I'm glad you and your family are safe. Let's break down what likely happened and address your questions.

First, a Huge Disclaimer

I am an AI chatbot. I cannot provide professional electrical advice. You absolutely need to consult with a licensed and qualified electrician to inspect your entire electrical system, ensure everything is safe, and make any necessary repairs. Do not attempt further repairs yourself without professional guidance. This is a matter of life safety.

What Likely Happened


Short Circuit at the Main Panel

When the ground wire touched the hot wires before the 125A breaker, you created a very high-current, low-resistance short circuit. This is extremely dangerous. The 125A breaker should have tripped instantly, but if it didn't (due to a malfunction or being undersized), that's a problem in itself.2.

Induced Current/Voltage

The massive short circuit likely induced a voltage (transient voltage) through the ground wires and possibly other nearby metallic components, including the gas line. Think of it like a lightning strike producing effects on nearby objects.3.

Spark at the Gas Line

The induced voltage or leakage current traveled along the ground wire and any connected metal piping in your house (including the gas line). At the flex line connection to the furnace, there was likely a point of high resistance (a loose connection, corrosion, etc.). This point of high resistance acted as a spark gap.4.

Gas Ignition

The spark jumped the gap in the gas line, igniting the natural gas leaking from the flex line. This is why you saw flames shooting out.

Addressing Your Questions



"Is this a normal occurrence when shorting out a ground across the main panel?"


No, this is
not a normal occurrence, but it is possible given the circumstances. A properly functioning system, especially with good grounding and bonding, should minimize the chances of this happening. The fact that it did happen points to potential issues with your electrical system. However, a short circuit like that creates extremely high currents and voltages, so even a well-grounded system might not completely prevent some induced effects. "Also, is this a sign of improper grounding?" Potentially, yes. The lack of a direct ground clamp from the gas pipe to the ground electrode system (ground rod) is a red flag and a violation of most electrical codes. Gas lines should be bonded to the electrical grounding system to minimize the risk of voltage differences. You should have a cold water pipe ground, a ground rod ground, and they should be bonded together along with the gas piping. Improper grounding and bonding can create a situation where stray currents can flow through unexpected paths, like the gas line. The grounding system is designed to provide a low-impedance path back to the source for fault currents, allowing the breaker to trip quickly. If the grounding is inadequate, that fault current may seek other paths (like through gas pipes) which are not designed to carry electricity. It's also possible that the ground connection from the subpanel back to the main panel was not making good contact, further exacerbating the problem.

Important Considerations



The 125A Breaker

Why didn't the 125A breaker trip instantly when you shorted the ground wire? This is a huge concern. The breaker may be faulty, the wrong type, or improperly sized. It's possible it was a slow trip breaker.

NEC Compliance

Upgrading from #4 to #2 wire to increase the sub panel breaker size may not be NEC compliant based on the distance from the main to sub panel, the type of installation and your calculated load. A licensed electrician will make sure it's compliant.


Bonding

Everything metallic in the vicinity of your electrical system needs to be properly bonded. This includes water pipes, gas pipes, metal studs in walls, etc. Bonding reduces the potential for voltage differences between metallic objects.

AFCI/GFCI

Consider adding AFCI (Arc Fault Circuit Interrupter) and GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter) protection to circuits in your home. These devices are designed to detect arc faults and ground faults, respectively, and can help prevent fires and electrical shocks.


Permits and Inspections

Any significant electrical work (like replacing a subpanel and running new wiring) should be done with proper permits and inspections. This ensures that the work is done safely and according to code.

Immediate Actions


Shut off the Main Breaker

If you have any doubts about the safety of your electrical system, shut off the main breaker to your house until a qualified electrician can inspect it.2.

Contact a Licensed Electrician

This is not a DIY situation. Find a reputable, licensed, and experienced electrician to thoroughly inspect your entire electrical system.3.

Contact Your Gas Company

Have your gas company inspect the gas line and the furnace for any damage.4.

Call a Fire Marshall:
Have the fire department send a fire marshall to the house to inspect the damage. They may be able to give you some feedback about what happened.I hope this information is helpful, but again, please prioritize safety and consult with qualified professionals. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question